Anonymous wrote:Academics always love to hear that a young student is willing to pay lots of money to keep their unprofitable scholarship humming along.

Sure, it might be a hook given that he's a male interested in the humanities.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Wait, you're an academic and you can't readily identify an adult who is passionate about literary criticism?

Not this PP. But I am the PP with a grad degree in English and I know many academics/scholars ... and I don't know anyone "passionate about literary criticism." Passionate about literature? Yes. Lit crit? No, lol. Those people surely exist, but you can spend a life in academia and not meet one.

Your average republican upperclass finance bro will claim to be steeped in lit crit, that is Harold Bloom and his anti-wokies nonsense.

Anonymous wrote:So your high schooler has written some killer lit crit?

OK, then…

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

Yeah ... no way. I have a grad degree in English so I've spent way too much time around way too many people who are "interested ... in literary criticism," and I don't buy this. Nope.

Anonymous wrote:DC is about to go to Duke in fall. DC applied ED which we believe made a difference. DC also had activities that showed interest in the area they interred to study (stem). I do think this helped. Know your dc is interested in different field but hopes this helps. I think demonstrated interest can really help
a student and distinguish from others. Good
Luck to your DC!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Wait, you're an academic and you can't readily identify an adult who is passionate about literary criticism?

Not this PP. But I am the PP with a grad degree in English and I know many academics/scholars ... and I don't know anyone "passionate about literary criticism." Passionate about literature? Yes. Lit crit? No, lol. Those people surely exist, but you can spend a life in academia and not meet one.

Are you thinking of literature like 50 Shades of Gray?

When people talk about literature, what do think that activity is called?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Wait, you're an academic and you can't readily identify an adult who is passionate about literary criticism?

Not this PP. But I am the PP with a grad degree in English and I know many academics/scholars ... and I don't know anyone "passionate about literary criticism." Passionate about literature? Yes. Lit crit? No, lol. Those people surely exist, but you can spend a life in academia and not meet one.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Wait, you're an academic and you can't readily identify an adult who is passionate about literary criticism?

Not this PP. But I am the PP with a grad degree in English and I know many academics/scholars ... and I don't know anyone "passionate about literary criticism." Passionate about literature? Yes. Lit crit? No, lol. Those people surely exist, but you can spend a life in academia and not meet one.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Wait, you're an academic and you can't readily identify an adult who is passionate about literary criticism?

Not this PP. But I am the PP with a grad degree in English and I know many academics/scholars ... and I don't know anyone "passionate about literary criticism." Passionate about literature? Yes. Lit crit? No, lol. Those people surely exist, but you can spend a life in academia and not meet one.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Wait, you're an academic and you can't readily identify an adult who is passionate about literary criticism?

Not this PP. But I am the PP with a grad degree in English and I know many academics/scholars ... and I don't know anyone "passionate about literary criticism." Passionate about literature? Yes. Lit crit? No, lol. Those people surely exist, but you can spend a life in academia and not meet one.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Wait, you're an academic and you can't readily identify an adult who is passionate about literary criticism?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.

I'm the PP who asked. I have one teenager who reads obsessively (no fiction, only a certain period of American history.) I've never heard of a teenager who has been passionate about literary criticism for years. Or an adult for that matter. And I'm an academic. So it sounded like a parental fantasy. Either way I doubt it makes a meaningful difference in an application to a school as competitive as Duke.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What 16/17yo has been interested "for years" in literary criticism?

It's called "enjoying reading." Some teens aren't terminally online.