Anonymous
11/23/2023 14:54
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
I think with the broad rubrics, it’s more subjective than ever before. I wouldn’t call it raising the bar. If anything, expectations are lower.
If that were true wouldn’t it be easier to get an A?
Anonymous
11/23/2023 14:36
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
I think with the broad rubrics, it’s more subjective than ever before. I wouldn’t call it raising the bar. If anything, expectations are lower.
So it's both harder and easier. Makes sense.
Stfu. Clearly you don’t have high achieving kids that go there. If you don’t have kids there, skip the snark and listen. Maybe you’ll learn something.
Anonymous
11/23/2023 11:22
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
I think with the broad rubrics, it’s more subjective than ever before. I wouldn’t call it raising the bar. If anything, expectations are lower.
So it's both harder and easier. Makes sense.
Yes very subjective based on the teacher
Anonymous
11/23/2023 10:54
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
I think with the broad rubrics, it’s more subjective than ever before. I wouldn’t call it raising the bar. If anything, expectations are lower.
So it's both harder and easier. Makes sense.
Anonymous
11/23/2023 10:11
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
I have several kids at madison. Yes, in my experience, much harder now. There is no reason a small, technical issue done once should result in a B.
There is only one reason, equitable grading and closing the gap.
Anonymous
11/23/2023 10:03
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
I have several kids at madison. Yes, in my experience, much harder now. There is no reason a small, technical issue done once should result in a B.
Anonymous
11/23/2023 09:42
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
I think with the broad rubrics, it’s more subjective than ever before. I wouldn’t call it raising the bar. If anything, expectations are lower.
Anonymous
11/23/2023 09:35
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
So they’ve raised the bar to get an A?
Anonymous
11/23/2023 09:34
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:I think the problem is that outside of the VA colleges the students will be compared by Country/ region. So my child who doesn’t get to take retakes at Madison will be compared to another student at McLean who does. As mentioned the practices are not similar to the assessments and are not graded so students don’t know what to expect or fully understand how much they know the content before they take the assessment. It really is pushing students to a B
This is the biggest issue with SBG and kids applying to college. If applying to VA schools AOs will understand what is going on so kids at Madison will be compared to other kids from Madison.
Where it becomes a major problem is when applying out of state. AOs don’t know some schools allow retest to 100, some to 80, some no retest at all.
Principals and admin only care about a more even grade distribution and closing the “achievement gap”.
Anonymous
11/23/2023 08:58
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
I think the problem is that outside of the VA colleges the students will be compared by Country/ region. So my child who doesn’t get to take retakes at Madison will be compared to another student at McLean who does. As mentioned the practices are not similar to the assessments and are not graded so students don’t know what to expect or fully understand how much they know the content before they take the assessment. It really is pushing students to a B
Anonymous
11/23/2023 07:52
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
In my kid’s class 1 wrong is a B. 2 wrong is a C. Wrong in can be a paper where something underlined should have been italicized. Done once is a B. It goes down from there.
Anonymous
11/23/2023 07:50
Subject: Re:More skills based grading at madison hs
Anonymous wrote:Taking kids 5 seconds to embrace “test doesn’t matter” because they know can retake it.
Madison doesn’t do retakes
Anonymous
11/23/2023 07:32
Subject: Re:More skills based grading at madison hs
Taking kids 5 seconds to embrace “test doesn’t matter” because they know can retake it.
Anonymous
11/22/2023 18:38
Subject: More skills based grading at madison hs
How does this lower grades? Only being assessed on major assignments is college-like. Someone said one mistake gives you a B on a test. That’s the part that’s confusing. And won’t colleges be comparing kids within the same school?
Anonymous
11/22/2023 16:59
Subject: Re:More skills based grading at madison hs
It sucks. It’s terrible. It serves no one except the bottom kids, and even then, giving them something that boost their grade does a disservice to them.