Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 13:07     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:I would be doubting spending thousands of dollars on a club that can't keep the names straight for just two teams worth of u-littles.


Hah! Didn't even think of that angle. This club is the main game in our smallish town. It's not the best club in town, but it's the popular one because it's known to be friendlier, cheaper, and they practice 3 min from our kids school. So the only kids who play other clubs are the rock stars, and usually not until U12 or so when certain kids / parents get more serious about things.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 13:04     Subject: Re:Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Ok, mystery solved- there was indeed a name mix up. Jack #2, the much better player, was mysteriously added to the A team roster to make the team one player larger. Jack #2 previously had been on no team- I was surprised he had gotten cut and assumed he went to play for a different club, but apparently they mixed up the Jacks when sending emails. What a mess. They rightfully do not want to break Jack 1's (parent's) heart by rescinding his offer so they're just letting him stay, which may not be the kinder thing in the long run considering this kid has zero interest or ability in playing hours and hours of travel soccer every week, but at least it will keep his well connected parents from feeling the embarassment of someone else's mistake. Since it was in no way their fault.

I feel better about soccer politics in our town!!! I knew there were politics and always would be. But this was so out of left field to put this sweet kid on a travel soccer A team when he sat on the sidelines in tears for part of tryouts saying he wanted to go home and that soccer wasn't fun, and barely touched the ball in scrimmages because he's afraid of the ball. It was so beyond any normal expectation of parent politics. I hope his parents take pity on him and let him quit, but that's drama for a different thread.


I'm impressed that you remember so many details about the other players on the field. During tryouts, I really only watch my kid and will maybe chit chat with a few other parents of my kid's friends/teammates/ex-teammates. My guess is that the parents of Jack #1 will have the option to move down to team B if he's really having a hard time keeping up, or not do travel and get a refund. There's always the outside chance that he learns to swim and grows a lot this year. At U9, I don't think of this really matters in the long run.


I've known these kids since they were babies (the kids in question), so they weren't new faces, and I personally find myself getting anxious if I watch my kid too intently at tryouts or games so I purposely watch other kids instead a lot of the time. But I agree with all this.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 12:14     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

I would be doubting spending thousands of dollars on a club that can't keep the names straight for just two teams worth of u-littles.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 12:12     Subject: Re:Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:Ok, mystery solved- there was indeed a name mix up. Jack #2, the much better player, was mysteriously added to the A team roster to make the team one player larger. Jack #2 previously had been on no team- I was surprised he had gotten cut and assumed he went to play for a different club, but apparently they mixed up the Jacks when sending emails. What a mess. They rightfully do not want to break Jack 1's (parent's) heart by rescinding his offer so they're just letting him stay, which may not be the kinder thing in the long run considering this kid has zero interest or ability in playing hours and hours of travel soccer every week, but at least it will keep his well connected parents from feeling the embarassment of someone else's mistake. Since it was in no way their fault.

I feel better about soccer politics in our town!!! I knew there were politics and always would be. But this was so out of left field to put this sweet kid on a travel soccer A team when he sat on the sidelines in tears for part of tryouts saying he wanted to go home and that soccer wasn't fun, and barely touched the ball in scrimmages because he's afraid of the ball. It was so beyond any normal expectation of parent politics. I hope his parents take pity on him and let him quit, but that's drama for a different thread.


I'm impressed that you remember so many details about the other players on the field. During tryouts, I really only watch my kid and will maybe chit chat with a few other parents of my kid's friends/teammates/ex-teammates. My guess is that the parents of Jack #1 will have the option to move down to team B if he's really having a hard time keeping up, or not do travel and get a refund. There's always the outside chance that he learns to swim and grows a lot this year. At U9, I don't think of this really matters in the long run.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 11:01     Subject: Re:Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Ok, mystery solved- there was indeed a name mix up. Jack #2, the much better player, was mysteriously added to the A team roster to make the team one player larger. Jack #2 previously had been on no team- I was surprised he had gotten cut and assumed he went to play for a different club, but apparently they mixed up the Jacks when sending emails. What a mess. They rightfully do not want to break Jack 1's (parent's) heart by rescinding his offer so they're just letting him stay, which may not be the kinder thing in the long run considering this kid has zero interest or ability in playing hours and hours of travel soccer every week, but at least it will keep his well connected parents from feeling the embarassment of someone else's mistake. Since it was in no way their fault.

