Just re-watched the latest episode and it's TOTALLY John's baby, his wife killed Erin, and she called Billy to help her with the body.

I don’t know who actually killed Erin, but I think the men are involved with trafficking - John, Billy, Frank as the teacher is the connection to Dylan and his friend. I feel like Frank was disqualified too early. I don’t know why his fiancée would leave over the paternity test if he had a good excuse and she trusted him.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

Siobhan’s alibi was murky, right? But what would be her motive? And we saw John with the distinctive cop Colt.

After Erin was beaten up by the new red haired girlfriend the video showed Siobhan going over, putting her arm around her and walking her away

But there’s hours between that and when Erin is found. I need to go back and watch Siobhan’s police interview.

Remember Siobhan asked Erin if she wanted a ride home. Erin said no then wandered off.

Also that was well before the deacon picked her up/dropped her off at park. It could still be Siobhan, but it didn’t happen then.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

Siobhan’s alibi was murky, right? But what would be her motive? And we saw John with the distinctive cop Colt.

After Erin was beaten up by the new red haired girlfriend the video showed Siobhan going over, putting her arm around her and walking her away

But there’s hours between that and when Erin is found. I need to go back and watch Siobhan’s police interview.

Remember Siobhan asked Erin if she wanted a ride home. Erin said no then wandered off.

Yeah, I don't think it's Siobhan.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

Siobhan’s alibi was murky, right? But what would be her motive? And we saw John with the distinctive cop Colt.

After Erin was beaten up by the new red haired girlfriend the video showed Siobhan going over, putting her arm around her and walking her away

But there’s hours between that and when Erin is found. I need to go back and watch Siobhan’s police interview.

Remember Siobhan asked Erin if she wanted a ride home. Erin said no then wandered off.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

And Siobhan took off her clothes too?

No it can’t be Siobhan! Someone had to drag Erin’s body to the river and Siobhan is too small. Unless she had help.

It was John and Lore.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

Interesting idea. What was her motive though??

DP - Maybe Erin was secretly involved with Kevin that month he was "missing" and Siobhan blames Erin for Kevin's suicide?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

Siobhan’s alibi was murky, right? But what would be her motive? And we saw John with the distinctive cop Colt.

After Erin was beaten up by the new red haired girlfriend the video showed Siobhan going over, putting her arm around her and walking her away

But there’s hours between that and when Erin is found. I need to go back and watch Siobhan’s police interview.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

Siobhan’s alibi was murky, right? But what would be her motive? And we saw John with the distinctive cop Colt.

After Erin was beaten up by the new red haired girlfriend the video showed Siobhan going over, putting her arm around her and walking her away

Anonymous wrote:On the contrary, I thought in episode two it showed how pretty she still was when she gussied herself up to see Guy Pierce.

And shows how impactful hair and makeup are!

Agree. I think they are purposefully making her look frumpy and worn out. When you got made up, she looked great. Not movie star with Botox great. Natural woman great.

I’m only a few episodes in. Is it crazy to wonder if it’s Mare herself?

Anonymous wrote:I am really enjoying this series. Question for people who are from Delaware/Chester county Pennsylvania...Does the show accurately reflect the culture there? Or is it like watching The Wire and thinking that accurately describes Baltimore?

I am from Pennsylvania and I do not even hear an accent while watching this show. It also took me three tries to watch episode one, because I watching it and the people just made me feel sad and brought up a lot of bad memories. So, yep, it’s pretty accurate.

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

Interesting idea. What was her motive though??

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

And Siobhan took off her clothes too?

Anonymous wrote:Winslet said the reveal is devastating?

It was Siobhan. I'd put money on it.

I think it being her BFF would be devastating too. Since Siobhan tried to help Erin that night, hard to see, but I guess anything's possible.