Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So many of you think the worst of your in-laws! Assume good intentions. It’s sweet of them to send something. Who cares if the gift itself is a miss. They haven’t had a 2 year old in 30+ years and don’t remember that they’re probably not eating candy yet. Just say thank you.

She told them not to do it. No need to thank someone for ignoring a request. Thank them when they are kind. Thank them when they babysit. Thank them for being fun company when you see them. No need to thank someone for ignoring a boundary.

No, OP said the grandparents know they don't give the kid candy. And I think extending some grace is the right thing to do. I don't KNOW what my nieces and nephews are allowed. It's been a while since I had a 2 year old. Why not be grateful there are people in your life who care enough to send a gift? You people obsessed with boundaries are going to have a long, lonely life.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I used to get so worked up about this sort of issues with my MIL, who never respected our values and rules. Well, my kids are now college aged and at some point she stopped sending them gifts, and with maturity I can see at least in part that is my fault because I probably scared her off so much from gift giving since many of her gifts prompted me to remind her of our rules and why she was disregarding them. If I could do it over, I’d just smile, say thank you, snap a pic for her of grandkids and gifts, and find my own way of dealing with the gift that matched my own values (eg, donating the unecessary clothes, giving away the candy, etc). Life is too short to get so worked up about gifts.

I love this perspective.

This! Some of my best memories of my grandparents were that they were co-conspirators in "rebelling" against my parents. If not for my grandmother, I would not have gotten piereced ears or gone to any concerts before I was 18.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I used to get so worked up about this sort of issues with my MIL, who never respected our values and rules. Well, my kids are now college aged and at some point she stopped sending them gifts, and with maturity I can see at least in part that is my fault because I probably scared her off so much from gift giving since many of her gifts prompted me to remind her of our rules and why she was disregarding them. If I could do it over, I’d just smile, say thank you, snap a pic for her of grandkids and gifts, and find my own way of dealing with the gift that matched my own values (eg, donating the unecessary clothes, giving away the candy, etc). Life is too short to get so worked up about gifts.

+100

+100. In ~3 years there will be so much you cannot control and they will eat all kinds of crap. Just say thanks for thinking of Larla and move on.

You need to be gracious and thank them for the gift and then use that as an opportunity to mention again that you don't allow candy. You can say we took a few pieces out for her as a "special treat" and then shared your beautiful gift with our neighborhood trick or treaters who were most appreciative.

Anonymous wrote:I wouldn’t take a pic if the kid with it, but I would say thank you.

+1

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So many of you think the worst of your in-laws! Assume good intentions. It’s sweet of them to send something. Who cares if the gift itself is a miss. They haven’t had a 2 year old in 30+ years and don’t remember that they’re probably not eating candy yet. Just say thank you.

She told them not to do it. No need to thank someone for ignoring a request. Thank them when they are kind. Thank them when they babysit. Thank them for being fun company when you see them. No need to thank someone for ignoring a boundary.

I think a lot of grandparents send candy for Halloween or Valentines day. This is SO minor in the scheme of things. It probably made the grandparents happy to send it and/or remember their grandparents doing stuff like this. Don't stop the gifts now because it will have effects later. I know my older kids would love a box of candy for Halloween from grandparents.

And yes, you say thank you any time that someone gives you a gift. No matter how unwelcome it is.

Just say thank you and eat it yourself. Or bring it into work. Or give the box to a neighbor.

I do let my 2 year old have treats sometimes and I'm pretty crunchy. It's all about balance.

It’s ok if your kid eats one piece of candy on camera.
Give away the rest.
Win win!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So many of you think the worst of your in-laws! Assume good intentions. It’s sweet of them to send something. Who cares if the gift itself is a miss. They haven’t had a 2 year old in 30+ years and don’t remember that they’re probably not eating candy yet. Just say thank you.

She told them not to do it. No need to thank someone for ignoring a request. Thank them when they are kind. Thank them when they babysit. Thank them for being fun company when you see them. No need to thank someone for ignoring a boundary.

I don’t know. It isn’t clear she told them “don’t ever send candy ever.” Or if they just generally know these people don’t keep candy around for their kid, but assumed Halloween was an exception. I’m pretty darn good at boundaries and I would just thank these people and move on.

As I said before, maybe these are the worst in-laws ever. Or maybe they are just normal people who think there are occasional exceptions to rules for fun events. Which is where most parents land by early elementary. I mean, I had a lot of boundaries around protecting my kid’s sleep, but eventually there were exceptions to the rule. And I didn’t think grandparents were super horrible people if they suggested my kid stay up late. I might not have kept the kids up late, but I didn’t hate them and feel like I needed to call them out or anything.

Anonymous wrote:So many of you think the worst of your in-laws! Assume good intentions. It’s sweet of them to send something. Who cares if the gift itself is a miss. They haven’t had a 2 year old in 30+ years and don’t remember that they’re probably not eating candy yet. Just say thank you.

She told them not to do it. No need to thank someone for ignoring a request. Thank them when they are kind. Thank them when they babysit. Thank them for being fun company when you see them. No need to thank someone for ignoring a boundary.

OP you have to find a way to calm down. You can either calm down about the candy consumption, or calm down about the gift management.

Seriously no one is out to get you here or trying to work you into a tizzy. Yes, we should expect our friends and family to respect our boundaries. But you also have to learn to get along a little bit and not make a federal case of every mistake or minor provocation. You can’t let every little thing like this derail you. That’s an impossible way to live.

I mean they sent candy for HALLOWEEN, a day that is basically about kids eating candy. This has to be your first child. Are you planning on banning your kid from participating in trick or treating? This does not seem like the boundary hill to die on. Relax.

So many of you think the worst of your in-laws! Assume good intentions. It’s sweet of them to send something. Who cares if the gift itself is a miss. They haven’t had a 2 year old in 30+ years and don’t remember that they’re probably not eating candy yet. Just say thank you.

Anonymous wrote:Grandparents know we don’t give our 2 year old candy. They sent a huge box of expensive candy for Halloween with a note that said “To Larla, love grandparents”.

What should we do? With their other gifts, I usually send a photo of the kid with the gift but we have no intention of giving kid the giant box of candy. Just text thank you? Is it disingenuous to do so when we are really just going to chuck the box/donate? I am also annoyed they would give this and would almost just rather ignore the “gift” and make it clear we do not appreciate this.

Politely thank them and then tell them not to send gifts of candy/cookies/pastries as well as no sugar free candy. You have to tell them so they know not to send the products for any upcoming events like Thanksgiving, Christmas, etc. You can give it away or stick it out if having large number of people over.

Just say thank you and move on. You are going to feel very silly about this in a couple of years as your kid plows through candy at various Halloween related events.

I mean, maybe you have the worst in laws ever, but this isn’t the right example. Or maybe, you have totally normal in laws. Hard to tell.