Anonymous
01/19/2026 14:31
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Why did they arrest Cats husband? The evidence Alice planted indicated Lexy but the husband would be a stretch.
Anonymous
01/19/2026 09:26
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I liked it, but I do have similar questions as pps with some of the holes. I had it on all day in the background so I may not have been paying super close attention and missed things.
How did Cat/lexy kill her sister? Did she tamper with the inhaler or something?
The blackmail was not very clear here. Why the friends would wait 10 years to blackmail her over this? Why were Anna/Richard together in the first place? I want to know more about Lexy - did she stalk anna and get a job at the same place? Doubt it's coincidence.
Anna's mom tampered with the inhaler, a change from the book I think. But Cat was gleeful about the death as she ate her donuts.
Huh??? You're saying this happened in the show? It did not.
+1
They very clearly show Catherine deliberately letting all the medicine out of the inhaler before getting on the boat.
SPOILERS
Guessing they showed this to make it plausible that Catherine deserved her ending, too. Otherwise we'd just have a Pygmalion plot, where Catherine goes from social outcast to lead anchor, and viewers would sympathize with her and complain about her ending.
Anonymous
01/18/2026 23:32
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:Absolutely terrible. Really bad. Poorly acted, ridiculous ending, and nonsensical decision-making by the characters. I regret watching it.
So, so bad. Terrible acting, ridiculous plot. I've never read any Alice Feeney books. I definitely won't now!
Anonymous
01/16/2026 13:01
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I liked it, but I do have similar questions as pps with some of the holes. I had it on all day in the background so I may not have been paying super close attention and missed things.
How did Cat/lexy kill her sister? Did she tamper with the inhaler or something?
The blackmail was not very clear here. Why the friends would wait 10 years to blackmail her over this? Why were Anna/Richard together in the first place? I want to know more about Lexy - did she stalk anna and get a job at the same place? Doubt it's coincidence.
Anna's mom tampered with the inhaler, a change from the book I think. But Cat was gleeful about the death as she ate her donuts.
Huh??? You're saying this happened in the show? It did not.
+1
They very clearly show Catherine deliberately letting all the medicine out of the inhaler before getting on the boat.
Anonymous
01/16/2026 13:00
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:I'm really sick of Jon Bernthal's twitchy good ol' boy schtick. Tessa Thompson is the only thing that made this series watchable.
Totally agree. He was playing his character Shane from the Walking Dead, fake southern accent and all.
Anonymous
01/16/2026 12:47
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I liked it, but I do have similar questions as pps with some of the holes. I had it on all day in the background so I may not have been paying super close attention and missed things.
How did Cat/lexy kill her sister? Did she tamper with the inhaler or something?
The blackmail was not very clear here. Why the friends would wait 10 years to blackmail her over this? Why were Anna/Richard together in the first place? I want to know more about Lexy - did she stalk anna and get a job at the same place? Doubt it's coincidence.
Anna's mom tampered with the inhaler, a change from the book I think. But Cat was gleeful about the death as she ate her donuts.
Huh??? You're saying this happened in the show? It did not.
Yeah, they flashed back to show the three murders the mom was responsible for. Catherine/Lexy was a sociopath, shown early in Ep 6 emptying her Andrea's inhaler before the sailing outing.
Anonymous
01/16/2026 12:14
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
I'm really sick of Jon Bernthal's twitchy good ol' boy schtick. Tessa Thompson is the only thing that made this series watchable.
Anonymous
01/16/2026 11:45
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I liked it, but I do have similar questions as pps with some of the holes. I had it on all day in the background so I may not have been paying super close attention and missed things.
How did Cat/lexy kill her sister? Did she tamper with the inhaler or something?
The blackmail was not very clear here. Why the friends would wait 10 years to blackmail her over this? Why were Anna/Richard together in the first place? I want to know more about Lexy - did she stalk anna and get a job at the same place? Doubt it's coincidence.
Anna's mom tampered with the inhaler, a change from the book I think. But Cat was gleeful about the death as she ate her donuts.
Huh??? You're saying this happened in the show? It did not.
Anonymous
01/15/2026 22:32
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:I thought they were blackmailing the other husband over the S&M photos/videos?
No, that was just one of the many red herrings. Jack assumes there is blackmailing going on when he sees the text messages and video, but there wasn't.
Another loose end - we see Jack let himself into the school by way of the chapel on the very night Helen is murdered. But of course, they never circle back and explain what he was doing there. We're supposed to wonder if he killed Helen. It's just all so stupid.
Anonymous
01/15/2026 22:00
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
I thought they were blackmailing the other husband over the S&M photos/videos?
Anonymous
01/15/2026 20:50
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
I disliked all the people in this show but the female detective. Everyone was just so unlikable. I had so many issues with this show. Anna is so argumentative and arrogant but demands people’s attention and time- there’s no universe that exists the people would give her the time of day. And during the ridiculous press conference where Anna takes over the microphone. The whole story and the way the people behave is just so unrealistic.
Anonymous
01/15/2026 20:21
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous
01/15/2026 18:41
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I liked it, but I do have similar questions as pps with some of the holes. I had it on all day in the background so I may not have been paying super close attention and missed things.
How did Cat/lexy kill her sister? Did she tamper with the inhaler or something?
The blackmail was not very clear here. Why the friends would wait 10 years to blackmail her over this? Why were Anna/Richard together in the first place? I want to know more about Lexy - did she stalk anna and get a job at the same place? Doubt it's coincidence.
Anna's mom tampered with the inhaler, a change from the book I think. But Cat was gleeful about the death as she ate her donuts.
Is the blackmail in the books? Why would the friends blackmail cat when it was alice? So confused lol
Anonymous
01/15/2026 18:28
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:I liked it, but I do have similar questions as pps with some of the holes. I had it on all day in the background so I may not have been paying super close attention and missed things.
How did Cat/lexy kill her sister? Did she tamper with the inhaler or something?
The blackmail was not very clear here. Why the friends would wait 10 years to blackmail her over this? Why were Anna/Richard together in the first place? I want to know more about Lexy - did she stalk anna and get a job at the same place? Doubt it's coincidence.
All of this, yes. Very odd omissions.
Anonymous
01/15/2026 18:27
Subject: His & Hers, new Netflix series
Anonymous wrote:I liked it, but I do have similar questions as pps with some of the holes. I had it on all day in the background so I may not have been paying super close attention and missed things.
How did Cat/lexy kill her sister? Did she tamper with the inhaler or something?
The blackmail was not very clear here. Why the friends would wait 10 years to blackmail her over this? Why were Anna/Richard together in the first place? I want to know more about Lexy - did she stalk anna and get a job at the same place? Doubt it's coincidence.
Anna's mom tampered with the inhaler, a change from the book I think. But Cat was gleeful about the death as she ate her donuts.