Anonymous
09/26/2023 11:22
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
M&D defender to Villanova
Anonymous
09/26/2023 11:06
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Is it possible to just go, yeah- amazing job girls. The commitment and dedication to even be at this level is so impressive. Being a committed D1 athlete, top 20 or top 100, is an honor very few girls get. And regardless of top 20 lax or not, they all need to get jobs. I am embarrassed as a parent and an adult that a young woman who has worked her butt off to get an offer to…let’s say Clemson, saw that adults had an opinion on her academic and lacrosse choice. I mean, it’s not a”good school”. Shame on you. And yes, the girls look at this site esp during lax season when parents do nothing but talk crap about their school, coach and sometimes players.
And for the record, Ivy's give plenty of $ to athletes. Yes, not athletic, but the academic money is there and you don’t have to have opened a school in Rwanda and have a 5.0GPA. So, money does flow.
Most ivys no longer give merit.
No athletic and no merit at Ivies.
Merit is offered at ivies but the income threshold is very low.
That is not merit. That is need based.
I think this is a good point. The need based thresold is low, we typically think of HHI over 150K not getting AID but this is not the case based on my knowledge at Ivys, someone can correct me if I am wrong.
Also, can someone clarify. If you make too much for need based, couldn't you just have your adult kid be responsible for $$, therefore you should meet the need based easily?
If it were that easy don’t you think EVERYONE would do that? I mean come on.
Anonymous
09/26/2023 10:56
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Is it possible to just go, yeah- amazing job girls. The commitment and dedication to even be at this level is so impressive. Being a committed D1 athlete, top 20 or top 100, is an honor very few girls get. And regardless of top 20 lax or not, they all need to get jobs. I am embarrassed as a parent and an adult that a young woman who has worked her butt off to get an offer to…let’s say Clemson, saw that adults had an opinion on her academic and lacrosse choice. I mean, it’s not a”good school”. Shame on you. And yes, the girls look at this site esp during lax season when parents do nothing but talk crap about their school, coach and sometimes players.
And for the record, Ivy's give plenty of $ to athletes. Yes, not athletic, but the academic money is there and you don’t have to have opened a school in Rwanda and have a 5.0GPA. So, money does flow.
Most ivys no longer give merit.
No athletic and no merit at Ivies.
Merit is offered at ivies but the income threshold is very low.
That is not merit. That is need based.
I think this is a good point. The need based thresold is low, we typically think of HHI over 150K not getting AID but this is not the case based on my knowledge at Ivys, someone can correct me if I am wrong.
Also, can someone clarify. If you make too much for need based, couldn't you just have your adult kid be responsible for $$, therefore you should meet the need based easily?
Anonymous
09/26/2023 10:35
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Is it possible to just go, yeah- amazing job girls. The commitment and dedication to even be at this level is so impressive. Being a committed D1 athlete, top 20 or top 100, is an honor very few girls get. And regardless of top 20 lax or not, they all need to get jobs. I am embarrassed as a parent and an adult that a young woman who has worked her butt off to get an offer to…let’s say Clemson, saw that adults had an opinion on her academic and lacrosse choice. I mean, it’s not a”good school”. Shame on you. And yes, the girls look at this site esp during lax season when parents do nothing but talk crap about their school, coach and sometimes players.
And for the record, Ivy's give plenty of $ to athletes. Yes, not athletic, but the academic money is there and you don’t have to have opened a school in Rwanda and have a 5.0GPA. So, money does flow.
Most ivys no longer give merit.
No athletic and no merit at Ivies.
Merit is offered at ivies but the income threshold is very low.
That is not merit. That is need based.
Anonymous
09/26/2023 10:32
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote: Of UVA's current 31-player roster nearly 20 are from public schools. Two of UVA's five in-state players are from VA public schools.
Can’t argue with facts. Does not sound like any public school bias. Sounds like a bias toward great players.
Here are the facts: The one Virginia D1 school ranked higher than UVA, and with more recent success, is JMU. In recent years, it’s in state public school recruiting looks like this: Robinson 1, Riverside 1, Langley 2, Battlefield 1, Lake Braddock 1, Oakton 3, Woodson 1, Kettle Run 1, James Madison 1, Douglas Freeman 1. If these players were recruited to a perennial top 10 team that has a fairly recent national championship to its credit, you can’t credibly argue that UVA is equally active in looking for in state talent.
Again, JMU isn't UVA ... sorry she didn't get any love, but she'll still have fun.
Anonymous
09/26/2023 10:14
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote: Of UVA's current 31-player roster nearly 20 are from public schools. Two of UVA's five in-state players are from VA public schools.
Can’t argue with facts. Does not sound like any public school bias. Sounds like a bias toward great players.
