Anonymous wrote:BTW my high GPA daughter applied ONLY safeties she would go to. The catch is they have to give her really good merit aid.
So screw yield protection concept. She is 100 percent committed to going to a safety.
But if full pay or low aid why should she.
My middle child did go her safety. She got in NYU, Leigh and Pitt and the Aid was terrible.
Her safety offered her honors program, honors dorm and great merit aid and she went.
Anonymous wrote:I vacillate between feeling confident about DD’s strategy and anxious we’re not casting the net wide enough. She has very specific criteria and feels okay about taking a gap year if none work out. The acceptance rates are predicted by CollegeVine based on her profile and validated by Naviance. They are not the overall acceptance rates.
1 private far reach (22%)
2 private hard targets (28% and 36%)
2 public targets (56% and 78%)
1 private target (85%)
2 public safeties (98% and 99%)
Her top choice is UMD, which CV predicts at 78% but she’s coming from MCPS so I know that’s optimistic. Thoughts?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The only issue I have is that your kid basically ruins the chances for other kids when they submit a throwaway to a place like VT it JMU or some other state school.
There isn’t a reasonable reason to apply to more than ten schools because after that pint, you can’t tell me that he would rather go to number 12, 13, 14 if he got into any of 1-10.
And 1-10 should include a balance of reach, target, and backup. (3-2-2….or 2-3-2)
With yield protection, safeties don’t exist.
Anonymous wrote:To be honest don't waste time on more than 2 safeties.
DC ended up applying to 4 safeties and was admitted into all 4 - Knox, HWS, Allegheny and Gettysburg. Regretted later on wasting time / slot.