Anonymous
Post 02/18/2026 08:09     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Anonymous wrote:Try brick house butcher in Falls Church. Great quality.


Bumping this - no, I don’t work there but for all the people dissatisfied with Organic Butcher, it is worth trying.
Anonymous
Post 02/18/2026 07:49     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP here, thanks. We went this afternoon and found the rear parking.
We went to Balduccis first and I went to eyeball the beef and prices.
Was a little put off by the food smell in Organic Butcher. I guess it's garlicky sausage or something.
I guess their core clientele know what they want, not browsers. We got a strip steak. Will see if it's better.
I noticed the boneless rib eye looked better trimmed at Balduccis and was $38 a pound, not $46 as at Organic but maybe it tastes better ?


You really can’t compare to Balduccis…Balduccis is just Safeway with prices marked up. The quality of meat is no better than what you get at your local Safeway.


Someone said they had same supplier?

If you go online, the suppliers/farms are often listed in the product description. Whole chicken is under $20.
Anonymous
Post 02/17/2026 11:39     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Anonymous wrote:I dislike the parking situation, but it's worth it. I always use them when I need something special (recently I made a stuffed pork loin and they cut it for me so it was easy to stuff and roll).


Park in back/on the side. It's much easier than parking in front.
Anonymous
Post 02/17/2026 11:38     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
I haven’t found the quality to be superior to meat at Whole Foods, but the one in Bethesda has stuff that I can’t get at WF. Separately, as a French person, I’m used to going to the butcher’s. Honestly this one isn’t great compared to the ones in my home country.
Anonymous
Post 02/17/2026 11:07     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I go to the one in Bethesda. Had a nit great experience there this weekend - they open at 10am and were sold out of crab cakes when I arrived at 10:25am. Also I requested 1-1.5 inch thick boneless rib eyes and the rib eyes they gave me were over 2” thick (they wrapped them up and handed them to me so I didn’t get a chance to see them until home). When I am paying those prices, I should get what I asked for.


Order and pay online in advance, which both ensures you get what you want and are in and out quickly.

In my experience they sometimes give you more than what you ordered, at least by weight. That may have happened to you, even if you didn't value the thicker cut.


I didn’t do this because I wanted to specific the thickness of ribeye cuts that I wanted. I expect that at a butcher I should get as close to what I ask for as possible (vs buying at the meat counter at whole foods, for example). Whole Foods had lovely ribeyes and crab cakes!
Anonymous
Post 02/16/2026 16:14     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
If I buy hamburger for 2 adult burgers how much to buy? Willing to give them another try. Had burgers yesterday first time in 6 years using Balduccis patties. I thought they were ok but DH said meat was blah. So one last chance...
I was very disappointed with Organic Butcher lamb chops and steaks. Meh meat.
Anonymous
Post 02/16/2026 14:51     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
I dislike the parking situation, but it's worth it. I always use them when I need something special (recently I made a stuffed pork loin and they cut it for me so it was easy to stuff and roll).
Anonymous
Post 02/16/2026 12:54     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Anonymous wrote:I go to the one in Bethesda. Had a nit great experience there this weekend - they open at 10am and were sold out of crab cakes when I arrived at 10:25am. Also I requested 1-1.5 inch thick boneless rib eyes and the rib eyes they gave me were over 2” thick (they wrapped them up and handed them to me so I didn’t get a chance to see them until home). When I am paying those prices, I should get what I asked for.


Order and pay online in advance, which both ensures you get what you want and are in and out quickly.

In my experience they sometimes give you more than what you ordered, at least by weight. That may have happened to you, even if you didn't value the thicker cut.
Anonymous
Post 02/15/2026 21:32     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
I go to the one in Bethesda. Had a nit great experience there this weekend - they open at 10am and were sold out of crab cakes when I arrived at 10:25am. Also I requested 1-1.5 inch thick boneless rib eyes and the rib eyes they gave me were over 2” thick (they wrapped them up and handed them to me so I didn’t get a chance to see them until home). When I am paying those prices, I should get what I asked for.
Anonymous
Post 02/15/2026 21:21     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Went in this week to take a look. Meat is not as affordable and low-cost as Whole Foods. Did not buy anything.
Anonymous
Post 10/28/2025 17:07     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Our PC ordered from there regularly.
Anonymous
Post 10/26/2025 15:18     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Anonymous wrote:Well it was there in the case. Had to pick quick they don't coddle newbies. Also they don't let you take meat to check out yourself in case you steal it, apparently.

I think filet mignon is bland. DH likes it. Do they have real Chateaubriand? Not tied together "tenderloin"?

You should check out their website to explore the meats, etc that they have.
Anonymous
Post 10/26/2025 11:59     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Well it was there in the case. Had to pick quick they don't coddle newbies. Also they don't let you take meat to check out yourself in case you steal it, apparently.

I think filet mignon is bland. DH likes it. Do they have real Chateaubriand? Not tied together "tenderloin"?
Anonymous
Post 10/26/2025 08:33     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
I just think the New York strip is an odd choice to test out the organic butcher. You should go for fillets or something else unique. I mean, there’s nothing wrong with a New York strip or even getting it from there but for your first time trying to decide the difference – it’s a pretty basic piece of meat. I’ve never eaten any strip and been like OMG that’s the best strip I’ve ever eaten in my entire life.
Anonymous
Post 10/26/2025 07:47     Subject: The Organic Butcher in McLean?
Meat is great. Park down the street and walk. You have legs