Anonymous
Post 05/12/2023 08:39     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

For a talented/competitive child, you attend practices prior to tryouts and then go to the tryout as a formality. Your interaction with the coach prior to tryouts will likely inform you how much they want you.

For your less talented child, just avoid tryouts by finding a small club where there’s only one team and they play on a league and division where the kid is not the best kid but gets plenty of playing time.

Parents just really need to manage their kids expectations better and have a realistic view of their kids abilities.
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2023 08:33     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The past three pages are just distraction. What matters is that your kid plays travel.

EVERY kid should play travel in at least ONE sport by 8th grade. EVERY kid. With dedication, hard work and putting skin in the game, any kid can play travel in something,

Kids need to know they’re elite in something. It helps them understand who are winners, who will embarrass you and who hurts your reputation and social standing.

It’s stupid to try to play football and, for example, do glee club or math “team” or something. That doesn’t work. Girls get all confused and like “who are you?” and the football coaches doubt your commitment with good reason.

In high school you need to know where you stand and then elevate your place as high as possible. Travel gives you the foundation. LEGO and Minecraft don’t.


The problem with this area is I can’t tell if this is a troll or if you’re serious. Because who’s I really hope this is a joke post, even odds it’s not.


Nah. Too over the top to be clever.
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2023 08:31     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:The past three pages are just distraction. What matters is that your kid plays travel.

EVERY kid should play travel in at least ONE sport by 8th grade. EVERY kid. With dedication, hard work and putting skin in the game, any kid can play travel in something,

Kids need to know they’re elite in something. It helps them understand who are winners, who will embarrass you and who hurts your reputation and social standing.

It’s stupid to try to play football and, for example, do glee club or math “team” or something. That doesn’t work. Girls get all confused and like “who are you?” and the football coaches doubt your commitment with good reason.

In high school you need to know where you stand and then elevate your place as high as possible. Travel gives you the foundation. LEGO and Minecraft don’t.


Very bizarre take.
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2023 08:29     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:This is one of those crazy Type A/rampant untreated anxiety/raising children is a blood sport DC things that absolutely drives me crazy… and that I will obsess over and over and over…


This has nothing to do with DC. This is rampant all over the country.
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2023 07:26     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:The past three pages are just distraction. What matters is that your kid plays travel.

EVERY kid should play travel in at least ONE sport by 8th grade. EVERY kid. With dedication, hard work and putting skin in the game, any kid can play travel in something,

Kids need to know they’re elite in something. It helps them understand who are winners, who will embarrass you and who hurts your reputation and social standing.

It’s stupid to try to play football and, for example, do glee club or math “team” or something. That doesn’t work. Girls get all confused and like “who are you?” and the football coaches doubt your commitment with good reason.

In high school you need to know where you stand and then elevate your place as high as possible. Travel gives you the foundation. LEGO and Minecraft don’t.


The problem with this area is I can’t tell if this is a troll or if you’re serious. Because who’s I really hope this is a joke post, even odds it’s not.
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2023 07:15     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

The past three pages are just distraction. What matters is that your kid plays travel.

EVERY kid should play travel in at least ONE sport by 8th grade. EVERY kid. With dedication, hard work and putting skin in the game, any kid can play travel in something,

Kids need to know they’re elite in something. It helps them understand who are winners, who will embarrass you and who hurts your reputation and social standing.

It’s stupid to try to play football and, for example, do glee club or math “team” or something. That doesn’t work. Girls get all confused and like “who are you?” and the football coaches doubt your commitment with good reason.

In high school you need to know where you stand and then elevate your place as high as possible. Travel gives you the foundation. LEGO and Minecraft don’t.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 21:48     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:It's pretty simple and straightforward - if the club tells you we'll get back to you in 2 days, and you haven't heard back in 2 days, then go ahead and assume your child did not make the team.

If they end up reaching out to you after the 2 days to welcome your child to the team, well, lucky you. Cause your child literally did not make the team, they literally choose other's over your kid. It's just a spot that wasn't intended for your child ended opening up.

Not sure why this is hard?


Not sure why it’s so hard to understand for you-op’s complaint is abt telling the kids they will all hear in three days. If it’s if you don’t hear in three days it’s a no unless we have someone decline that’s completely fine, they should just tell the kids that (if they’re telling them a timeline.)
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 21:37     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

just tell your kid that they didn't make it. Explain to them the process. Pretty simple
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 19:53     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

This is one of those crazy Type A/rampant untreated anxiety/raising children is a blood sport DC things that absolutely drives me crazy… and that I will obsess over and over and over…
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 19:49     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:It's pretty simple and straightforward - if the club tells you we'll get back to you in 2 days, and you haven't heard back in 2 days, then go ahead and assume your child did not make the team.

If they end up reaching out to you after the 2 days to welcome your child to the team, well, lucky you. Cause your child literally did not make the team, they literally choose other's over your kid. It's just a spot that wasn't intended for your child ended opening up.

Not sure why this is hard?


It’s actually not that simple.

For the scenario

Bernice delays committing to a spot on team cucumber because team radish hasn’t gotten back to her yet. And team radish is waiting for Cornelia to accept before letting Bernice have the spot. Meanwhile Cornelia wants a spot on team potato, who is waiting to hear back from Dorothy. And Dorothy hasn’t committed to team potato because she wants Bernice’s spot on team cucumber. It could go on forever.

