Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 15:25     Subject: Re:PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:White, but sourdough is better for your health!


they are the same
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 15:10     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:Oh absolutely not! Rye should not go with anything sweet...


Agree! And I love a ham and cheese or turkey and avocado on rye. Or rye toast with butter.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 15:08     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
PB&J is good in apple slices. Actually, I skip the J.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 14:47     Subject: Re:PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Meh, you do you. Rye with sweet or non savory is a bit odd. Even Peanutbutter but it is a good bread really so have at it.

I know someone who regularly makes aforementioned peanutbutter and jelly on everything bagel and again, v weird, but they like it.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 14:27     Subject: Re:PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
I’d toast the rye and eat just PB open face
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 14:10     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
PB&J is best on the type of bread they called whole wheat back in the 80's.

Rye is great for a tuna sandwich.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 13:48     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP again. The only other bread available in the house were everything bagels.

So I guess the question should really be, what's worse, PB&J on marble rye or PB&J on an everything bagel?

If you pick everything bagel, does it matter if it's toasted or not?


Then you skip the PB & J! You just eat the everything bagel with cream cheese!



This is what i would do. Or just butter or peanut butter, if nothing else, but no jelly in this situation. Does not go.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 13:46     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:OP again. The only other bread available in the house were everything bagels.

So I guess the question should really be, what's worse, PB&J on marble rye or PB&J on an everything bagel?

If you pick everything bagel, does it matter if it's toasted or not?


Then you skip the PB & J! You just eat the everything bagel with cream cheese!

Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 13:42     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
I think no, but my toddler is fine with it.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 13:41     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
No thank you. I like pb and j on potato bread or graham cracker.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 13:31     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP again. The only other bread available in the house were everything bagels.

So I guess the question should really be, what's worse, PB&J on marble rye or PB&J on an everything bagel?

If you pick everything bagel, does it matter if it's toasted or not?


Given those options, I would definitely pick rye over an everything bagel.


I would opt for PB & J on two spoons and skip the bread.


Agree

But if I had to choose bread, I would go with toasted bagel.

Peanut butter on an Eggo waffle is good
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 13:29     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP again. The only other bread available in the house were everything bagels.

So I guess the question should really be, what's worse, PB&J on marble rye or PB&J on an everything bagel?

If you pick everything bagel, does it matter if it's toasted or not?


Given those options, I would definitely pick rye over an everything bagel.

I might try peanut butter on the ET bagel but not with jelly.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 13:10     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP again. The only other bread available in the house were everything bagels.

So I guess the question should really be, what's worse, PB&J on marble rye or PB&J on an everything bagel?

If you pick everything bagel, does it matter if it's toasted or not?


Given those options, I would definitely pick rye over an everything bagel.


I would opt for PB & J on two spoons and skip the bread.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 11:52     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
I do love a good sour/sweet mix. One of my favorite breads is chocolate cherry sourdough.
Anonymous
Post 01/20/2023 11:45     Subject: PB&J on rye bread -- y/n?
Anonymous wrote:OP again. The only other bread available in the house were everything bagels.

So I guess the question should really be, what's worse, PB&J on marble rye or PB&J on an everything bagel?

If you pick everything bagel, does it matter if it's toasted or not?


Given those options, I would definitely pick rye over an everything bagel.