I feel better about soccer politics in our town!!! I knew there were politics and always would be. But this was so out of left field to put this sweet kid on a travel soccer A team when he sat on the sidelines in tears for part of tryouts saying he wanted to go home and that soccer wasn't fun, and barely touched the ball in scrimmages because he's afraid of the ball. It was so beyond any normal expectation of parent politics. I hope his parents take pity on him and let him quit, but that's drama for a different thread.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 06:50     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

It’s u9. Lots of parent involvement. You need to chill out or you’re going to ruin everyone’s season.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 06:08     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It's grossly sexist and hurts all women, yourself included, when you make such allegations, OP, even on an anonymous forum. Why? Because you're perpetuating myths that persist in the minds of stupid people.

I'm not inclined to engage with your topic any further. Check yourself.



Nah, Diana Russini is doing that for you.... the joke was funny


Yeah, one angry person completely derailed the thread. I have no direct answer to the original OP, but my kid has been playing since U8 and is now U14 and we've come across many head scratching roster decisions. These typically resolve themselves over time, sometimes even during the year with a kid moving down who clearly doesn't belong.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2026 06:02     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:It's grossly sexist and hurts all women, yourself included, when you make such allegations, OP, even on an anonymous forum. Why? Because you're perpetuating myths that persist in the minds of stupid people.

I'm not inclined to engage with your topic any further. Check yourself.



Nah, Diana Russini is doing that for you.... the joke was funny
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2026 23:52     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

[quote=Anonymous]This sounds like some small town BS where the family of that kid is well connected in the town and/or the kid’s dad is friends with the coach. The coach either doesn’t want to mess up the friendship or the club sees them as a family who they want to keep happy maybe for reasons totally outside of soccer. It’s like if you have a friend who’s a real estate agent. They may not be the best one, but you feel obligated to go with them. [/quote]

This. Even in a mid size city, this will happen. Its all about social connections and popularity and who loves in different circles. Same with private schools.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2026 23:50     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:I think you are too invested. It is possible this kid has some qualities you don’t recognize. Some coaches like the polite kid who listens and follows instructions and/or works hard. When my son first started he didn’t look like a superstar to many of the parents who had children scoring goal after goal. Yet, coach after coach praised my son for passing the ball, understanding positioning and having a good read of the field. Another possibility is that 2 players were confused with one another. If so, it will be discovered soon enough. This boy may well be moved or just sit on the bench. But I’d also like to caution you to be kind and watch what you say. Don’t jump to conclusions.

+1. Certainly there are instances where kids get placed for political reasons, BUT I’ve seen at least as many, and probably many more, where a coach has a preference for a player or a type of player that doesn’t align with the parent sideline.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2026 23:41     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

I think you are too invested. It is possible this kid has some qualities you don’t recognize. Some coaches like the polite kid who listens and follows instructions and/or works hard. When my son first started he didn’t look like a superstar to many of the parents who had children scoring goal after goal. Yet, coach after coach praised my son for passing the ball, understanding positioning and having a good read of the field. Another possibility is that 2 players were confused with one another. If so, it will be discovered soon enough. This boy may well be moved or just sit on the bench. But I’d also like to caution you to be kind and watch what you say. Don’t jump to conclusions.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2026 23:11     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:Is he really tall? Willing to play goalie? Some kids who are really tall aren’t the most athletic when growing so fast but have a lot of potential.


Ha, I have one of those kids. Joined a U9 travel team after tryouts because older sibling plays for the club and they needed a few more on the B team. Pretty sure his height is what’s keeping him there. He has improved a lot and not afraid of the ball anymore, but it was rough the first couple of months. He is starting to figure out how to use his size and I assume the coaches think they can work with him to further unlock that advantage. I am not totally convinced but we’ll see. He is having fun.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2026 23:03     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is he really tall? Willing to play goalie? Some kids who are really tall aren’t the most athletic when growing so fast but have a lot of potential.


Ding ding ding.

This.

Alas it doesn’t work other way. System 1 thinking. It’s a real bias - and honestly is why smaller nations - Italy Spain Portugal hand USA our hat at WC and will do so again this year.

Italy didn’t even make the World Cup but in general I agree with you.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2026 21:23     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:Is he really tall? Willing to play goalie? Some kids who are really tall aren’t the most athletic when growing so fast but have a lot of potential.


Ding ding ding.

This.

Alas it doesn’t work other way. System 1 thinking. It’s a real bias - and honestly is why smaller nations - Italy Spain Portugal hand USA our hat at WC and will do so again this year.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2026 21:05     Subject: Am I naive? Kid made the top team who can barely play.

Anonymous wrote:Is he really tall? Willing to play goalie? Some kids who are really tall aren’t the most athletic when growing so fast but have a lot of potential.


Or in one of the oldest kids.

Our girls ECNL team was originally made up of almost all girls born September 1-April. Big changes this year.