If Cornelia doesn’t delay and takes the offer from team Radish, Bernice will hear no from them and take the team Cucumber spot. Dorothy will hear no from them and take Team Potato.

But if Cornelia holds out too long, team Radish moves on and gives an offer to Bernice. Bernice is ecstatic and gives up her team Cucumber spot. Dorothy is now Team Cucumber. Team Potato wonders where it all went wrong.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 18:51     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The only way for teams to fulfill the promise of a timely answer is if families and clubs went through a matching process like public schools in ny or medical residency. I don’t think families or teams want that, so it’s inevitable that some kids get spots right away and some kids get spots a little late, and some kids get spots right before the season starts. There will always be a good number of people holding each other’s tail waiting for someone to make a decision and commit to a spot or free it up.

Bernice delays committing to a spot on team cucumber because team radish hasn’t gotten back to her yet. And team radish is waiting for Cornelia to accept before letting Bernice have the spot. Meanwhile Cornelia wants a spot on team potato, who is waiting to hear back from Dorothy. And Dorothy hasn’t committed to team potato because she wants Bernice’s spot on team cucumber. It could go on forever.


hahaha, love this!

Tryouts are stressful, good luck to everyone out there, especially to those whose kid is not the top player, or at least not perceived as such during tryouts.


This is our first season dealing with it as "veterans" and man this is true. I have way too many side email chains and chats with different parents right now. I'm so afraid I'm going to respond to the wrong one with the wrong thing. I was not expecting to get involved in any drama but I guess this is what happens when certain parents start reaching out because they want to know who's staying, who's unhappy, etc...


+1

It’s a weird space where I’m afraid to say anything to anyone, while also hoping to find out whether my kid will land with friends.
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 17:13     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The only way for teams to fulfill the promise of a timely answer is if families and clubs went through a matching process like public schools in ny or medical residency. I don’t think families or teams want that, so it’s inevitable that some kids get spots right away and some kids get spots a little late, and some kids get spots right before the season starts. There will always be a good number of people holding each other’s tail waiting for someone to make a decision and commit to a spot or free it up.

Bernice delays committing to a spot on team cucumber because team radish hasn’t gotten back to her yet. And team radish is waiting for Cornelia to accept before letting Bernice have the spot. Meanwhile Cornelia wants a spot on team potato, who is waiting to hear back from Dorothy. And Dorothy hasn’t committed to team potato because she wants Bernice’s spot on team cucumber. It could go on forever.


hahaha, love this!

Tryouts are stressful, good luck to everyone out there, especially to those whose kid is not the top player, or at least not perceived as such during tryouts.


This is our first season dealing with it as "veterans" and man this is true. I have way too many side email chains and chats with different parents right now. I'm so afraid I'm going to respond to the wrong one with the wrong thing. I was not expecting to get involved in any drama but I guess this is what happens when certain parents start reaching out because they want to know who's staying, who's unhappy, etc...
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 17:07     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It's pretty simple and straightforward - if the club tells you we'll get back to you in 2 days, and you haven't heard back in 2 days, then go ahead and assume your child did not make the team.

If they end up reaching out to you after the 2 days to welcome your child to the team, well, lucky you. Cause your child literally did not make the team, they literally choose other's over your kid. It's just a spot that wasn't intended for your child ended opening up.

Honestly, having experienced this from several perspectives, it’s really not that simple. Names do indeed get left off spreadsheets, so people stress when clubs thought an offer had gone out.

Not sure why this is hard?


Not sure why you have to be rude. It's hard because these are kids, sometimes pretty young kids. To these kids, this is super important in their life and if they're told by a grownup they'll get an answer in two days, they believe it. If the club, which in our case is well-established (and from what I've heard, does this kind of thing every year frankly) wants to give players 10 days to decide whether to accept an offer, that's totally fine. But if they tell a 10-year-old they'll have an answer in two days, they should stick to that. It should not be four days later (or longer).

Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 16:46     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:It's pretty simple and straightforward - if the club tells you we'll get back to you in 2 days, and you haven't heard back in 2 days, then go ahead and assume your child did not make the team.

If they end up reaching out to you after the 2 days to welcome your child to the team, well, lucky you. Cause your child literally did not make the team, they literally choose other's over your kid. It's just a spot that wasn't intended for your child ended opening up.

Honestly, having experienced this from several perspectives, it’s really not that simple. Names do indeed get left off spreadsheets, so people stress when clubs thought an offer had gone out.

Not sure why this is hard?
Anonymous
Post 05/11/2023 16:35     Subject: A general note to clubs about tryouts

Anonymous wrote:The only way for teams to fulfill the promise of a timely answer is if families and clubs went through a matching process like public schools in ny or medical residency. I don’t think families or teams want that, so it’s inevitable that some kids get spots right away and some kids get spots a little late, and some kids get spots right before the season starts. There will always be a good number of people holding each other’s tail waiting for someone to make a decision and commit to a spot or free it up.

Bernice delays committing to a spot on team cucumber because team radish hasn’t gotten back to her yet. And team radish is waiting for Cornelia to accept before letting Bernice have the spot. Meanwhile Cornelia wants a spot on team potato, who is waiting to hear back from Dorothy. And Dorothy hasn’t committed to team potato because she wants Bernice’s spot on team cucumber. It could go on forever.


hahaha, love this!

Tryouts are stressful, good luck to everyone out there, especially to those whose kid is not the top player, or at least not perceived as such during tryouts.