Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 20:15     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Ben and Jerry's stores make a yummy ice cream cake.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 20:11     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Dairy queen oreo!
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 17:46     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Definitely Cold Stone! Just make sure you leave out to thaw a bit. They freeze very solid!
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 15:53     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Carvel all the way.

The only time I had something that seemed possibly better was Giffords ice cream cake. RIP.
Anonymous
Post 05/03/2023 22:55     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:Fudgy the whale.

Haters and their foo foo gourmet crap can buzz off. Fudgy reigns supreme.
Runner up spot goes to Cookie Puss.
Anonymous
Post 05/03/2023 09:44     Subject: Best ice cream cake
I worked at Baskin-Robbins, and that cake came to us frozen and was probably 10 years old. Lol! Disgusting. Definitely recommend one of the local ice cream shops in your neighborhood. Like mentioned before, Toby's in Arlington. They make a fantastic cake! Two layers of ice cream with a crunchy cookie layer in between.
Anonymous
Post 05/03/2023 09:41     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:Fudgy the whale.

Haters and their foo foo gourmet crap can buzz off. Fudgy reigns supreme.


Can't believe it took this long for someone to namecheck Fudgy!

We've had a bunch of ice cream cakes - the favorite was one from BR that had cookies and cream ice cream and also some real cake in it.
Anonymous
Post 05/03/2023 08:59     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Cold Stone ice cream is bad—they put in so many emulsifiers so it stretches when they mix it it ruins the texture.

Baskin Robbins is the best. If you’re willing to spend more you can get one that’s all ice cream, no cakes, with 2 or three flavors.

Dairy Queen isn’t technically ice cream, it’s ice milk.
Anonymous
Post 05/03/2023 08:38     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Fudgy the whale.

Haters and their foo foo gourmet crap can buzz off. Fudgy reigns supreme.
Anonymous
Post 05/03/2023 08:06     Subject: Best ice cream cake
OP here. We prefer no cake, all ice cream so I’ll check out those recommendations. Thank you for the great ideas! I welcome other thoughts!
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2023 23:36     Subject: Re:Best ice cream cake


not technically cake, but I love Baskin-Robbin’s Turtle Pie.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2023 20:48     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Coldstone is always good but the last time we had it, we had one piece sitting there on the table for 30 minutes and the ice cream oddly... didn't melt. hmmmm. But a crowd pleaser!
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2023 20:40     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Milwaukee Frozen Custard in Chantilly (Route 50 near Route 28) makes amazing Frozen Custard cakes.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2023 20:39     Subject: Re:Best ice cream cake
DQ!
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2023 20:36     Subject: Re:Best ice cream cake
OP, clearly the first step is to figure out whether or not you want cake in your ice cream cake, and then go from there.