Anonymous
10/03/2024 00:54
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:BCC is a very good school, but the least strong, I feel, of the so-called W schools. It's an honorary W school. My second kid goes there. My first kid went to WJ because he was part of a special program. WJ has more rigorous instruction with better teachers (overall, of course, there are exceptions). As PP explained, Bethesda has a high mean HHI, but a lot of its wealthy families send their kids to privates, and the rest ends up at the public school. On my street of 1.5M+ houses, about two thirds of the families send their kids to privates. Before the pandemic, it was the reverse.
Lol. Only because it is located in same-named city as Whitman and WJ.
Hence the term honorary. Although to be entirely fair, BCC is much more rigorous and studious than the non-magnet Blair, Poolesville, and Rockville, Einstein, Wheaton, etc. So the description is apt. Wootton is another W that's a little weaker than the three big ones: Whitman, WJ and Winston Churchill.
I'm so impressed to hear that you've taught at, parented through, _and_ attended all of these schools, along with studying all of their data and their demographics. You must be even more amazing than a BCC kid.
Anonymous
10/02/2024 23:15
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
One of the more interesting things about the list of semifinalists is how many of those students attended CCES HGC. This class was the last one to take the full COGAT test. Perhaps, MCPS should consider bringing it back.
Anonymous
10/02/2024 20:27
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
Anonymous wrote:Because all the rich kids are smoking a lot of pot? At least that was the deal in the 90s!
Trolling from 30 years ago? weak sauce.
Anonymous
10/02/2024 11:10
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet kids at Blair and RM come from somewhere. They disproportionately pull from BCC and Wootton due to geography and self fulfilling look at statistics (e.g Blair has more National Merit scholars than BCC, so I want my kid to go there.)
No, more kids at Blair come from the DCC.
Yes, and they don't disproportionally pull from Wootton or BCC. This is just a myth that some parents like to tell themselves. The reality is the majority of magnet kids at Blair come from TPMS and the majority of magnet kids from TPMS were zoned for Blair to begin with.
Even if it so, it doesn't follow from your premises that majority or plurality of Blair magnet kids were zoned for Blair.
Anonymous
10/02/2024 10:57
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
Anonymous wrote:
... compared to other non-magnets Walter Johnson, Churchill, Whitman? Five kids out of ~ 580 who took the PSAT at BCC were selected. I don't get it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/psat/comments/1fej2md/nmsf_2025_maryland/#lightbox
My kid opted to take ACT from the start (got a 35) and didn’t really try their hardest on the psat (which was also the first time they took a digital test). Maybe there are others like this at bcc.
Anonymous
10/02/2024 09:45
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet kids at Blair and RM come from somewhere. They disproportionately pull from BCC and Wootton due to geography and self fulfilling look at statistics (e.g Blair has more National Merit scholars than BCC, so I want my kid to go there.)
No, more kids at Blair come from the DCC.
Yes, and they don't disproportionally pull from Wootton or BCC. This is just a myth that some parents like to tell themselves. The reality is the majority of magnet kids at Blair come from TPMS and the majority of magnet kids from TPMS were zoned for Blair to begin with.
Anonymous
10/02/2024 08:30
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
Because all the rich kids are smoking a lot of pot? At least that was the deal in the 90s!
Anonymous
10/02/2024 08:16
Subject: NMSF are out - why does BCC have so very, very few semifinalists?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet kids at Blair and RM come from somewhere. They disproportionately pull from BCC and Wootton due to geography and self fulfilling look at statistics (e.g Blair has more National Merit scholars than BCC, so I want my kid to go there.)
No more kids at Blair come from the DCC.
Wow, more kids come from those 5 schools than these 2?