Anonymous wrote:How much studying of queer identity needs to occur? My kid is in middle and I’m ok with the rest of the DEI but the kids get sick of talking about sexuality all the time. It can be draining to those who would prefer to not read and discuss peoples sexual preferences. It doesn’t mean that we don’t accept them but the constant discussion is too much. Parents are beginning to pull their kids out (especially after 2nd grade) and GDS needs to wake up!

True. 2nd grade Identity Project got off the rails the last few years with Jazz Jennings trans books before health ed, Explore your Gender homework, all the his/hers/them worksheets, and Dominant Culture lectures.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

This has to be a troll. Critical race theory is legal scholarship, no way they’d be teaching it in HS English, unless the person teaching it doesn’t understand what it is. Sounds like a Maga trump fan making fun of GDS’ wokism.

I'm not OP but can vouch that this Not a Troll post - go to GDS Open House and they happily list the English books per grade. It's really different from any other school.

Ugh. Open house for prospective families, bc we missed hearing examples like this or the academics. Or Open House for second month of school parents?

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

I went to GDS. This sounds like the 11th grade English course that I took (albeit, this was many years ago), so no, not OP is a troll. That class was very focused on rhetoric and argument in addition to the study of various critical lenses through which literature can be examined. I remember once I had to do a paper that involved taking two of the aforementioned critical lenses and close reading a short story or essay, the goal being that different critical frameworks yield different analyses and interpretations (so, not at all the 'indoctrination', but an encouragement of different thinking). And for the people griping that English needs to focus on the "classics" this same English 11 course started with Greek rhetorical appeals (ethos, logos, pathos) and Aristotle's poetics.


The only reasonable critique of teaching these things that I can fathom is that they're boring and maybe a bit advanced for some students (and I take issue with that claim, personally). English, especially a class which is focused on rhetoric and argument, is absolutely the place to learn about, well, different approaches to reading a text. And I don't remember being taught that one of these approaches is more right than another -- it's simply useful and important to know they exist.

I found this class to be challenging, but it did make me a better writer and I still use what I learned today, as an adult.

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

I went to GDS. This sounds like the 11th grade English course that I took (albeit, this was many years ago), so no, not OP is a troll. That class was very focused on rhetoric and argument in addition to the study of various critical lenses through which literature can be examined. I remember once I had to do a paper that involved taking two of the aforementioned critical lenses and close reading a short story or essay, the goal being that different critical frameworks yield different analyses and interpretations (so, not at all the 'indoctrination', but an encouragement of different thinking). And for the people griping that English needs to focus on the "classics" this same English 11 course started with Greek rhetorical appeals (ethos, logos, pathos) and Aristotle's poetics.


The only reasonable critique of teaching these things that I can fathom is that they're boring and maybe a bit advanced for some students (and I take issue with that claim, personally). English, especially a class which is focused on rhetoric and argument, is absolutely the place to learn about, well, different approaches to reading a text. And I don't remember that DD was taught that one of these approaches is more right than another -- it's simply useful and important to know they exist.

I found this class to be challenging, but it did make me a better writer and I still use what I learned today, as an adult.

Because you're at GDS, OP. Everyone knows they are crazy as loons. If you don't like it, leave.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

This has to be a troll. Critical race theory is legal scholarship, no way they’d be teaching it in HS English, unless the person teaching it doesn’t understand what it is. Sounds like a Maga trump fan making fun of GDS’ wokism.

I'm not OP but can vouch that this Not a Troll post - go to GDS Open House and they happily list the English books per grade. It's really different from any other school.

I’m the OP. Honestly this is not a troll. This is the core English class for an upper grade in the high school. Truly really.

I'm the PP - Yes I know - this is for the regular Grade level English classes that everyone has to take. Not a specialty class or an elective you choose as you get to 12th grade. It was eye opening that there seemed to be NO classic books at all.

Can you name the books please?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

This has to be a troll. Critical race theory is legal scholarship, no way they’d be teaching it in HS English, unless the person teaching it doesn’t understand what it is. Sounds like a Maga trump fan making fun of GDS’ wokism.

I'm not OP but can vouch that this Not a Troll post - go to GDS Open House and they happily list the English books per grade. It's really different from any other school.

I’m the OP. Honestly this is not a troll. This is the core English class for an upper grade in the high school. Truly really.

I'm the PP - Yes I know - this is for the regular Grade level English classes that everyone has to take. Not a specialty class or an elective you choose as you get to 12th grade. It was eye opening that there seemed to be NO classic books at all.

Anonymous wrote:What framework do you use to analyze literature, OP? These are all tools/theoretical frameworks of analysis.

Likely most posters never studied these, and some are quite new. So, here is an explanation:

https://iep.utm.edu/literary/

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

This has to be a troll. Critical race theory is legal scholarship, no way they’d be teaching it in HS English, unless the person teaching it doesn’t understand what it is. Sounds like a Maga trump fan making fun of GDS’ wokism.

I'm not OP but can vouch that this Not a Troll post - go to GDS Open House and they happily list the English books per grade. It's really different from any other school.

I’m the OP. Honestly this is not a troll. This is the core English class for an upper grade in the high school. Truly really.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

All of those topics could be taught outside literature in history or sociology, but I expect that college-level literature courses are using those as some of several analytical viewpoints, so GDS wants their students to be familiar with them, just like they would other viewpoints like heroic sagas, classical tragedies, etc.

Literary analysis is more complicated and diverse than it used to be.

Are they also reading the heroic sagas and classical tragedies?

Yes OP here in fact this is being taught as the framework to read the heroic sagas and tragedies!!

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

Lordy this is miserable.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

This has to be a troll. Critical race theory is legal scholarship, no way they’d be teaching it in HS English, unless the person teaching it doesn’t understand what it is. Sounds like a Maga trump fan making fun of GDS’ wokism.

I'm not OP but can vouch that this Not a Troll post - go to GDS Open House and they happily list the English books per grade. It's really different from any other school.

Can you give any examples of the books?

How much studying of queer identity needs to occur? My kid is in middle and I’m ok with the rest of the DEI but the kids get sick of talking about sexuality all the time. It can be draining to those who would prefer to not read and discuss peoples sexual preferences. It doesn’t mean that we don’t accept them but the constant discussion is too much. Parents are beginning to pull their kids out (especially after 2nd grade) and GDS needs to wake up!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Parent here. Have been mostly happy w GDS HS english and related faculty.

This fall, one of the HS grades as started out by studying the following topics:

Queer Studies, CRT, Marxist Theory, Intersectionality, Structuralism Theory

Serious old person question - why are these taught in ENGLISH rather than in a special elective class? Isn't english for the study of literature. I get it - literature is a window into humanity....but really? I also get it - it's GDS but this is a core class all students must take.

And there was even an op-ed in student paper last week from a student very unhappy with the single-minded bias faculty show and the lack of oxygen they provide for dissenting views.

This has to be a troll. Critical race theory is legal scholarship, no way they’d be teaching it in HS English, unless the person teaching it doesn’t understand what it is. Sounds like a Maga trump fan making fun of GDS’ wokism.

I'm not OP but can vouch that this Not a Troll post - go to GDS Open House and they happily list the English books per grade. It's really different from any other school.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Looks like a class on literary theory, which is usually housed in an English/literature curriculum. Pretty common for college courses, and GDS English courses are supposed to be at that level.

So they should use tons of controversial, politically slanted new author books to do so?

What books? I didn't see a list of books in the op.