Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone know how the promotion from GA Tier 2 (Aspire) into GA will work?

Will it be for one team at one age group, if they do particularly well for example. Or is it for the whole Club to earn a promotion?

-If its only for a whole club, will they ignore promotion of GA2 team if the same club already has a GA1 team? I.e. if a clubs GA2 team wins their league, would they have no shot at promotion because the same club already has a GA1 team?

Typical promotion leagues promote the top 3 and relegate the bottom 3. It would be cool to see relegating the bottom 3 and making 3rd and 4th in Aspire play an elimination game to win promotion.

The problem with youth league and club structure is there's a multiple levels of teams for every age group. Pro/Rel doesn't work in the current club structure because a single coach might have multiple levels or age group teams.

What this means is if you wanted to do Pro/Rel ar the youth level it would have to be club wide at all age groups. This doesn't work because clubs will just go to competitors before being relegated if it's going to happen across all age groups and levels.

ECNLs way to get around all this was to force crappy clubs to merge with better clubs vs boot them completely from the league. Unfortunately this just delays the inevitable because merged club leadership will fight for power eventually spinning back put into separate clubs usually in a different league.

Pro/Rel works with acadamies because there's 1 top team and all age groups feed I to it. Age has no bearing on who plays.

Good points that I agree with, that’s why I’m wondering what they mean when they say teams can be promoted…. Wonder if it’s just technical lip service.

Given that GA plays the same club vs club format where all six age groups play each other on the same day, it cannot be individual team promotion

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone know how the promotion from GA Tier 2 (Aspire) into GA will work?

Will it be for one team at one age group, if they do particularly well for example. Or is it for the whole Club to earn a promotion?

-If its only for a whole club, will they ignore promotion of GA2 team if the same club already has a GA1 team? I.e. if a clubs GA2 team wins their league, would they have no shot at promotion because the same club already has a GA1 team?

Typical promotion leagues promote the top 3 and relegate the bottom 3. It would be cool to see relegating the bottom 3 and making 3rd and 4th in Aspire play an elimination game to win promotion.

The problem with youth league and club structure is there's a multiple levels of teams for every age group. Pro/Rel doesn't work in the current club structure because a single coach might have multiple levels or age group teams.

What this means is if you wanted to do Pro/Rel ar the youth level it would have to be club wide at all age groups. This doesn't work because clubs will just go to competitors before being relegated if it's going to happen across all age groups and levels.

ECNLs way to get around all this was to force crappy clubs to merge with better clubs vs boot them completely from the league. Unfortunately this just delays the inevitable because merged club leadership will fight for power eventually spinning back put into separate clubs usually in a different league.

Pro/Rel works with acadamies because there's 1 top team and all age groups feed I to it. Age has no bearing on who plays.

Good points that I agree with, that’s why I’m wondering what they mean when they say teams can be promoted…. Wonder if it’s just technical lip service.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Who cares that league is 4-5 years away at best to being on par

Every girl except one from my daughters GA team was recruited with money. 5 of them to ACC schools.

Anonymous wrote:Who cares that league is 4-5 years away at best to being on par

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone know how the promotion from GA Tier 2 (Aspire) into GA will work?

Will it be for one team at one age group, if they do particularly well for example. Or is it for the whole Club to earn a promotion?

-If its only for a whole club, will they ignore promotion of GA2 team if the same club already has a GA1 team? I.e. if a clubs GA2 team wins their league, would they have no shot at promotion because the same club already has a GA1 team?

Typical promotion leagues promote the top 3 and relegate the bottom 3. It would be cool to see relegating the bottom 3 and making 3rd and 4th in Aspire play an elimination game to win promotion.

The problem with youth league and club structure is there's a multiple levels of teams for every age group. Pro/Rel doesn't work in the current club structure because a single coach might have multiple levels or age group teams.

What this means is if you wanted to do Pro/Rel ar the youth level it would have to be club wide at all age groups. This doesn't work because clubs will just go to competitors before being relegated if it's going to happen across all age groups and levels.

ECNLs way to get around all this was to force crappy clubs to merge with better clubs vs boot them completely from the league. Unfortunately this just delays the inevitable because merged club leadership will fight for power eventually spinning back put into separate clubs usually in a different league.

Pro/Rel works with acadamies because there's 1 top team and all age groups feed I to it. Age has no bearing on who plays.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone know how the promotion from GA Tier 2 (Aspire) into GA will work?

Will it be for one team at one age group, if they do particularly well for example. Or is it for the whole Club to earn a promotion?

-If its only for a whole club, will they ignore promotion of GA2 team if the same club already has a GA1 team? I.e. if a clubs GA2 team wins their league, would they have no shot at promotion because the same club already has a GA1 team?

