Anonymous
07/16/2019 11:11
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:BDA people love throwing Pulisic name out their as their crowning achievement. Once you dig deeper you will find that the BDA did not cultivate him. The BDA has been around for 12 years. It's a failure. The USMNT is shameful. And who is behind it all? The USSF!
At least three FIFA world players of the year winners played High school soccer. The US darling of this World Cup, Rose Lavelle, played high school.
Do I believe that HS soccer made these players what they are? Nope. Do I believe that club soccer made them what they are? Nope.
Do I believe that BDA made Pulisic what he is? Nope.
Human development is so much deeper.
what this statement ignores is that our USMNT would be significantly worse without the BDA and the reason is that ECNL and every other league has all the problems of the DA PLUS less training, less coaching education, less referee education, more overload, and more crappy soccer competition in general. If the BDA didn't exist, none of USSF's numerous problems would magically be fixed. The BDA addresses some (albeit not nearly enough) of the problems associated with youth soccer in this country. The GDA will solve those same problems and for this reason is better than ECNL or any other league even if the DA is not anywhere near perfect.
Is the USMNT better because of the DA or because players are playing in professional academies now (mls)?
Why does it have to be mutually exclusive?
Anonymous
07/16/2019 11:09
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:BDA people love throwing Pulisic name out their as their crowning achievement. Once you dig deeper you will find that the BDA did not cultivate him. The BDA has been around for 12 years. It's a failure. The USMNT is shameful. And who is behind it all? The USSF!
At least three FIFA world players of the year winners played High school soccer. The US darling of this World Cup, Rose Lavelle, played high school.
Do I believe that HS soccer made these players what they are? Nope. Do I believe that club soccer made them what they are? Nope.
Do I believe that BDA made Pulisic what he is? Nope.
Human development is so much deeper.
what this statement ignores is that our USMNT would be significantly worse without the BDA and the reason is that ECNL and every other league has all the problems of the DA PLUS less training, less coaching education, less referee education, more overload, and more crappy soccer competition in general. If the BDA didn't exist, none of USSF's numerous problems would magically be fixed. The BDA addresses some (albeit not nearly enough) of the problems associated with youth soccer in this country. The GDA will solve those same problems and for this reason is better than ECNL or any other league even if the DA is not anywhere near perfect.
Is the USMNT better because of the DA or because players are playing in professional academies now (mls)?
Anonymous
07/16/2019 10:56
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:BDA people love throwing Pulisic name out their as their crowning achievement. Once you dig deeper you will find that the BDA did not cultivate him. The BDA has been around for 12 years. It's a failure. The USMNT is shameful. And who is behind it all? The USSF!
At least three FIFA world players of the year winners played High school soccer. The US darling of this World Cup, Rose Lavelle, played high school.
Do I believe that HS soccer made these players what they are? Nope. Do I believe that club soccer made them what they are? Nope.
Do I believe that BDA made Pulisic what he is? Nope.
Human development is so much deeper.
And yet some nations seem to be able to do better at human development than we do. We have a culture of individual achievement that likes to try and discount the role that society and systems have in the development of greatness. There are always circumstances outside of the individual's control that played a greater impact in the persons rise to greatness than we like to acknowledge.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 10:47
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:BDA people love throwing Pulisic name out their as their crowning achievement. Once you dig deeper you will find that the BDA did not cultivate him. The BDA has been around for 12 years. It's a failure. The USMNT is shameful. And who is behind it all? The USSF!
At least three FIFA world players of the year winners played High school soccer. The US darling of this World Cup, Rose Lavelle, played high school.
Do I believe that HS soccer made these players what they are? Nope. Do I believe that club soccer made them what they are? Nope.
Do I believe that BDA made Pulisic what he is? Nope.
Human development is so much deeper.
what this statement ignores is that our USMNT would be significantly worse without the BDA and the reason is that ECNL and every other league has all the problems of the DA PLUS less training, less coaching education, less referee education, more overload, and more crappy soccer competition in general. If the BDA didn't exist, none of USSF's numerous problems would magically be fixed. The BDA addresses some (albeit not nearly enough) of the problems associated with youth soccer in this country. The GDA will solve those same problems and for this reason is better than ECNL or any other league even if the DA is not anywhere near perfect.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 10:00
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:PDA is the real deal. Even if DA is better, the fact that PDA brought home multiple titles says enough. PDA is a super club.
https://www.soccerwire.com/news/ecnl-national-finals-conclude-with-u14-u17-title-matches-in-richmond-va/
PDA is one of those clubs that doesn't need a league. They went back to ECNL because they can charge for two ECNL teams and pull it off. It isn't about any ideological belief in this league versus that league. ECNL gave them two teams and a showcase to host. ANY club takes that deal 10 out of 10 times but not many clubs can demand that kind of a deal.
