Anonymous
Post 07/01/2019 14:05     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The other thing that no one has mentioned is that if you don’t get enough calories then your body goes into survival mode and reduces your metabolism bc it thinks you’re starving yourself.


Because that’s false. It’s honestly nuts the stuff that gets spread around here about nutrition and fitness. Cut carbs, you can tone in 4 weeks, it’s probably a bad thyroid. No no no.


but, I mean, if I'm not losing weight it must be because I'm not eating enough calories. I clearly need to eat more to lose weight


I eat 2700 calories a day, I bet my body is in starvation mode
Anonymous
Post 07/01/2019 13:54     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The other thing that no one has mentioned is that if you don’t get enough calories then your body goes into survival mode and reduces your metabolism bc it thinks you’re starving yourself.


Because that’s false. It’s honestly nuts the stuff that gets spread around here about nutrition and fitness. Cut carbs, you can tone in 4 weeks, it’s probably a bad thyroid. No no no.


but, I mean, if I'm not losing weight it must be because I'm not eating enough calories. I clearly need to eat more to lose weight
Anonymous
Post 07/01/2019 13:47     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:The other thing that no one has mentioned is that if you don’t get enough calories then your body goes into survival mode and reduces your metabolism bc it thinks you’re starving yourself.


Because that’s false. It’s honestly nuts the stuff that gets spread around here about nutrition and fitness. Cut carbs, you can tone in 4 weeks, it’s probably a bad thyroid. No no no.
Anonymous
Post 07/01/2019 09:25     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:The other thing that no one has mentioned is that if you don’t get enough calories then your body goes into survival mode and reduces your metabolism bc it thinks you’re starving yourself.


No, no it doesn't.

Starvation mode is a myth. Metabolism will slow a little, but it it negligible and not eating enough it NOT the reason you can't lose weight. I have found that people who restrict too much can't lose weight because they restrict too much a few days a week and that causes then to over eat the other days or they do well on their diet M-F and use that as an excuse to overeat on the weekend. So in the end their calories even out and they maintain their weight.
Anonymous
Post 06/28/2019 18:18     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
The other thing that no one has mentioned is that if you don’t get enough calories then your body goes into survival mode and reduces your metabolism bc it thinks you’re starving yourself.
Anonymous
Post 06/27/2019 09:42     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:Why is it so hard to believe that your caloric intake is too high? Another thread has a similar issue, there op is going to check her thyroid, here 10lbs are because of the pill. I was on the pill, it didn't add 10lbs. Maybe 2,3. The whole culture is messed up, always something else is to blame.


+1 Amen Sister!!

So many posts where people want to blame everything but diet for weight gain or inability to lose weight. i love the "I only eat 1000 cal a day and I'm gaining"- well guess what, you are fooling yourself if you really think you are only eating 900 cal/day. And yes, I lived in the denial for YEARS- had metabolism checked (it was fine), thyroid was high, but even once it was in a normal range with medication I still blamed my thyroid. Once I was honest and honestly tracked EVERYTHING that went into my mouth all of my "metabolism issues and hormonal" issues magically went away, go figure
Anonymous
Post 06/27/2019 06:22     Subject: Re:I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
1. Get off the pill. Get a nonhornonal iud
2. Fit in some exercise.
3. Get over food. It’s just food
4. Cut back on carbs
5. Weigh yourself daily. If you’re not losing weight after a few days then make more drastic cuts
Anonymous
Post 06/27/2019 05:33     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Why is it so hard to believe that your caloric intake is too high? Another thread has a similar issue, there op is going to check her thyroid, here 10lbs are because of the pill. I was on the pill, it didn't add 10lbs. Maybe 2,3. The whole culture is messed up, always something else is to blame.


I’m not blaming the pill so relax. I’m just saying that i hold a lot of water be of the pill. Jeez. I’m just saying the pill hasn’t helped in a good way when it’s comes to health


But it is not why you’ve gained 40 lbs and become obese. What we are telling you is you will never fix the real issue if you insist on pretending you gained 10 lbs from the pill. You will continue to be the person who overeats and then swears they can’t lose even though they ate 1000 calories for 3 months and have a busted metabolism. Your choices and actions led to your weight- not the pill, not a thyroid, not some imaginary metabolic issue. You basically take ownership of fixing this out of your hands when you pretend otherwise.


NP.

What a rude and unhelpful response. You haven’t walked in OP’s shoes. Maybe her body doesn’t react well to the chemical environment and all of the plastics and antibiotics and garbage we are swimming in at all times. Not everything has to be someone’s fault.


Omg now a 23 year old has gained weight because of plastic? She’s 23. Her whole life has been lived around plastic. She eats too much!
Anonymous
Post 06/27/2019 05:32     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Why is it so hard to believe that your caloric intake is too high? Another thread has a similar issue, there op is going to check her thyroid, here 10lbs are because of the pill. I was on the pill, it didn't add 10lbs. Maybe 2,3. The whole culture is messed up, always something else is to blame.


