We've been at Cap City for several years--started in PK4 and now in second grade. We haven't played the lottery since we entered, and we only put this school on our list when it was time to try to get our youngest into PK3. He's there now, too. We're very happy and feel lucky.
We've had excellent, caring teachers. The teachers think through their pedagogy. When we visited other schools, sometimes the Montesorri or other approaches seemed more in name only than actual practice. The expeditionary learning approach pulls in different disciplines. To speak back to the above grumpy poster, my daughter studied bees and learned not just about that topic, but about biology, geography, poetry. There's close attention to the literacy of reading and writing and of math, too. It's a rich curriculum. She learned basics of research that some students aren't learning until much later grades. They did a musical performance in which the characters were bees. All of this has paid off in a child who, through this experience of coming to a subject from many different angles, loves learning and is academically curious on her own steam, not just because work is school-assigned. The second grade has been even better, with a rock-star teacher taking them to Rock Creek Park to do field research, complete with field journals, instructing them to work as practicing scientists.
The teachers think work hard to meet each kid at each developmental stage. The elementary school is very diverse--one of the most diverse schools out there, in fact--not just by race but also by class, ethnicity, and nationality.
Will we stay past elementary school? I can't say definitively. We're taking it year by year and will see.
Test scores: They parsed those out when there was a drop after the move, and the kids who had been in the school longer did better than those who joined once the school moved. Take that for what it's worth. But my bigger sense is that this school explicitly isn't teaching to the test--or hasn't been. My bigger worry is that they'll start doing so. The expeditionary learning model doesn't map exactly onto the ways that the former tests assessed, and so I think some of that preparation is about sitting kids down to learn how to fill out bubbles and multiple choice tests that are different from the ways they're being taught to explore, question, and answer. I also can't imagine comparing across the board--the population is so different. Cap City seems very welcoming to English-as-a-second-language students and their families, for example, but that population isn't going to test as well on an English-based test as in a school where almost all students are native speakers. That's not to say I'm not paying attention to those scores, because they are a kind of barometer about literacy and the levels the teachers need to meet, raising questions about what happens when the kids get older and the ability ranges and knowledge are so diverse that it becomes harder to accomplish differentiated learning in the classroom.
Aftercare has been rocky in recent years, but especially for the littles, now, it's quite good. And they've added in meaningful clubs and activities for the elementary school kids that work in tandem with aftercare and offer options after school. Aftercare is run by a long-time Cap City staffer. For the Preschool, preK-ers, it's play-based, and the kids are often playing in centers or doing crafts when I come to pick my youngest up. His aftercare teachers are sweet and caring, and they've clearly started to do some training, as the aftercare teachers echo the methods and language of the daytime school culture.
The facilities are great--playing fields, playgrounds both for the preschool kids and for the elementary. The library is beautiful and thoughtfully run. The gym is also nice (looks pretty much like any good HS gym to me). There's also a stage and performance space that they'll eventually refurbish, but that's going to take lots of money. Facilities are the big win from the move, and to us help make the commute worth it, versus the cramped and not entirely safe play spaces we saw at other schools further in town.
Hope that helps. It's well worth checking into. I can't imagine being serious about seeking out a good education here in DC and not putting it on a lottery list.