Anonymous
02/15/2023 19:01
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
I've been pondering the same question as OP and currently using a 70% estimate in my planning. Concerned about SS and Medicare being reduced by politicians though. Are you all relying on SS in your projections?
Anonymous
02/15/2023 18:29
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Even if your retirement income is taxable, it may be so at a lower rate. Also, no payroll taxes. There’s an 8% savings right there.
Anonymous
02/15/2023 12:25
Subject: Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The biggest thing most people forget is that once you're IN retirement you stop SAVING for retirement.
Chances are, you're already living on less than 100% of your actual income, because you're socking a chunk of it away.
Start with your actual take home pay, subtract expenses you won't have in retirement and add/increase expenses that could rise. You'll eat out more, travel more, take up hobbies, your cars may need work/replacing, house will be older/need work. Etc.
Better to be conservative, but I agree most retirees with few major expenses don't need 80% of their income to live well.
You also stop paying social security and medicare taxes.
dp.. really? They don't take out ss and medicare taxes on retirement distributions?
They are payroll taxes so you don't pay them if you are not receiving wages.
This explains it in more detail: https://www.realized1031.com/blog/do-you-pay-fica-on-retirement-income
Anonymous
02/15/2023 11:58
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I've been retired for a little under a decade and just turned 60. My spouse stayed at home and our kids are long out of college and launched so she is retired as well. We still have a mortgage because we have a very low interest rate so there's no reason to pay it off. We live a very, very nice life in the DMV, with a home in a highly desirable part of the city and a second home in the country where we also spend a large amount of time. I track my expenses with the personal cap app.
Removing mortgage payments from our expenses -- because I know others will insist on paying theirs off before retiring, for whatever (often irrational) reason -- here are our average yearly expenses for the last three years, from highest to lowest:
Taxes (federal and DC income and DC and second home property taxes): 35k
Healthcare (premiums, deductibles and all out of pockets): 28k
Home maintenance (for both the DC and second home, including cleaning services, lawn services, swimming pool maintenance in the second home, and all general maintenance on both houses): 26k
General merchandise (basically every "thing" we buy): 18k
Travel: 13k (average probably lower than the past because of covid)
Car (gas and maintenance, including buying a late model used one): 14k
Groceries: 12k
Restaurants: 8k
Utilities: 7k
Cable/internet: 5k
Gifts: 4k
Insurance (home & auto): 3.5k
Phones: 3.3k
Miscellaneous (assistance to elderly mother, entertainment, cash withdrawals from ATMs, gifts to charity, clothing): 6k
TOTAL per year average: $183k
So, for $183k a year, we are paying our taxes, paying for health care, managing to high end homes, traveling, eating out, buying decent cars, helping out our mother, etc. It's a very nice life, and it's affordable.
Some DCUM posters worry too much.
How do you manage to pay so little federal and state tax on 150k in income
Careful planning and relying on capital gains rather than withdrawing from my retirement accounts as much as possible. My tax bill really varies each year depending on how well I manage to do that. For example, for the year that just ended my federal tax bill is less than $500. The year before it was more like $40k.
This will change when you hit RMDs.
Tell me something I don’t know. I’m also 15 years away.
You may know, but many people don’t take RMDs into account when saving. Too many posters on this board assume all of their retirement savings should be in qualified plans.
Meant to add — & because most tend to save in qualified plans, they can’t do what you’re doing even before they hit RMDs.
DP.. Yes, this is why to me it makes sense to take social security early if you have a lot in your retirement accounts. If you have a lot in those accounts, and wait to take social security at 70 so you can claim more, it may bump up your tax bracket.
We are planning to take ss at 62, combined with pulling out money from our Roth and 401k to keep our taxes low. SS is not taxed in our state, and I believe it's only taxed at 85% at the federal level.
When we hit 70+, I anticipate that we will slow down a lot, so we won't need as much to live on.
Anonymous
02/15/2023 11:54
Subject: Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The biggest thing most people forget is that once you're IN retirement you stop SAVING for retirement.
Chances are, you're already living on less than 100% of your actual income, because you're socking a chunk of it away.
Start with your actual take home pay, subtract expenses you won't have in retirement and add/increase expenses that could rise. You'll eat out more, travel more, take up hobbies, your cars may need work/replacing, house will be older/need work. Etc.
Better to be conservative, but I agree most retirees with few major expenses don't need 80% of their income to live well.
You also stop paying social security and medicare taxes.
dp.. really? They don't take out ss and medicare taxes on retirement distributions?
Anonymous
02/15/2023 11:49
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Plan for the worst, hope for the best. My FIL went back to work to support my SIL and her kids.
