Anonymous
01/29/2025 13:23
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
Dude, it's called acting. If you're looking for "representation" in a show like this, you're... a little lost.
You don't seem to have an actual complaint about the performance, or the content of the show. Stop making drama where there isn't any.
You need to join the rest of us in the 21st century. Black face anyone?
Bro, there is a WORLD of difference between blackface and someone playing a character outside their religion in a completely benign, non-offensive way. If you don't understand that, I don't know how to help you.
Anonymous
01/29/2025 11:09
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
I was only asking because it was a weird thing to throw in there. "I'm Jewish actually". That's all it was. It was so random. I am also Jewish.
Anonymous
01/29/2025 11:07
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
Dude, it's called acting. If you're looking for "representation" in a show like this, you're... a little lost.
You don't seem to have an actual complaint about the performance, or the content of the show. Stop making drama where there isn't any.
It is very much a conversation, when and in what circumstances it's appropriate for someone to play a character whose demographics are so different from their own. If someone in blackface played a character, would that be a problem? If so, then why is it ok for someone not Jewish to play a Jewish character?
I'm not saying that non-Jews can't play Jews - or that Jews can't play non-Jews! - but it is certainly an open conversation.
+1 Very much agreed.
Anonymous
01/29/2025 11:06
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
Dude, it's called acting. If you're looking for "representation" in a show like this, you're... a little lost.
You don't seem to have an actual complaint about the performance, or the content of the show. Stop making drama where there isn't any.
You need to join the rest of us in the 21st century. Black face anyone?
Anonymous
01/29/2025 09:28
Subject: The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Am I the only one who doesn’t care for Noah Wylie’s scruffy beard? He was so baby-faced in ER. His voice seems a bit raspy too.
Yes, what is up with his voice?
Anonymous
01/29/2025 09:05
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
Dude, it's called acting. If you're looking for "representation" in a show like this, you're... a little lost.
You don't seem to have an actual complaint about the performance, or the content of the show. Stop making drama where there isn't any.
It is very much a conversation, when and in what circumstances it's appropriate for someone to play a character whose demographics are so different from their own. If someone in blackface played a character, would that be a problem? If so, then why is it ok for someone not Jewish to play a Jewish character?
I'm not saying that non-Jews can't play Jews - or that Jews can't play non-Jews! - but it is certainly an open conversation.
And in any case, Wikipedia says his dad is Jewish, his mom is not, and he was raised with both traditions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noah_Wyle
Anonymous
01/29/2025 09:03
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
Dude, it's called acting. If you're looking for "representation" in a show like this, you're... a little lost.
You don't seem to have an actual complaint about the performance, or the content of the show. Stop making drama where there isn't any.
It is very much a conversation, when and in what circumstances it's appropriate for someone to play a character whose demographics are so different from their own. If someone in blackface played a character, would that be a problem? If so, then why is it ok for someone not Jewish to play a Jewish character?
I'm not saying that non-Jews can't play Jews - or that Jews can't play non-Jews! - but it is certainly an open conversation.
Anonymous
01/29/2025 09:00
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
Dude, it's called acting. If you're looking for "representation" in a show like this, you're... a little lost.
You don't seem to have an actual complaint about the performance, or the content of the show. Stop making drama where there isn't any.
Anonymous
01/29/2025 08:43
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
A story as old as time! See Mrs Maisel and Meet the Fabelmans
Anonymous
01/28/2025 20:56
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
No they really don't. I think they're concerned about non-Jews representing real ones.
Anonymous
01/28/2025 19:19
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
You sound extremely anti-semitic
Anonymous
01/28/2025 17:34
Subject: The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
I loved ER (up until all of the original cast members left). I wonder if this new show will take place entirely in the hospital or branch out to cover stories outside of it.
Anonymous
01/28/2025 16:53
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Of course it is. I am wondering if he's Jewish in real life like the character on the show. If not, it's kind of a weird thing to throw into an episode.
Anonymous
01/28/2025 15:29
Subject: Re:The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Noah Wyle is such a cutie.
Is he jewish? He plays a Jew on the show.
Why?
I really like it. I wasn’t sure about the hour by hour time frame, but I’m finding I like it. I like hospital shows, and one of the pitfalls is always those patients that you wish you could see more of. The lawsuit is so dumb. Good or bad, hospital shows are hospital shows. You have the doctors and staff and their ongoing storylines, and the patients supplying everything from comedy to tragedy. I could make a bingo card. Twin to Twin Transfer Syndrome. Major Disaster, patient identities get switched. Heroic correction of diagnosis: omg your child does not have a rare cancer it’s actually strep! The Chrighton estate should have taken their free money and run.
Why what?
Why is someone asking if he’s Jewish? It’s not relevant to the thread and it’s just weird to ask.
Anonymous
01/28/2025 14:31
Subject: The Pitt, new HBO Max show w Noah Wyle
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Code Black with Marcia Gay Harden is as good or better than ER....and I loved ER.
In Season 1, maybe. Went downhill after that. I'm enjoying Doc now too, more so than The Pitt.
I really like Doc, too. Molly Parker is perfect in the lead role.