There are only 5 or so clubs in the nation with that kind of cache though the rest are just not that different than any other club.
They went back to ECNL because players wanted to play high school and the coaches didn’t like having tactics dictated to them from Chicago. The “back to ECNL to charge more money theory” makes no sense. Not every club is a money grubbing cash grab.
Actually financials did play into the decision to go back. PDA practices 2x a week and then charges extra for a 3rd practice so coaches can supplement their income. They just recently starting introducing some changes at the tail end of the Spring season. DA dictates 4x a week practice, granted not everyone does that. PDA’s coaches are contractors and not FT salaried employees of the club. PDA was in a place where they had to increase # of practices with DA but not increase fees. Coaches were training more but getting paid less and certainly not happy. Combined with being a founding member of ECNL, the same HS they so discreetly discouraged previously, they decided to go back to ECNL. And yes 2 teams to a founding member...they have pull.
+1
Of course financials played a big part. PDA wasn't losing players to competing ECNL clubs while they were in DA so that kids could play High School. ECNL and ECNL clubs are simply marketing High School as a point of distinction between the two leagues but PDA is PDA and as such the players will fall in line with the club whether they are happy or not. For PDA this was all about money and not some real firmly held ideology that HS Soccer is so important. There was heavy financial incentive for PDA to move back.
When Real Colorado and Top Hat tried to get the same deal this year as Michigan and PDA have they were turned down by ECNL so they went all in with DA instead. They wanted to field two teams and when they were not allowed to they simply left. Their decision was not based on ideology either regardless of what any boiler plate press release says.
None of it is based on ideology. It’s all money, power, and influence.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 09:58
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:BDA people love throwing Pulisic name out their as their crowning achievement. Once you dig deeper you will find that the BDA did not cultivate him. The BDA has been around for 12 years. It's a failure. The USMNT is shameful. And who is behind it all? The USSF!
At least three FIFA world players of the year winners played High school soccer. The US darling of this World Cup, Rose Lavelle, played high school.
Do I believe that HS soccer made these players what they are? Nope. Do I believe that club soccer made them what they are? Nope.
Do I believe that BDA made Pulisic what he is? Nope.
Human development is so much deeper.
I didn't mention a thing about BDA and Pulisic. This was about High School.
But, Pulisic and his age are really the first generation to have been exposed to BDA and are now coming through the system completely. Not Pulisic but his general cohort. But to say that Pulisic was not in DA is also misleading. He was and it was at a DA event that Dortmand scouted him.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 09:55
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:PDA is the real deal. Even if DA is better, the fact that PDA brought home multiple titles says enough. PDA is a super club.
https://www.soccerwire.com/news/ecnl-national-finals-conclude-with-u14-u17-title-matches-in-richmond-va/
PDA is one of those clubs that doesn't need a league. They went back to ECNL because they can charge for two ECNL teams and pull it off. It isn't about any ideological belief in this league versus that league. ECNL gave them two teams and a showcase to host. ANY club takes that deal 10 out of 10 times but not many clubs can demand that kind of a deal.
There are only 5 or so clubs in the nation with that kind of cache though the rest are just not that different than any other club.
They went back to ECNL because players wanted to play high school and the coaches didn’t like having tactics dictated to them from Chicago. The “back to ECNL to charge more money theory” makes no sense. Not every club is a money grubbing cash grab.
Actually financials did play into the decision to go back. PDA practices 2x a week and then charges extra for a 3rd practice so coaches can supplement their income. They just recently starting introducing some changes at the tail end of the Spring season. DA dictates 4x a week practice, granted not everyone does that. PDA’s coaches are contractors and not FT salaried employees of the club. PDA was in a place where they had to increase # of practices with DA but not increase fees. Coaches were training more but getting paid less and certainly not happy. Combined with being a founding member of ECNL, the same HS they so discreetly discouraged previously, they decided to go back to ECNL. And yes 2 teams to a founding member...they have pull.
