Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My K girl weighs 54 lbs! She's extremely tall and athletic - no fat on her ... bmi is still healthy

How is that possible? How tall is she?

Totally possible! I was the tallest girl in my kindergarten class, and I remember weighing 50 pounds. As an adult, I am 5'9" and 127 pounds.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:62 pounds. Not sure how that happened as he doesn't eat a lot of sweets and is very picky.

How tall is he? Depending on his height &, to a lesser degree, his build he may be just as skinny (or skinnier) at 63" as some of these other PP's kids are at 49 lbs (or whatever).

^ 63 lbs, not 63"

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My super skinny weighs 57 pounds

My super skinny 5th grader ds weighs 62 pounds and is healthy. I'd say your kid is doing just fine.

There's no way for you to know whether or not the first PP's kid's weight is "fine" without knowing his height & historical growth curve. The fact that he weighs more than your 6th grader -- who has a completely different genetic make up -- is irrelevant.

Anonymous wrote:62 pounds. Not sure how that happened as he doesn't eat a lot of sweets and is very picky.

How tall is he? Depending on his height &, to a lesser degree, his build he may be just as skinny (or skinnier) at 63" as some of these other PP's kids are at 49 lbs (or whatever).

Anonymous wrote:54'', 65lb

Same for my oldest at that age.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My 8 y old is 56" and 80 lbs. my 5 y old is 47" and 50 lbs!

Are you worried about their weight?

Why should she be?

Because they are obese.

50lbs is obese for a 47" child?? It's perfect - absolutely proportional. I can't quite visualize 80lbs on 56" but it doesn't ring as obese. Man, what a jerk.

Seriously. My K boy about to be 6 is also 47" and 49 pounds. He's really th

A kid who is 56" (4'8") & 80lbs isn't even overweight, never mind obese. 80lbs is probably quite a bit more than most third graders weigh but this kid is also quite a bit taller than most third graders.

76 pounds the other day at the doctor, 56 inches (I think lol) He is average height and skinny but muscular. Hope that helps OP!!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My 8 y old is 56" and 80 lbs. my 5 y old is 47" and 50 lbs!

Are you worried about their weight?

Why should she be?

Because they are obese.

50lbs is obese for a 47" child?? It's perfect - absolutely proportional. I can't quite visualize 80lbs on 56" but it doesn't ring as obese. Man, what a jerk.

Seriously. My K boy about to be 6 is also 47" and 49 pounds. He's really th

Darn iPhone! He's really thin but muscular. Insanely so we think but he loves sports and spends all his free time outside playing them. Definitely not obese!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My 8 y old is 56" and 80 lbs. my 5 y old is 47" and 50 lbs!

Are you worried about their weight?

Why should she be?

Because they are obese.

50lbs is obese for a 47" child?? It's perfect - absolutely proportional. I can't quite visualize 80lbs on 56" but it doesn't ring as obese. Man, what a jerk.

Seriously. My K boy about to be 6 is also 47" and 49 pounds. He's really th

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My 8 y old is 56" and 80 lbs. my 5 y old is 47" and 50 lbs!

Are you worried about their weight?

Why should she be?

Because they are obese.

50lbs is obese for a 47" child?? It's perfect - absolutely proportional. I can't quite visualize 80lbs on 56" but it doesn't ring as obese. Man, what a jerk.

73 pounds and 56 inches.

Mine is a girl, but she is SUPER skinny and 73 pounds. She is tall and has an enormous head. Weight is pretty meaningless in the abstract.

DC1 was around 70 lbs at 5 ft tall. He's 5'2 now and 74 lbs as a 4th grader. He's very tall and thin.

56", 69 lbs.

54'', 65lb