Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 21:08     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:Christian here. Anyone can have and enjoy a Christmas/Holiday Tree!

Go for it! Kids love them and they smell lovely. Enjoy! You have my blessing!



Jew here. If y’all want to have a menorah too, go for it! I recognize they’re not as fun, but just wanted to make sure we have it on the record.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 21:07     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:18:52 here

Bear in mind that you'd be engaging in pagan practices with Christmas tree.


And? Bring it on! It’s fun!
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 21:00     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
18:52 here

Bear in mind that you'd be engaging in pagan practices with Christmas tree.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:56     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Christian here. Anyone can have and enjoy a Christmas/Holiday Tree!

Go for it! Kids love them and they smell lovely. Enjoy! You have my blessing!

Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:53     Subject: Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It is not a holiday tree. No.


THIS


You don't get to decide what other people call their decorations.


Exactly. If I want to put a tree in my house in December and put crap on it, you don’t get to say I can’t call it a holiday tree or a cookie tree or whatever the heck else. It’s my tree dammit!

Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:51     Subject: Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It is not a holiday tree. No.


THIS


You don't get to decide what other people call their decorations.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:51     Subject: Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:So WASPs get yelled out for culturally appropriating anything, anytime ever...but Jews can go ahead and appropriate a part of a religious holiday they don't celebrate, and it's all good?

Got it.


Yeah, poor you...
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:50     Subject: Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:So WASPs get yelled out for culturally appropriating anything, anytime ever...but Jews can go ahead and appropriate a part of a religious holiday they don't celebrate, and it's all good?

Got it.


So glad you understand! Thank!
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:50     Subject: Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:So WASPs get yelled out for culturally appropriating anything, anytime ever...but Jews can go ahead and appropriate a part of a religious holiday they don't celebrate, and it's all good?

Got it.


Appropriating and assimilating are two different things.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:48     Subject: Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
So WASPs get yelled out for culturally appropriating anything, anytime ever...but Jews can go ahead and appropriate a part of a religious holiday they don't celebrate, and it's all good?

Got it.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:48     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:Christian here - Christmas has nothing to do with Jesus and Christianity. It is an ancient Roman holiday called Saturnalia that the medieval church merged into its celebrations because people needed some cheer during long and dark winter months.
As a Christian I have nothing to do with commercial Christmas or Christmas at all but recognize that it brings joy to many people.
Now, when it comes to Passover time and Jesus's resurrection, I strictly follow those observances.


Exactly! Historians believe Jesus wasn’t even born in the winter months. So really we’re all celebrating some combination of Saturnalia with pagan and Christian traditions thrown in. If someone wants a tree with lights and ornaments, who cares?
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 20:44     Subject: Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:I think there are a lot of you. I'm jewish and I'm not going to celebrate christmas. Period, full stop. Seems sacrilegious to me.

I'm with you.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 18:52     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Christian here - Christmas has nothing to do with Jesus and Christianity. It is an ancient Roman holiday called Saturnalia that the medieval church merged into its celebrations because people needed some cheer during long and dark winter months.
As a Christian I have nothing to do with commercial Christmas or Christmas at all but recognize that it brings joy to many people.
Now, when it comes to Passover time and Jesus's resurrection, I strictly follow those observances.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 18:40     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So on DCUM it's OK for one religion to use the unique aspects of another, but you can't wear a sumo outfit on Halloween unless you're Asian? So cultural appropriation is much more of a grey area here.


Let me ask: okay, any Christians have a problem with this Jew getting a pine tree and putting lights on it?

No, not at all. I don't see a problem with Jewish families having an evergreen tree in their house for the holidays. I actually love the idea! Christmas is about love, family, and celebration. If a Jewish family wants a tree, then that is their business. I'm Catholic and I put up Hanukah decorations in my house.

Sending peace, love, & joy your way! Have fun with your family and enjoy your tree. Don't listen to the haters.
Anonymous
Post 10/18/2018 18:32     Subject: Re:Jews with Christmas/Holiday trees
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So on DCUM it's OK for one religion to use the unique aspects of another, but you can't wear a sumo outfit on Halloween unless you're Asian? So cultural appropriation is much more of a grey area here.


Let me ask: okay, any Christians have a problem with this Jew getting a pine tree and putting lights on it?


As in around December and placing said tree within your house? Yep, sure do.