Thyroid issues are real. I had hyperthyroidism and lost 20 pounds in a few weeks. I had my thyroid killed off, so if my Synthroid dose is too low, I gain weight.

When I went off birth control, I lost 15 pounds in 6 months.

However, diet is normally the only way. I lost 25 pounds over a few months by cutting carbs, sugar, eating mostly vegetables and protein and avoiding drinking any calories. It wasn’t fun. I was hungry. I went to bed hungry. I looked great, but I was miserable. I loosened my diet up, accepted the 10 extra pounds, and I am much happier.

Menopause really made maintaining my weight very difficult.


They’re real but they are only the cause of unexplained weight issues for like 5-% of people. Most people gain weight because they’re eating too much. That’s it.
Anonymous
Post 06/27/2019 01:51     Subject: Re:I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds

Check out the ideal protein diet. I'm a much bigger person (and guy) but it works really well.
Anonymous
Post 06/26/2019 21:34     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:Why is it so hard to believe that your caloric intake is too high? Another thread has a similar issue, there op is going to check her thyroid, here 10lbs are because of the pill. I was on the pill, it didn't add 10lbs. Maybe 2,3. The whole culture is messed up, always something else is to blame.


Thyroid issues are real. I had hyperthyroidism and lost 20 pounds in a few weeks. I had my thyroid killed off, so if my Synthroid dose is too low, I gain weight.

When I went off birth control, I lost 15 pounds in 6 months.

However, diet is normally the only way. I lost 25 pounds over a few months by cutting carbs, sugar, eating mostly vegetables and protein and avoiding drinking any calories. It wasn’t fun. I was hungry. I went to bed hungry. I looked great, but I was miserable. I loosened my diet up, accepted the 10 extra pounds, and I am much happier.

Menopause really made maintaining my weight very difficult.
Anonymous
Post 06/26/2019 20:41     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Why is it so hard to believe that your caloric intake is too high? Another thread has a similar issue, there op is going to check her thyroid, here 10lbs are because of the pill. I was on the pill, it didn't add 10lbs. Maybe 2,3. The whole culture is messed up, always something else is to blame.


I’m not blaming the pill so relax. I’m just saying that i hold a lot of water be of the pill. Jeez. I’m just saying the pill hasn’t helped in a good way when it’s comes to health


But it is not why you’ve gained 40 lbs and become obese. What we are telling you is you will never fix the real issue if you insist on pretending you gained 10 lbs from the pill. You will continue to be the person who overeats and then swears they can’t lose even though they ate 1000 calories for 3 months and have a busted metabolism. Your choices and actions led to your weight- not the pill, not a thyroid, not some imaginary metabolic issue. You basically take ownership of fixing this out of your hands when you pretend otherwise.


NP.

What a rude and unhelpful response. You haven’t walked in OP’s shoes. Maybe her body doesn’t react well to the chemical environment and all of the plastics and antibiotics and garbage we are swimming in at all times. Not everything has to be someone’s fault.
Anonymous
Post 06/26/2019 20:23     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
I’m 5’1 just lost 40 lbs. it took 8 months of very serious dieting - 1200 calories. I tend to eat more when I work out a ton so I did very moderate excercise (walking) which was ok at that calorie count or a little more.

I’m 40 - it was a lot easier when I was younger!!
Anonymous
Post 06/26/2019 17:32     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
Anonymous wrote:I'm 5'2 and 43. I lost 30 pounds over the past 18 months, intentionally slow as it's a lifestyle change for me. First thing I did was tracking everything through myfitnesspal.com (free) and really focused on eating more healthy foods and upping water intake. Then I added in cardio 5x a week (gym at work). I'd like to lose a couple more pounds but I'm within healthy BMI range now. I've shifted from all cardio to a mix of cardio and weight training. I also really like the recipes on www.skinnytaste.com Made her fish Florentine for dinner and even my 2 & 5 year olds liked it.


Thank you so much for the advice! Really appreciate it. I started tracking my calories already but don’t really like the app
Anonymous
Post 06/26/2019 11:32     Subject: I’m 5’1 and need to lose 40 pounds
I'm 5'2 and 43. I lost 30 pounds over the past 18 months, intentionally slow as it's a lifestyle change for me. First thing I did was tracking everything through myfitnesspal.com (free) and really focused on eating more healthy foods and upping water intake. Then I added in cardio 5x a week (gym at work). I'd like to lose a couple more pounds but I'm within healthy BMI range now. I've shifted from all cardio to a mix of cardio and weight training. I also really like the recipes on www.skinnytaste.com Made her fish Florentine for dinner and even my 2 & 5 year olds liked it.