Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 11:42     Subject: Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:Agreed. I like that she doubted herself so much. They should have burned the body after the unsuccessful attempt at reviving him. Then her faith in her visions would have been restored AND everyone would know Jon is a Targarian.

Don't get me wrong... I'm relieved to see JS back. Love him and it sounds like he's got a huge role this season. I read that he filmed more than any other character on the show.



My assumption at the end was that believing the Red Priestess' attempt was unsuccessful they were going out to tell some schleps to bring the body to the pire.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 11:30     Subject: Game of Thrones
Agreed. I like that she doubted herself so much. They should have burned the body after the unsuccessful attempt at reviving him. Then her faith in her visions would have been restored AND everyone would know Jon is a Targarian.

Don't get me wrong... I'm relieved to see JS back. Love him and it sounds like he's got a huge role this season. I read that he filmed more than any other character on the show.

Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 11:01     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I wonder if the Watch will attempt to burn him believing him a Wight.

BTW what was the legend about the king of the white walkers and some ice queen / witch?


Wights can't speak. Beric Dondarian could after being resurrected by Thoros of Myr, so I would assume Jon will be able to speak.


But does the Brotherhood know that ... Without Sam Tarley to tell them?
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 10:18     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Sure she could've remained uncertain of her abilities but it would've been better if after not waking they tried to burn the corpse and there was a rebirth by flame or something more dramatic. Not on Melisandre's end but on the circumstances of the resurrection.


I'm fairly certain this is how it will happen in the books. Like many readers, I think R+L=J, so it would make sense if they burn him and he comes out 'unburnt.'

For the show - there was literally no other reason to have Melisandre at the wall, so not really shocked that Jon is alive again.


Well I'm not saying Melisandre shouldn't have been involved I'm just saying after she made an attempt something more dramatic could've happened.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 09:34     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:I wonder if the Watch will attempt to burn him believing him a Wight.

BTW what was the legend about the king of the white walkers and some ice queen / witch?


Wights can't speak. Beric Dondarian could after being resurrected by Thoros of Myr, so I would assume Jon will be able to speak.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 09:08     Subject: Game of Thrones
They're definitely going to try to burn him. Great way to introduce R+L=J.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 09:07     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:I wonder if the Watch will attempt to burn him believing him a Wight.


This is a likely way to reveal Jon's heritage.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 08:55     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
I wonder if the Watch will attempt to burn him believing him a Wight.

BTW what was the legend about the king of the white walkers and some ice queen / witch?
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 08:49     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:
Sure she could've remained uncertain of her abilities but it would've been better if after not waking they tried to burn the corpse and there was a rebirth by flame or something more dramatic. Not on Melisandre's end but on the circumstances of the resurrection.


I'm fairly certain this is how it will happen in the books. Like many readers, I think R+L=J, so it would make sense if they burn him and he comes out 'unburnt.'

For the show - there was literally no other reason to have Melisandre at the wall, so not really shocked that Jon is alive again.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 07:21     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Lame... Hair snip, put clippings in flames, speak mumbo jumbo and voila!

I think that might be the worst segment in the whole series.



+1. Underwhelming especially after such a buildup.


Nah. The simplicity of it highlights her insecurity and lack of faith in her own, well, faith. If she'd stormed in there, all balls, and made some sort of magical fireworks and then POOF! Jon Snow! we would've missed the impact of her "impostor syndrome" and self-doubt. She doesn't think she can do it, and there's a tentative, hesitant quality to each of her movements.

The ritual itself was similar the last time we saw it, so it wouldn't have made sense to change it much anyway.


Sure she could've remained uncertain of her abilities but it would've been better if after not waking they tried to burn the corpse and there was a rebirth by flame or something more dramatic. Not on Melisandre's end but on the circumstances of the resurrection.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 06:44     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Lame... Hair snip, put clippings in flames, speak mumbo jumbo and voila!

I think that might be the worst segment in the whole series.



+1. Underwhelming especially after such a buildup.


Nah. The simplicity of it highlights her insecurity and lack of faith in her own, well, faith. If she'd stormed in there, all balls, and made some sort of magical fireworks and then POOF! Jon Snow! we would've missed the impact of her "impostor syndrome" and self-doubt. She doesn't think she can do it, and there's a tentative, hesitant quality to each of her movements.

The ritual itself was similar the last time we saw it, so it wouldn't have made sense to change it much anyway.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 04:42     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Anonymous wrote:Lame... Hair snip, put clippings in flames, speak mumbo jumbo and voila!

I think that might be the worst segment in the whole series.



+1. Underwhelming especially after such a buildup.
Anonymous
Post 05/02/2016 00:47     Subject: Game of Thrones
That's pretty much how it worked in Season 3, too, minus the hair stuff. Praying over the wounds and voila!
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2016 22:55     Subject: Re:Game of Thrones
Lame... Hair snip, put clippings in flames, speak mumbo jumbo and voila!

I think that might be the worst segment in the whole series.

Anonymous
Post 05/01/2016 22:05     Subject: Game of Thrones
Did she have to cut his hair?! N

Did the direwolf die? A life for a life like when droggo came back?