Anonymous wrote:I know a Scarlett who goes by Carly…because she hates her real name.

I had a colleague named Letty and I didn’t realize that was a NN for Scarlett until I saw her name in a report years later. I assumed her name was Leticia or something.

Anonymous wrote:I love it, OP. I say go for it.

+1
It's classic

I know a Scarlett who goes by Carly…because she hates her real name.

Anonymous wrote:Too precious. Not a fan.

+1 I could see a kid ending up hating being saddled with it.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I hate this name, both for the racist undertones but it’s also just kind of trashy.

Agree. It sounds like a stripper name.

+1

Too precious. Not a fan.

Trashy

I liked it and considered it when my first kid was born, so 18 years ago. It had just become popular then. It's one of those names I like but I'm glad I didn't use. It doesn't seem very versatile for a high schooler.

Eh, just seems southern to me.

Anonymous wrote:I knew a family with daughters named Scarlett, Bonnie, and Tara. In Connecticut, of all places.

Yikes lol

Anonymous wrote:My 8 yr old niece has a friend named that. Sometimes she calls her Scarlie.

I love this name too but I think it falls in the category of something that will inevitably get a nickname and doesn't have a good one.