Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 12:07     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:It seems silly to penalize the gymnasts for a “late” appeal (by 4 seconds?) if the facts are that Chiles’s routine was improperly scored and the Romanian gymnast did not in fact step out of bounds. How is it fair to ignore what actually happened and elevate procedure over facts.


It's dumb. It sounds like the core issue is them not wanting to take accountability for messing this event up. You can't can't prioritize procedure when you haven't been following the procedure in the first place. Regardless of the ending, this has completely stained the girls experience.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 11:45     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:Just share the bronze and move on. It’s not gold.


That’s why this isn’t a bigger issue. Only the athletes really care about a bronze.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 11:44     Subject: Re:Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:Now The U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee (USOPC) is appealing the decision by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) to strip Jordan Chiles bronze medal.


The Court of Arbitration for Sport did not make this decision. Their ruling was to restore Chiles' original score and leave the decision of what should be done about the medal to the IOC.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 11:43     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
It seems silly to penalize the gymnasts for a “late” appeal (by 4 seconds?) if the facts are that Chiles’s routine was improperly scored and the Romanian gymnast did not in fact step out of bounds. How is it fair to ignore what actually happened and elevate procedure over facts.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 11:25     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It’s the figure skating scandal again. Crooked judges.


+1 An overhaul is needed.


+2 Romanians were right and should receive the medal and Chiles should give it back.

My issue is that Romania and the US both acted within their rights to advocate for their athletes. FIG made at least two errors in their scoring. First they didn’t give Jordan credit she deserved, and then they accepted an inquiry outside the window they were allowed. It takes a lot of nerve to punish an athlete for the judges’ mistakes. There are cases to be made for any three of the athletes to receive the bronze, and the appeals will drag on. I’m in the camp that the IOC and FIG should acknowledge that THEY screwed up, and just issue medals to everyone.


Agreed.Thats why Romania wanted all three girls to get a bronze. Continuous mistakes were made by the judges to put them in this situation


+1 !!!
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 11:08     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It’s the figure skating scandal again. Crooked judges.


+1 An overhaul is needed.


+2 Romanians were right and should receive the medal and Chiles should give it back.

My issue is that Romania and the US both acted within their rights to advocate for their athletes. FIG made at least two errors in their scoring. First they didn’t give Jordan credit she deserved, and then they accepted an inquiry outside the window they were allowed. It takes a lot of nerve to punish an athlete for the judges’ mistakes. There are cases to be made for any three of the athletes to receive the bronze, and the appeals will drag on. I’m in the camp that the IOC and FIG should acknowledge that THEY screwed up, and just issue medals to everyone.


Agreed.Thats why Romania wanted all three girls to get a bronze. Continuous mistakes were made by the judges to put them in this situation
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 11:03     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:Just share the bronze and move on. It’s not gold.


+1 this is so absurd. They all want to share. Let them. These games are only held every 4 years. The judges should have done a better job.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:57     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It’s the figure skating scandal again. Crooked judges.


+1 An overhaul is needed.


+2 Romanians were right and should receive the medal and Chiles should give it back.

My issue is that Romania and the US both acted within their rights to advocate for their athletes. FIG made at least two errors in their scoring. First they didn’t give Jordan credit she deserved, and then they accepted an inquiry outside the window they were allowed. It takes a lot of nerve to punish an athlete for the judges’ mistakes. There are cases to be made for any three of the athletes to receive the bronze, and the appeals will drag on. I’m in the camp that the IOC and FIG should acknowledge that THEY screwed up, and just issue medals to everyone.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:50     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Just share the bronze and move on. It’s not gold.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:49     Subject: Re:Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:Now The U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee (USOPC) is appealing the decision by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) to strip Jordan Chiles bronze medal.


As they should!! The Romanians should appeal as well. All three should be sharing a bronze.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:47     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is it normal for them to not be able to appeal when there's proof they didn't step out of line?


What do you mean proof? It’s not like football where you can have the officials watch the replay. They are judging in real time.


And there is video evidence they were wrong


+1. Sabrina is in 4th place for an error she didnt make that's and there's video evidence
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:45     Subject: Re:Summer 2024 Olympics
Now The U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee (USOPC) is appealing the decision by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) to strip Jordan Chiles bronze medal.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:13     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is it normal for them to not be able to appeal when there's proof they didn't step out of line?


What do you mean proof? It’s not like football where you can have the officials watch the replay. They are judging in real time.


And there is video evidence they were wrong


So? That’s not how this works. The Romanians appealed the inquiry and got the outcome they wanted anyway.[/quote
They didn't get the exact outcome they wanted since they wanted Sabrina to have a metal as well. There's video evidence she didn't step out of bounds so it is unfair they refuse to look into it.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:11     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Bumping this because breakdancing happened. I was open to it but wow I cringed the whole time. What are the odds they pull it before the next Olympics?


It was so cringe. Not anywhere near a sport.




I’ve tried to breakdance, and have younger relatives who do it. The level of strength, balance and coordination which is required to do it at this level is enormous. It’s as much a sport as any other. I loved watching it.
Anonymous
Post 08/11/2024 10:09     Subject: Summer 2024 Olympics
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It’s the figure skating scandal again. Crooked judges.


+1 An overhaul is needed.


+2 Romanians were right and should receive the medal and Chiles should give it back.