Here are the facts: The one Virginia D1 school ranked higher than UVA, and with more recent success, is JMU. In recent years, it’s in state public school recruiting looks like this: Robinson 1, Riverside 1, Langley 2, Battlefield 1, Lake Braddock 1, Oakton 3, Woodson 1, Kettle Run 1, James Madison 1, Douglas Freeman 1. If these players were recruited to a perennial top 10 team that has a fairly recent national championship to its credit, you can’t credibly argue that UVA is equally active in looking for in state talent.
JMU had 9 players from the 2023 team that made 1st or 2nd team All Conf. None were in state VA kids. Teams are going to recruit where the talent is, period.
Anonymous
09/26/2023 09:42
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote: Of UVA's current 31-player roster nearly 20 are from public schools. Two of UVA's five in-state players are from VA public schools.
Can’t argue with facts. Does not sound like any public school bias. Sounds like a bias toward great players.
Here are the facts: The one Virginia D1 school ranked higher than UVA, and with more recent success, is JMU. In recent years, it’s in state public school recruiting looks like this: Robinson 1, Riverside 1, Langley 2, Battlefield 1, Lake Braddock 1, Oakton 3, Woodson 1, Kettle Run 1, James Madison 1, Douglas Freeman 1. If these players were recruited to a perennial top 10 team that has a fairly recent national championship to its credit, you can’t credibly argue that UVA is equally active in looking for in state talent.
Anonymous
09/25/2023 22:08
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:UVA is an elite academic school and there are certainly some talented lax players who can’t get in.
Not a lot of those on players Capital. These girls are generally pretty smart. Plus state schools have much lower standards for athletes. UVA is not like the Ivy league, Stanford, Duke, Hopkins, ND, NW, or other academically elite and T25 lacrosse schools that require wlax recruits to meet set academic standards. It’s very different than standard admissions. There are of course schools that are T25 who have both similar and lower standards than UVA.
Anonymous
09/25/2023 21:50
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
UVA is an elite academic school and there are certainly some talented lax players who can’t get in.
Anonymous
09/25/2023 21:23
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Well, if UVA was great at recruiting they probably wouldn’t be ranked way down at 18 in USA LAX’s Way Too Early rankings.
The fact UVA is a top 20 program would say they're excellent at recruiting. Why so mad? JMU isn't UVA but still a good school.
Anonymous
09/25/2023 21:00
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:They have a new coach...
UVA’s recruiting under the previous coach was tilted heavily towards out of state private school players. Numerous public school standouts couldn’t even get the coaches to look at their video or respond to emails. Hopefully, the new regime will be better.
Of UVA's current 31-player roster nearly 20 are from public schools. Two of UVA's five in-state players are from VA public schools. No top 20 contender (short of UMD possibly for obvious reasons) sources the majority of players from public schools in their home state. Player skill, rather than a misperceived anti-public school bias, better explains why someone didn't get any UVA love.
Some areas (Long Island) have very few private schools and public is typically the default. Others (CT) are so upper class, that the public schools are pseudo private schools.
Anonymous
09/25/2023 20:55
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Well, if UVA was great at recruiting they probably wouldn’t be ranked way down at 18 in USA LAX’s Way Too Early rankings.
Anonymous
09/25/2023 20:32
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Capital 25 Blue- Dartmouth
Is this the SJC girl? 😂
Sidwell
Anonymous
09/25/2023 20:28
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:They have a new coach...
UVA’s recruiting under the previous coach was tilted heavily towards out of state private school players. Numerous public school standouts couldn’t even get the coaches to look at their video or respond to emails. Hopefully, the new regime will be better.
Of UVA's current 31-player roster nearly 20 are from public schools. Two of UVA's five in-state players are from VA public schools. No top 20 contender (short of UMD possibly for obvious reasons) sources the majority of players from public schools in their home state. Player skill, rather than a misperceived anti-public school bias, better explains why someone didn't get any UVA love.
Can’t argue with facts. Does not sound like any public school bias. Sounds like a bias toward great players.
The Cap ‘25 blue team is filled with great players since it’s ranked #3 in country. And their commitment list bears this out. If those girls aren’t going to UVA to play it’s because they don’t want to. UVA is not the be-all end-all for most of these girls. They go to the camps of the schools they are interested in and I guarantee UVA would have loved to get one or two of them. Clearly the girls weren’t interested.
Anonymous
09/25/2023 20:06
Subject: 2025 Girls Commits
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:They have a new coach...
UVA’s recruiting under the previous coach was tilted heavily towards out of state private school players. Numerous public school standouts couldn’t even get the coaches to look at their video or respond to emails. Hopefully, the new regime will be better.
Of UVA's current 31-player roster nearly 20 are from public schools. Two of UVA's five in-state players are from VA public schools. No top 20 contender (short of UMD possibly for obvious reasons) sources the majority of players from public schools in their home state. Player skill, rather than a misperceived anti-public school bias, better explains why someone didn't get any UVA love.
Good analysis…