Anonymous
Post 09/15/2025 09:30     Subject: Coat help - casual city lifestyle
Anonymous wrote:I like both of the coats that OP posted.

But.... when someone starts their post as saying they have been wearing 15 year old too-tight outerwear, and are in jeans and tees..... I think these two coats will not only be wasted on this person, but potentially look frump. Both of these coats you're ideally skinny, stylish (and tall is a plus). If you're a middle aged unstylish mom wearing 7 year old Jcrew Factory, these two coats are going to look dowdy on you, and no one is going to recognize that they are stylish expensive coats.


OP. lol, no, I don’t think I meet that description. But thank you for looking out for me here.
Anonymous
Post 09/15/2025 09:26     Subject: Coat help - casual city lifestyle
Anonymous wrote:They're both lovely. Personally I think the camel one is extraordinary - the scarf, the embroidery, the color. Love it!


I personally hate the shape of the camel coat, and I also like to have a bit of length in my coats. I vote the plaid. Super cute.
Anonymous
Post 09/15/2025 09:21     Subject: Coat help - casual city lifestyle
Hard disagree.

I'm 70, 5'1" and plump. Boxy coats suit me best. I get lots of compliments on my style.

Older women benefit from being able to afford expensive clothes. Younger women can make anything look good.