Anonymous
02/15/2023 11:45
Subject: Post-retirement spending
80% feels really high.
When I retire I will:
1) Have recently jettisoned all kids from the house
2) Will recently have paid off both houses
3) Will no longer be contributing a substantial % of my income to retirement funds
4) Will no longer be contributing to 529 funds
The above alone represents probably 50% of my pre-tax income.
I know I'll have more time to fill which often means spending money, but I think I'll be able to fill much of it with low-cost activities.
When I retire I will:
1) Have recently jettisoned all kids from the house
2) Will recently have paid off both houses
3) Will no longer be contributing a substantial % of my income to retirement funds
4) Will no longer be contributing to 529 funds
The above alone represents probably 50% of my pre-tax income.
I know I'll have more time to fill which often means spending money, but I think I'll be able to fill much of it with low-cost activities.
Anonymous
02/15/2023 00:05
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I've been retired for a little under a decade and just turned 60. My spouse stayed at home and our kids are long out of college and launched so she is retired as well. We still have a mortgage because we have a very low interest rate so there's no reason to pay it off. We live a very, very nice life in the DMV, with a home in a highly desirable part of the city and a second home in the country where we also spend a large amount of time. I track my expenses with the personal cap app.
Removing mortgage payments from our expenses -- because I know others will insist on paying theirs off before retiring, for whatever (often irrational) reason -- here are our average yearly expenses for the last three years, from highest to lowest:
Taxes (federal and DC income and DC and second home property taxes): 35k
Healthcare (premiums, deductibles and all out of pockets): 28k
Home maintenance (for both the DC and second home, including cleaning services, lawn services, swimming pool maintenance in the second home, and all general maintenance on both houses): 26k
General merchandise (basically every "thing" we buy): 18k
Travel: 13k (average probably lower than the past because of covid)
Car (gas and maintenance, including buying a late model used one): 14k
Groceries: 12k
Restaurants: 8k
Utilities: 7k
Cable/internet: 5k
Gifts: 4k
Insurance (home & auto): 3.5k
Phones: 3.3k
Miscellaneous (assistance to elderly mother, entertainment, cash withdrawals from ATMs, gifts to charity, clothing): 6k
TOTAL per year average: $183k
So, for $183k a year, we are paying our taxes, paying for health care, managing to high end homes, traveling, eating out, buying decent cars, helping out our mother, etc. It's a very nice life, and it's affordable.
Some DCUM posters worry too much.
How do you manage to pay so little federal and state tax on 150k in income
Careful planning and relying on capital gains rather than withdrawing from my retirement accounts as much as possible. My tax bill really varies each year depending on how well I manage to do that. For example, for the year that just ended my federal tax bill is less than $500. The year before it was more like $40k.
This will change when you hit RMDs.
Tell me something I don’t know. I’m also 15 years away.
You may know, but many people don’t take RMDs into account when saving. Too many posters on this board assume all of their retirement savings should be in qualified plans.
Meant to add — & because most tend to save in qualified plans, they can’t do what you’re doing even before they hit RMDs.
Anonymous
02/15/2023 00:03
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I've been retired for a little under a decade and just turned 60. My spouse stayed at home and our kids are long out of college and launched so she is retired as well. We still have a mortgage because we have a very low interest rate so there's no reason to pay it off. We live a very, very nice life in the DMV, with a home in a highly desirable part of the city and a second home in the country where we also spend a large amount of time. I track my expenses with the personal cap app.
Removing mortgage payments from our expenses -- because I know others will insist on paying theirs off before retiring, for whatever (often irrational) reason -- here are our average yearly expenses for the last three years, from highest to lowest:
Taxes (federal and DC income and DC and second home property taxes): 35k
Healthcare (premiums, deductibles and all out of pockets): 28k
Home maintenance (for both the DC and second home, including cleaning services, lawn services, swimming pool maintenance in the second home, and all general maintenance on both houses): 26k
General merchandise (basically every "thing" we buy): 18k
Travel: 13k (average probably lower than the past because of covid)
Car (gas and maintenance, including buying a late model used one): 14k
Groceries: 12k
Restaurants: 8k
Utilities: 7k
Cable/internet: 5k
Gifts: 4k
Insurance (home & auto): 3.5k
Phones: 3.3k
Miscellaneous (assistance to elderly mother, entertainment, cash withdrawals from ATMs, gifts to charity, clothing): 6k
TOTAL per year average: $183k
So, for $183k a year, we are paying our taxes, paying for health care, managing to high end homes, traveling, eating out, buying decent cars, helping out our mother, etc. It's a very nice life, and it's affordable.
Some DCUM posters worry too much.