+1
Of course financials played a big part. PDA wasn't losing players to competing ECNL clubs while they were in DA so that kids could play High School. ECNL and ECNL clubs are simply marketing High School as a point of distinction between the two leagues but PDA is PDA and as such the players will fall in line with the club whether they are happy or not. For PDA this was all about money and not some real firmly held ideology that HS Soccer is so important. There was heavy financial incentive for PDA to move back.
When Real Colorado and Top Hat tried to get the same deal this year as Michigan and PDA have they were turned down by ECNL so they went all in with DA instead. They wanted to field two teams and when they were not allowed to they simply left. Their decision was not based on ideology either regardless of what any boiler plate press release says.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 09:38
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
BDA people love throwing Pulisic name out their as their crowning achievement. Once you dig deeper you will find that the BDA did not cultivate him. The BDA has been around for 12 years. It's a failure. The USMNT is shameful. And who is behind it all? The USSF!
At least three FIFA world players of the year winners played High school soccer. The US darling of this World Cup, Rose Lavelle, played high school.
Do I believe that HS soccer made these players what they are? Nope. Do I believe that club soccer made them what they are? Nope.
Do I believe that BDA made Pulisic what he is? Nope.
Human development is so much deeper.
At least three FIFA world players of the year winners played High school soccer. The US darling of this World Cup, Rose Lavelle, played high school.
Do I believe that HS soccer made these players what they are? Nope. Do I believe that club soccer made them what they are? Nope.
Do I believe that BDA made Pulisic what he is? Nope.
Human development is so much deeper.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 09:19
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:PDA is the real deal. Even if DA is better, the fact that PDA brought home multiple titles says enough. PDA is a super club.
https://www.soccerwire.com/news/ecnl-national-finals-conclude-with-u14-u17-title-matches-in-richmond-va/
PDA is one of those clubs that doesn't need a league. They went back to ECNL because they can charge for two ECNL teams and pull it off. It isn't about any ideological belief in this league versus that league. ECNL gave them two teams and a showcase to host. ANY club takes that deal 10 out of 10 times but not many clubs can demand that kind of a deal.
There are only 5 or so clubs in the nation with that kind of cache though the rest are just not that different than any other club.
They went back to ECNL because players wanted to play high school and the coaches didn’t like having tactics dictated to them from Chicago. The “back to ECNL to charge more money theory” makes no sense. Not every club is a money grubbing cash grab.
Actually financials did play into the decision to go back. PDA practices 2x a week and then charges extra for a 3rd practice so coaches can supplement their income. They just recently starting introducing some changes at the tail end of the Spring season. DA dictates 4x a week practice, granted not everyone does that. PDA’s coaches are contractors and not FT salaried employees of the club. PDA was in a place where they had to increase # of practices with DA but not increase fees. Coaches were training more but getting paid less and certainly not happy. Combined with being a founding member of ECNL, the same HS they so discreetly discouraged previously, they decided to go back to ECNL. And yes 2 teams to a founding member...they have pull.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 08:31
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:Messi didnt play in the US "Development" Academy either.
However, he did receive steroid injections.
Maybe that's the answer.
Pulisic never played High School Soccer
Anonymous
07/16/2019 08:12
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Messi didnt play in the US "Development" Academy either.
However, he did receive steroid injections.
Maybe that's the answer.
However, he did receive steroid injections.
Maybe that's the answer.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 07:41
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:I can do this all day because they all mostly played HS.
In fact, I encourage you to look up the All-Met HS kids and see how they are doing in their recruiting process.
Messi never played High School soccer.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 07:41
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:I can do this all day because they all mostly played HS.
In fact, I encourage you to look up the All-Met HS kids and see how they are doing in their recruiting process.
Messi never played High School soccer.
Anonymous
07/16/2019 07:31
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
Anonymous wrote:I can do this all day because they all mostly played HS.
In fact, I encourage you to look up the All-Met HS kids and see how they are doing in their recruiting process.
Messi never played High School soccer.
Anonymous
07/15/2019 23:32
Subject: ECNL & DA Nationals Results
I can do this all day because they all mostly played HS.
In fact, I encourage you to look up the All-Met HS kids and see how they are doing in their recruiting process.
In fact, I encourage you to look up the All-Met HS kids and see how they are doing in their recruiting process.