Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 19:29     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I love the Boston Cream Cake from Wegmans


Meh.

Clearly OP wants something better than a grocery store cake.


Wegman's is pretty divine though. It has to be said.

OP, can you order a wedding cake in the flavors you want?
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 19:26     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
Anonymous wrote:OP did you get a cake yet? I like the Fresh Cream cakes from Shilla Bakery.


I love the honeydew melon cake from there.
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 19:24     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
Anonymous wrote:I love the Boston Cream Cake from Wegmans


Meh.

Clearly OP wants something better than a grocery store cake.
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 19:21     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
Bread and Chocolate has a nice chocolate raspberry cake.

I also really like the caramel cake from Caroline's cakes, and the Chantilly cake with strawberries from Whole Foods.
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 19:20     Subject: Re:What cake should I get for my birthday???
Anonymous wrote:Costco has a pistachio cheesecake. Sadly I am the only one who likes pistachios. It’s impossible to finish a Costco sized cheesecake without have a lot of people to eat it.


You are not the only person who likes pistachios. If you post your address here I will come help you eat it. It will be a community service!
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 19:12     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
cherry walnut
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 11:31     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
OP did you get a cake yet? I like the Fresh Cream cakes from Shilla Bakery.
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 10:43     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
Anonymous wrote:La madeleine coconut cream cake


Ahh I should have mentioned I also don’t really like coconut. I don’t hate it, but wouldn’t want it in a cake. La madeleine used to have a crème brulee cheesecake that was one of the best desserts I have ever had though.
Anonymous
Post 05/23/2026 10:42     Subject: Re:What cake should I get for my birthday???
Anonymous wrote:Costco has a pistachio cheesecake. Sadly I am the only one who likes pistachios. It’s impossible to finish a Costco sized cheesecake without have a lot of people to eat it.


Op here, I actually looked for this and it doesn’t seem my local costco has this yet. Luckily we do have a few people in the family that like pistachios. That being said, i’ve been known to freeze individual slices of cake/pie.
Anonymous
Post 05/22/2026 22:45     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
How’s Gerard’s in Oxen Hill these days?
I heard he was aiming to retire?
Anonymous
Post 05/19/2026 00:34     Subject: Re:What cake should I get for my birthday???
Costco has a pistachio cheesecake. Sadly I am the only one who likes pistachios. It’s impossible to finish a Costco sized cheesecake without have a lot of people to eat it.
Anonymous
Post 05/19/2026 00:25     Subject: What cake should I get for my birthday???
La madeleine coconut cream cake
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2026 14:51     Subject: Re:What cake should I get for my birthday???
Prantal's Almond Tort - buy it on Goldbelly. You won't be disappointed.
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2026 12:40     Subject: Re:What cake should I get for my birthday???
Anonymous wrote:Have real cannoli from Brooklyn sent to you via Goldbelly.


Cannoli has to be eaten right away. If it comes filled it will be soggy and disappointing.