How do you manage to pay so little federal and state tax on 150k in income
Careful planning and relying on capital gains rather than withdrawing from my retirement accounts as much as possible. My tax bill really varies each year depending on how well I manage to do that. For example, for the year that just ended my federal tax bill is less than $500. The year before it was more like $40k.
This will change when you hit RMDs.
Tell me something I don’t know. I’m also 15 years away.
You may know, but many people don’t take RMDs into account when saving. Too many posters on this board assume all of their retirement savings should be in qualified plans.
Anonymous
02/14/2023 12:39
Subject: Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:The biggest thing most people forget is that once you're IN retirement you stop SAVING for retirement.
Chances are, you're already living on less than 100% of your actual income, because you're socking a chunk of it away.
Start with your actual take home pay, subtract expenses you won't have in retirement and add/increase expenses that could rise. You'll eat out more, travel more, take up hobbies, your cars may need work/replacing, house will be older/need work. Etc.
Better to be conservative, but I agree most retirees with few major expenses don't need 80% of their income to live well.
You also stop paying social security and medicare taxes.
Anonymous
02/14/2023 01:43
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I've been retired for a little under a decade and just turned 60. My spouse stayed at home and our kids are long out of college and launched so she is retired as well. We still have a mortgage because we have a very low interest rate so there's no reason to pay it off. We live a very, very nice life in the DMV, with a home in a highly desirable part of the city and a second home in the country where we also spend a large amount of time. I track my expenses with the personal cap app.
Removing mortgage payments from our expenses -- because I know others will insist on paying theirs off before retiring, for whatever (often irrational) reason -- here are our average yearly expenses for the last three years, from highest to lowest:
Taxes (federal and DC income and DC and second home property taxes): 35k
Healthcare (premiums, deductibles and all out of pockets): 28k
Home maintenance (for both the DC and second home, including cleaning services, lawn services, swimming pool maintenance in the second home, and all general maintenance on both houses): 26k
General merchandise (basically every "thing" we buy): 18k
Travel: 13k (average probably lower than the past because of covid)
Car (gas and maintenance, including buying a late model used one): 14k
Groceries: 12k
Restaurants: 8k
Utilities: 7k
Cable/internet: 5k
Gifts: 4k
Insurance (home & auto): 3.5k
Phones: 3.3k
Miscellaneous (assistance to elderly mother, entertainment, cash withdrawals from ATMs, gifts to charity, clothing): 6k
TOTAL per year average: $183k
So, for $183k a year, we are paying our taxes, paying for health care, managing to high end homes, traveling, eating out, buying decent cars, helping out our mother, etc. It's a very nice life, and it's affordable.
Some DCUM posters worry too much.
How do you manage to pay so little federal and state tax on 150k in income
Careful planning and relying on capital gains rather than withdrawing from my retirement accounts as much as possible. My tax bill really varies each year depending on how well I manage to do that. For example, for the year that just ended my federal tax bill is less than $500. The year before it was more like $40k.
This will change when you hit RMDs.
Tell me something I don’t know. I’m also 15 years away.
Anonymous
02/13/2023 23:36
Subject: Post-retirement spending
Agree that this varies dramatically and you should base it on what you spend now (not your income). IME, expenses don’t really go down, they just shift. I wouldn’t count on spending a lot less than you do now.
Anonymous
02/13/2023 23:34
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I've been retired for a little under a decade and just turned 60. My spouse stayed at home and our kids are long out of college and launched so she is retired as well. We still have a mortgage because we have a very low interest rate so there's no reason to pay it off. We live a very, very nice life in the DMV, with a home in a highly desirable part of the city and a second home in the country where we also spend a large amount of time. I track my expenses with the personal cap app.
Removing mortgage payments from our expenses -- because I know others will insist on paying theirs off before retiring, for whatever (often irrational) reason -- here are our average yearly expenses for the last three years, from highest to lowest:
Taxes (federal and DC income and DC and second home property taxes): 35k
Healthcare (premiums, deductibles and all out of pockets): 28k
Home maintenance (for both the DC and second home, including cleaning services, lawn services, swimming pool maintenance in the second home, and all general maintenance on both houses): 26k
General merchandise (basically every "thing" we buy): 18k
Travel: 13k (average probably lower than the past because of covid)
Car (gas and maintenance, including buying a late model used one): 14k
Groceries: 12k
Restaurants: 8k
Utilities: 7k
Cable/internet: 5k
Gifts: 4k
Insurance (home & auto): 3.5k
Phones: 3.3k
Miscellaneous (assistance to elderly mother, entertainment, cash withdrawals from ATMs, gifts to charity, clothing): 6k
TOTAL per year average: $183k
So, for $183k a year, we are paying our taxes, paying for health care, managing to high end homes, traveling, eating out, buying decent cars, helping out our mother, etc. It's a very nice life, and it's affordable.
