Mine did little bo peep and a sheep.

Anonymous wrote:This won't help you, but when my youngest was a baby, the kids went as a slice of watermelon and a bundled up seed, LOL. At every single house, she would back at me holding a baby bundled up in all black and announce "I am a watermelon, and he is the seed that fell off from RIGHT HERE" and pointed to her belly.

That’s so cute!! and creative!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Op here. DD is very girlish and she’s not into superheroes. Every time I asked her what she wants to be, she gives me a different answer. It’s also hard to find a matching bro costume.

She’s thinking of:
Ariel - it is hard to find a crab costume for a 3 year old, lots of lobster costumes though
Fairy - what matches a fairy?!
Black cat
Witch (again)

She said no to thing 1, thing 2, Cat in the Hat.

Why do they have to match or go in theme? It's not about you and the pictures-it's about your kid.

They don’t HAVE to but since my youngest has no opinion, and I am the one paying for it, I thought it would be fun if they match. It’s not that serious. If they don’t match, it’s fine as well. I just thought I’ll post here to get some ideas. Sheesh!!

Anonymous wrote:Apparently now is the time to look for Halloween costumes![b] We have done Elsa and Olaf, witch and pumpkin.. please give me some suggestions! Older DD is 6 and little brother is 3. Thanks!!

Why so shocked? Next week is the beginning of October! For little kids, Halloween costumes, their birthday and Christmas ( if you celebrate) are very high priority. Have you asked either kid what they want to be?

We had our kids go as our cat and dog once. I painted sweatpants to match the animals. Also avocado and toast.

Anonymous wrote:Princess Leia and an Ewok

Mine were Luke and Leia one year...also Kanga and Roo

Anonymous wrote:Apparently now is the time to look for Halloween costumes! We have done Elsa and Olaf, witch and pumpkin.. please give me some suggestions! Older DD is 6 and little brother is 3. Thanks!!

Velma and Scooby Doo

Vampirina and gargoyle

Anonymous wrote:Op here. DD is very girlish and she’s not into superheroes. Every time I asked her what she wants to be, she gives me a different answer. It’s also hard to find a matching bro costume.

She’s thinking of:
Ariel - it is hard to find a crab costume for a 3 year old, lots of lobster costumes though
Fairy - what matches a fairy?!
Black cat
Witch (again)

She said no to thing 1, thing 2, Cat in the Hat.

Ignore the haters, OP, I agree it's cute. My 3 yo has no interest in costumes yet either so I believe you when you say your DS doesn't, and since that'll probably change soon, why NOT dress them alike while you still can?

For Ariel I think a lobster costume would be close enough. Or any sea thing - seahorse, clam, starfish, they all go with the theme.
Fairy: an elf, maybe? Or a flower/something woodsy? Tinkerbell and Peter Pan was another good suggestion.
Black cat: a mouse, or a dog?
Witch: he could be a wizard, broomstick, cat, frog/toad?

This won't help you, but when my youngest was a baby, the kids went as a slice of watermelon and a bundled up seed, LOL. At every single house, she would back at me holding a baby bundled up in all black and announce "I am a watermelon, and he is the seed that fell off from RIGHT HERE" and pointed to her belly.

Anonymous wrote:Op here. DD is very girlish and she’s not into superheroes. Every time I asked her what she wants to be, she gives me a different answer. It’s also hard to find a matching bro costume.

She’s thinking of:
Ariel - it is hard to find a crab costume for a 3 year old, lots of lobster costumes though
Fairy - what matches a fairy?!
Black cat
Witch (again)

She said no to thing 1, thing 2, Cat in the Hat.

Why do they have to match or go in theme? It's not about you and the pictures-it's about your kid.

Anonymous wrote:Apparently now is the time to look for Halloween costumes! We have done Elsa and Olaf, witch and pumpkin.. please give me some suggestions! Older DD is 6 and little brother is 3. Thanks!!

Your daughter is old enough to have an opinion on what she wants to be-just ask her and see if she has thoughts about her brother's costume too.

Dorothy and Toto
Alice and the White Rabbit
Princess and a Dragon

Anonymous wrote:I always let my older pick and then little bro was always that character's side kick:

Olaf and Elsa
Sebastian and Ariel
Prince Charming and Cinderella
Chip and Belle
Pascal and Rapunzel
Rajah and Jasmine
Dash and Violet (Incredibles)

Thank you for these suggestions!

Anonymous wrote:Does your younger not care at all what he's going to be? Both my kids have always had opinions except when they were babies. I think little kids should be able to be what they want because it's their Halloween, not be forced into some matching costume just so mom can get more likes on her instagram pictures.

OP here. He actually doesn’t care, unfortunately. I wish he would, but he just doesn’t.