Anonymous
Post 10/29/2016 07:35     Subject: How can I teach my child words have beginning sounds.
Anonymous wrote:How about D is for...Dafuq?

Ha! This is the best!
Anonymous
Post 10/28/2016 23:08     Subject: How can I teach my child words have beginning sounds.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:My 3.5 year knows all his letters and letter sounds. He can spell his name and even spell some other sight words. He can not name me words that sorts with a specific letter. I could ask to name me words that starts with S and he will say snake only because that's the picture that goes with S on his puzzles, he can not name anything else that starts with S even though he knows the sound.


Remedial reading teacher again.

Generating words that begin with a sound is not a skill that is needed for reading or writing. All they need to do to read is to know letter sounds, and be able to blend them together to make a word. For writing, they need to know letter sounds, and how to segment the whole word into each sound.

"Give me 5 words that start with the sound /s/" requires a lot of complicated skills and they aren't necessarily required for reading and writing, but they might be required to complete some reading and writing worksheets or activities he might be given in class.

1) search through memory to find a word, say the word, segment at least the first sound, and compare it to the sound /s/

or


2) say /s/ out loud and then search your memory banks for some words it could start.


It might be a lot easier on your child if you give him 10 possible words, and have him pick the ones that start with /s/.


You are describing a sequence of learning to read that is pretty specific for older readers who have very different cognitive skills from a 3.5 year old.

Totally not relevant here, and harmful to suggest.


I'm unclear what you are referring to. In the post you are responding to, I describe some skills that are necessary for what I say is a task that is NOT NECESSARY for reading (the task of identifying words that start with the letter s or sound /s/. I don't know why OP is concerned about her child being able to accomplish this task, but if she does, that's on her -- and I think it would be easier to have her child do it a different way.

My earlier post outlined a way to teach kids beginning sounds of key words and link them to a letter. This can start as early as age 3. It is not harmful to try these as early as age 3 and a half, if it is done in a low key way, but if a child isn't able to do it easily I would wait until age 4 or 5. Yes, if you force a child who isn't able to do these activities to do them, and yell at them because they suck at the tasks, it will be harmful.