Some DCUM posters worry too much.
How do you manage to pay so little federal and state tax on 150k in income
Careful planning and relying on capital gains rather than withdrawing from my retirement accounts as much as possible. My tax bill really varies each year depending on how well I manage to do that. For example, for the year that just ended my federal tax bill is less than $500. The year before it was more like $40k.
This will change when you hit RMDs.
Anonymous
02/13/2023 13:13
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I've been retired for a little under a decade and just turned 60. My spouse stayed at home and our kids are long out of college and launched so she is retired as well. We still have a mortgage because we have a very low interest rate so there's no reason to pay it off. We live a very, very nice life in the DMV, with a home in a highly desirable part of the city and a second home in the country where we also spend a large amount of time. I track my expenses with the personal cap app.
Removing mortgage payments from our expenses -- because I know others will insist on paying theirs off before retiring, for whatever (often irrational) reason -- here are our average yearly expenses for the last three years, from highest to lowest:
Taxes (federal and DC income and DC and second home property taxes): 35k
Healthcare (premiums, deductibles and all out of pockets): 28k
Home maintenance (for both the DC and second home, including cleaning services, lawn services, swimming pool maintenance in the second home, and all general maintenance on both houses): 26k
General merchandise (basically every "thing" we buy): 18k
Travel: 13k (average probably lower than the past because of covid)
Car (gas and maintenance, including buying a late model used one): 14k
Groceries: 12k
Restaurants: 8k
Utilities: 7k
Cable/internet: 5k
Gifts: 4k
Insurance (home & auto): 3.5k
Phones: 3.3k
Miscellaneous (assistance to elderly mother, entertainment, cash withdrawals from ATMs, gifts to charity, clothing): 6k
TOTAL per year average: $183k
So, for $183k a year, we are paying our taxes, paying for health care, managing to high end homes, traveling, eating out, buying decent cars, helping out our mother, etc. It's a very nice life, and it's affordable.
Some DCUM posters worry too much.
How do you manage to pay so little federal and state tax on 150k in income
Careful planning and relying on capital gains rather than withdrawing from my retirement accounts as much as possible. My tax bill really varies each year depending on how well I manage to do that. For example, for the year that just ended my federal tax bill is less than $500. The year before it was more like $40k.
Have you considered doing traditional to Roth rollovers? I can only imagine taxes on income going up from here due to expected shortfalls in SS and the like. Or do you have enough in taxable accounts that you are just going to leave the traditional IRAs/401Ks to your kids? Still wouldn’t fix the RMD issue. Just curious because we are probably going to do rollovers in early retirement before our pensions and SS bump up our brackets.
Anonymous
02/13/2023 13:07
Subject: Re:Post-retirement spending
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I've been retired for a little under a decade and just turned 60. My spouse stayed at home and our kids are long out of college and launched so she is retired as well. We still have a mortgage because we have a very low interest rate so there's no reason to pay it off. We live a very, very nice life in the DMV, with a home in a highly desirable part of the city and a second home in the country where we also spend a large amount of time. I track my expenses with the personal cap app.
Removing mortgage payments from our expenses -- because I know others will insist on paying theirs off before retiring, for whatever (often irrational) reason -- here are our average yearly expenses for the last three years, from highest to lowest:
Taxes (federal and DC income and DC and second home property taxes): 35k
Healthcare (premiums, deductibles and all out of pockets): 28k
Home maintenance (for both the DC and second home, including cleaning services, lawn services, swimming pool maintenance in the second home, and all general maintenance on both houses): 26k
General merchandise (basically every "thing" we buy): 18k
Travel: 13k (average probably lower than the past because of covid)
Car (gas and maintenance, including buying a late model used one): 14k
Groceries: 12k
Restaurants: 8k
Utilities: 7k
Cable/internet: 5k
Gifts: 4k
Insurance (home & auto): 3.5k
Phones: 3.3k
Miscellaneous (assistance to elderly mother, entertainment, cash withdrawals from ATMs, gifts to charity, clothing): 6k
TOTAL per year average: $183k
So, for $183k a year, we are paying our taxes, paying for health care, managing to high end homes, traveling, eating out, buying decent cars, helping out our mother, etc. It's a very nice life, and it's affordable.
Some DCUM posters worry too much.
How do you manage to pay so little federal and state tax on 150k in income
Careful planning and relying on capital gains rather than withdrawing from my retirement accounts as much as possible. My tax bill really varies each year depending on how well I manage to do that. For example, for the year that just ended my federal tax bill is less than $500. The year before it was more like $40k.