Anonymous wrote:What is wrong with retractable leashes?
Many things. Here are a few:
1) They can break. So you may assume you have the ability to retract the leash when you don't actually. Since the moment when you want to retract the leash is usually the worst possible time for you to not be able to, this is a problem.
2) The encourage bad habits. People use retractable leashes because they want to let their dog on a long leash but know there are situations where they will be expected to keep them on a short leash. In practice what this means is that the dog becomes accustomed to a long leash. When what you should actually be doing is training your dog to behave appropriately on a short leash. Especially in cities, your dog should always be on a short leash in places that require leashes (short leash means control over your dog so they are required anywhere that you would need to control your dog) and then simply unleash your dog in places where a leash is not required (and train your dog for recall in these locations). Long leashes are pointless, it's a way for people who don't want to leash their dog to do so only technically.
3) Injuries are common with retractable leashes, including to the dog owner. Common injuries include rope burn when people instinctively grab the leash when the dog starts to extend it and it runs right through their grip, as well as thumb and finger issues due to the handle being ripped out of their hands or their fingers getting caught in the retracting mechanism. If the connection to the dog fails, there are the risks of bodily injuries from the metal parts coming flying at you or someone near you while it retracts.
4) There are also all the risks associated with any long leash -- risks of tripping, risks of the leash getting caught or wrapped around something, and risks of the dog running into traffic or other dangers before you are able to retract the leash.
Retractable leashes are the choice of lazy dog owners who have not taken the time to properly train their dogs. In DC, leashes are required to be 4 feet or shorter and should not be retractable. This is a good rule of thumb for leashes generally. Any longer than that and you simply no longer have a connection with the dog and you might as well not have a leash at all.