Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 22:24     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Who is the best and is it even close?

My thoughts:

T has dozens of classic songs. B has 3 or 4.

B is copying T's innovative concert movie idea.

A lot of B's lyrics are...let's just say not appropriate for younger listeners.

T is just a better singer, songwriter, and more admirable person.

Answer: Taylor Swift by a mile!





This post is a fantastic example of how Taylor fans think she's innovative (A "mastermind", even ) when she's doing something that's already been done for decades LOL. Concert films have been around for a good while now.


Haha. So true. Swifties have to get out of the bubble and widen their knowledge.

Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 22:19     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Anonymous wrote:Who is the best and is it even close?

My thoughts:

T has dozens of classic songs. B has 3 or 4.

B is copying T's innovative concert movie idea.

A lot of B's lyrics are...let's just say not appropriate for younger listeners.

T is just a better singer, songwriter, and more admirable person.

Answer: Taylor Swift by a mile!





This post is a fantastic example of how Taylor fans think she's innovative (A "mastermind", even ) when she's doing something that's already been done for decades LOL. Concert films have been around for a good while now.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 22:18     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
To be fair, both are extremely lucky with finding right people, timing and opportunities. There are probably thousands of singers as good and as hard working as they are.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 22:04     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
They are both awesome! No need to pit women against each other like this.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 21:41     Subject: Re:Beyonce vs. Taylor
They both get crowns.

I will say I have mad respect for Beyoncé for being a wife/mom and POC in a world that makes it difficult to succeed professionally when any of those things.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 21:07     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Who is the best and is it even close?

My thoughts:

T has dozens of classic songs. B has 3 or 4.

B is copying T's innovative concert movie idea.

A lot of B's lyrics are...let's just say not appropriate for younger listeners.

T is just a better singer, songwriter, and more admirable person.

Answer: Taylor Swift by a mile!





Why oh why do people put women against women in these odd competitions?
As a woman I resent it. I am a Taylor fan but kudos as well to Beyoncé. Both are fabulous icons.


This. Why do this? We can cheer both. How about Taylor v Joe Jonas, or Beyonce v Jay Z.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 21:01     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Who is the best and is it even close?

My thoughts:

T has dozens of classic songs. B has 3 or 4.

B is copying T's innovative concert movie idea.

A lot of B's lyrics are...let's just say not appropriate for younger listeners.

T is just a better singer, songwriter, and more admirable person.

Answer: Taylor Swift by a mile!





Why oh why do people put women against women in these odd competitions?
As a woman I resent it. I am a Taylor fan but kudos as well to Beyoncé. Both are fabulous icons.


Agree! They are both highly successful. There is more than one star in the sky OP. Stop tearing people down. Both have supported each other by attending for each other's movies.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 20:37     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Anonymous wrote:The Cast of Glee even had a theatrical release concert movie. Everyone does it.


It’s not the concept of a concert movie that is new. It’s that Taylor and Beyonce both bypassed a distributor and entered into agreements directly with AMC.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 20:10     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Why is Taylor more admirable? Beyonce seems like a perfectly nice woman.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 20:09     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
They’re both copying a zillion other artists who have done the same type of movies.

I prefer Taylor over Beyonce however Beyonce has a much more technically impressive voice, so no Taylor is not the better singer. Beyonce has a very large vocal range, a richer tone, and can do much more with her voice than Taylor can.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 19:16     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
I’m a fairly big gen x swiftis, but I hate this. They both have accomplished so much and do a good job of supporting each other. I enjoy Bey’s activism and her lovely family.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 13:56     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Anonymous wrote:Who is the best and is it even close?

My thoughts:

T has dozens of classic songs. B has 3 or 4.

B is copying T's innovative concert movie idea.

A lot of B's lyrics are...let's just say not appropriate for younger listeners.

T is just a better singer, songwriter, and more admirable person.

Answer: Taylor Swift by a mile!





Why oh why do people put women against women in these odd competitions?
As a woman I resent it. I am a Taylor fan but kudos as well to Beyoncé. Both are fabulous icons.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 13:54     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
So I guess the existence of this thread is proof that the Swifties are coming out of the “never compare women” stage.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 13:27     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
Anonymous wrote:Who is the best and is it even close?

My thoughts:

T has dozens of classic songs. B has 3 or 4.

B is copying T's innovative concert movie idea.

A lot of B's lyrics are...let's just say not appropriate for younger listeners.

T is just a better singer, songwriter, and more admirable person.

Answer: Taylor Swift by a mile!





I don’t really understand what you mean by an admirable person as compared to Beyoncé. But I disagree that Taylor is a better singer than Beyoncé. I don’t even think it’s close.
Anonymous
Post 12/02/2023 10:20     Subject: Beyonce vs. Taylor
The Cast of Glee even had a theatrical release concert movie. Everyone does it.