Anonymous wrote:You can't make blanket statements, OP.
My MIL is having a wonderful experience aging in place. She has several chronic conditions, including Parkinson's, and she thought this through years ago: she selected her caregivers herself and pays a rotation of them so that she's covered even if one of them has an emergency (and one of them did), and they all love her. They're not expensive compared to a home, the effort involved was in the *selection* of honest and caring folk.
When her medical needs force her into a specialized facility, she'll be miserable. But we're doing all we can to push that day into the future.
Does she have friends who visit? One of the things that was especially good for my parents (in a CCRC) and bad for my ILs (aging in place) is that the only people my ILs saw were caregivers and their family. My parents have a lot of friends, and just having a meal or going to a movie with their friends can be the highlight of their day.