Typical promotion leagues promote the top 3 and relegate the bottom 3. It would be cool to see relegating the bottom 3 and making 3rd and 4th in Aspire play an elimination game to win promotion.

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone know how the promotion from GA Tier 2 (Aspire) into GA will work?

Will it be for one team at one age group, if they do particularly well for example. Or is it for the whole Club to earn a promotion?

-If its only for a whole club, will they ignore promotion of GA2 team if the same club already has a GA1 team? I.e. if a clubs GA2 team wins their league, would they have no shot at promotion because the same club already has a GA1 team?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Much of the above information is only partial and doesn’t really describe the ga. No local clubs are champions cup teams and not likely to be in the near future. The oversaturation by clubs joining into the gap will keep the teams weak on a wide scale basis for some years to come. The talent will begin to accumulate at one of the clubs, which will likely be VRSC just like the ECNL talent has accumulated at vda.

Wait, all the ECNL hats say that GA is easy. If this is case NVA + others should be able to steamroll through the finals.

Now the excuse is "oversaturation" of clubs? What does this even mean? There's only one winner of a regional league. You could have 50 teams in a regional league and it wouldn't matter. There would still only be one top team going to finals.

Sometimes the excuses get so thick if they jumped up in the air they'd get stuck.

How do you explain clubs like Nationals, South Shore Select and Ukrainian Nationals going from top GA teams to bottom tier ECNL teams?

Anonymous wrote:GA is a pretty well run league. It might not be if they over saturate it with teams that don’t compete.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Much of the above information is only partial and doesn’t really describe the ga. No local clubs are champions cup teams and not likely to be in the near future. The oversaturation by clubs joining into the gap will keep the teams weak on a wide scale basis for some years to come. The talent will begin to accumulate at one of the clubs, which will likely be VRSC just like the ECNL talent has accumulated at vda.

Wait, all the ECNL hats say that GA is easy. If this is case NVA + others should be able to steamroll through the finals.

Now the excuse is "oversaturation" of clubs? What does this even mean? There's only one winner of a regional league. You could have 50 teams in a regional league and it wouldn't matter. There would still only be one top team going to finals.

Sometimes the excuses get so thick if they jumped up in the air they'd get stuck.

How do you explain clubs like Nationals, South Shore Select and Ukrainian Nationals going from top GA teams to bottom tier ECNL teams?

Ukies lost a ton of players to other clubs when then moved from GA to ECNL. The Ukies teams playing ECNL right now are not the same players that played GA

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Much of the above information is only partial and doesn’t really describe the ga. No local clubs are champions cup teams and not likely to be in the near future. The oversaturation by clubs joining into the gap will keep the teams weak on a wide scale basis for some years to come. The talent will begin to accumulate at one of the clubs, which will likely be VRSC just like the ECNL talent has accumulated at vda.

Wait, all the ECNL hats say that GA is easy. If this is case NVA + others should be able to steamroll through the finals.

Now the excuse is "oversaturation" of clubs? What does this even mean? There's only one winner of a regional league. You could have 50 teams in a regional league and it wouldn't matter. There would still only be one top team going to finals.

Sometimes the excuses get so thick if they jumped up in the air they'd get stuck.

How do you explain clubs like Nationals, South Shore Select and Ukrainian Nationals going from top GA teams to bottom tier ECNL teams?

Ukies lost a ton of players to other clubs when then moved from GA to ECNL. The Ukies teams playing ECNL right now are not the same players that played GA

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Much of the above information is only partial and doesn’t really describe the ga. No local clubs are champions cup teams and not likely to be in the near future. The oversaturation by clubs joining into the gap will keep the teams weak on a wide scale basis for some years to come. The talent will begin to accumulate at one of the clubs, which will likely be VRSC just like the ECNL talent has accumulated at vda.

Wait, all the ECNL hats say that GA is easy. If this is case NVA + others should be able to steamroll through the finals.

Now the excuse is "oversaturation" of clubs? What does this even mean? There's only one winner of a regional league. You could have 50 teams in a regional league and it wouldn't matter. There would still only be one top team going to finals.

Sometimes the excuses get so thick if they jumped up in the air they'd get stuck.

How do you explain clubs like Nationals, South Shore Select and Ukrainian Nationals going from top GA teams to bottom tier ECNL teams?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Much of the above information is only partial and doesn’t really describe the ga. No local clubs are champions cup teams and not likely to be in the near future. The oversaturation by clubs joining into the gap will keep the teams weak on a wide scale basis for some years to come. The talent will begin to accumulate at one of the clubs, which will likely be VRSC just like the ECNL talent has accumulated at vda.

You’re trying so hard in every thread, does your livelihood depend on parents’ payments exclusively?