Anonymous
Post 02/04/2026 18:56     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
What about cold cream?
Anonymous
Post 02/04/2026 18:43     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Anonymous wrote:I have this problem, too. I also have developed dry eyes and occasional blepharitis as I approach age 50. I use Ilia regular mascara or Tarte tubing mascara, both which purport to be gentle and easy to remove, and both which I have trouble removing.

I have tried Almay eye makeup remover and bioderma micellar water and neither removes my mascara without a lot of rubbing, which causes redness and stinging (not to mention probably enhances eye area wrinkles ☺️) .

I have tried a makeup eraser towel and same result (requires lots of rubbing, so then redness, etc).

I have tried a cleansing oil and balms and they remove the eye makeup but they exacerbate the blepharitis, I think they are too heavy on my lids and clog the pores/ducts (I thoroughly rinse it off and double cleanse with La Roche Posay gentle cleanser after, and even use a separate eye wash).

I am at the point that I rarely wear eye makeup because of this problem. Hoping to see a new suggestion on this thread - I am going to try baby shampoo per one poster’s suggestion.

- NP


For mascara, maybe just try a different type of makeup. I switched to tubing last year if changing. Comes right off. Haven't found a great solution for eyeliner, so I just gave up on using it.
Anonymous
Post 02/04/2026 18:36     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Makeup artist here! For my clients with mature skin, I recommend using a cleansing oil or balm instead of any type of cloth/wipe/cotton round. It’s a lot more gentle on your skin. Cleansing oils or balms break down makeup without damaging the skin. I like DHC cleansing oil or Zero (by Banila Co) or Clinique cleansing balm. Apply it with dry hands, rinse, then follow with your preferred face wash
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2025 04:55     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Anonymous wrote:Switch to a tubing mascara. I use Thrive. And then all you need is Cetaphil or cerave


This leaves spider legs all over my face.
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2025 04:47     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50

Double cleanse! If you just use the balm it’s oily afterward- use one of the balms (Farmacy, Clinique, Elf dupe of Clinique) or a cleansing oil and then a gentle cleanser. I sometimes use a cotton ball with makeup remover in the middle because my eyeliner is hard to get off, and the balm loosens it. So much less rubbing. Then the cleanser finishes it off and makes your face feel nice.

Also get the Shishedo soft cotton squares- so much better than regular cotton balls.

I am also 50 and just the cotton ball and makeup remover is so irritating! If you are set on just one step, my final rec is the Glossier nicellar remover- if’s half oil and is really gentle. I have used it for many years.

Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 23:43     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Switch to a tubing mascara. I use Thrive. And then all you need is Cetaphil or cerave
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 23:26     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Lancome (the blue bottle)! Pricey but gentle with a pleasant fragrance.
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 22:30     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
I use tea tree oil wipes.
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 22:28     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Anonymous wrote:Don't wear eye makeup? Do you need it?


Such a dumb post.
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 22:20     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
I just use coconut oil on a pad. I also think the extra moisture around the eye area has kept wrinkles away.
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 22:18     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Instant Eye Makeup remover by Clarins. It’s the best!
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 09:53     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
I use makeup eraser cloths to remove tubing mascara, have for years and have not noticed any loss or damage. The key is that the makeup eraser cloth has to be very wet, like dripping wet, when you use it. Then you place it against the underside of your upper lashes (looking up a bit can help with this) and keep it there for a bit (10 - 20 seconds maybe) and then very gently push the cloth upwards against the lashes and the tubing mascara should slide right off the lashes.

I don’t wear mascara on my lower lashes but I imagine the technique would be basically the same, just holding the makeup eraser cloth against the top of the lower lashes.
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 09:39     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
Anonymous wrote:Just use plain water and a makeup eraser cloth.


+1
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 09:01     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
CeraVe cream to foam cleanser has been very effective and gentle for me.
Anonymous
Post 12/18/2025 08:53     Subject: Removing eye makeup at 50
I use ocusoft wipes at night and baby shampoo in the shower.