IME often the kids who “would have benefitted from an earlier start” for that kind of thing really needed an extra year or two without it, because they weren’t developmentally ready.

Homework in 1st and 2nd really just assesses whether the child is lucky enough to have an adult who can say, ”okay, let’s do homework, what do you have, here are the directions, etc.”

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A 2nd grader doesn't need homework. Limit their electronics, let them run around outside with friends, and make sure they read, read, read.

Exactly! They’re already at school for a full day. Why do you need your 7-year old to have homework?

It’s to reinforce the day lesson, and demonstrate competence and understanding independence of the classroom.

It also builds executive function to track, plan, and turn in homework, projects etc. if everything is just pop and do what is told in class, there is no independence required.

This does not need to be done in 2nd grade. These skills can be started in 4th and still be successful. The difference between 2nd and 4th grade is HUGE. The leap in 3rd from "little kid" to "big kid" is insane. Don't rush it.

I think that is kid dependent — ours would have benefited from an earlier start.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A 2nd grader doesn't need homework. Limit their electronics, let them run around outside with friends, and make sure they read, read, read.

Exactly! They’re already at school for a full day. Why do you need your 7-year old to have homework?

It’s to reinforce the day lesson, and demonstrate competence and understanding independence of the classroom.

It also builds executive function to track, plan, and turn in homework, projects etc. if everything is just pop and do what is told in class, there is no independence required.

This does not need to be done in 2nd grade. These skills can be started in 4th and still be successful. The difference between 2nd and 4th grade is HUGE. The leap in 3rd from "little kid" to "big kid" is insane. Don't rush it.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A 2nd grader doesn't need homework. Limit their electronics, let them run around outside with friends, and make sure they read, read, read.

Exactly! They’re already at school for a full day. Why do you need your 7-year old to have homework?

It’s to reinforce the day lesson, and demonstrate competence and understanding independence of the classroom.

It also builds executive function to track, plan, and turn in homework, projects etc. if everything is just pop and do what is told in class, there is no independence required.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A 2nd grader doesn't need homework. Limit their electronics, let them run around outside with friends, and make sure they read, read, read.

Exactly! They’re already at school for a full day. Why do you need your 7-year old to have homework?

Haha, have you ever seen the schedule for an elementary student? They spend maybe 2 hours on academics and half of that is with the iPad

Anonymous wrote:We didn’t get homework till ninth grade lol! The work was so easy that my kids finished all her middle school work in class and never had homework unless she was studying for a test.

Same.

We did private 6-8 for one and they breezed through HS and got into tier 1 school.

Our APS only child will probably not have that glide path and will finish hs and probably another route to college. Hopefully….but 6-8th in private was huge for structure and study habits.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I skipped BTSN. Not really concerned or surprised by anything OP wrote, because this is our 10th year in APS. However, what is AAC? Or what does that acronym represent? I’ve only ever heard of “gifted” and “gifted resource teacher” or seen that written anywhere. Care to enlighten me?

Me, too, please?

AAC=Advanced Academic Coach. Our reading teachers are now also called "reading coaches". Our AAC is the same person who was the "gifted resource" person.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I skipped BTSN. Not really concerned or surprised by anything OP wrote, because this is our 10th year in APS. However, what is AAC? Or what does that acronym represent? I’ve only ever heard of “gifted” and “gifted resource teacher” or seen that written anywhere. Care to enlighten me?

Me, too, please?

It’s just what they are calling gifted now.

What do the letters stand for and did we really just change it so it’s be more like FFX?

Anonymous wrote:A 2nd grader doesn't need homework. Limit their electronics, let them run around outside with friends, and make sure they read, read, read.

Exactly! They’re already at school for a full day. Why do you need your 7-year old to have homework?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I skipped BTSN. Not really concerned or surprised by anything OP wrote, because this is our 10th year in APS. However, what is AAC? Or what does that acronym represent? I’ve only ever heard of “gifted” and “gifted resource teacher” or seen that written anywhere. Care to enlighten me?

Me, too, please?

It’s just what they are calling gifted now.

Our DD was in K at parochial (we moved her there as it was Covid and public was fully virtual, while they were in-person). She had homework 3-4 nights/ week. Ok, it involved mostly pasting, cutting, and coloring (often of alphabet letters) but it was useful and helped her learn her reading and writing better.

Anonymous wrote:I skipped BTSN. Not really concerned or surprised by anything OP wrote, because this is our 10th year in APS. However, what is AAC? Or what does that acronym represent? I’ve only ever heard of “gifted” and “gifted resource teacher” or seen that written anywhere. Care to enlighten me?

Me, too, please?

I skipped BTSN. Not really concerned or surprised by anything OP wrote, because this is our 10th year in APS. However, what is AAC? Or what does that acronym represent? I’ve only ever heard of “gifted” and “gifted resource teacher” or seen that written anywhere. Care to enlighten me?

Anonymous wrote:A 2nd grader doesn't need homework. Limit their electronics, let them run around outside with friends, and make sure they read, read, read.

x1 million

We didn’t get homework till ninth grade lol! The work was so easy that my kids finished all her middle school work in class and never had homework unless she was studying for a test.