OP, my experience is that if you're hypo weight loss is just not that easy, but it was very hard for me when I was not medicated--mostly because I was so damn tired and because I could barely build muscle, etc. Have been on thyroid meds for nearly 15 years and after the first 2 or 3, I have maintained a normal, healthy weight, even after having a child. I can't eat whatever I want--am quite conscious without being punitive-- and I do exercise as much as I can, and I will never be skinny, but I finally found a good normal range which allows me to eat like a normal (if healthy, weight conscious) person and maintain a normal, healthy BMI (around 21).