Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I asked my BASIS kid about CAPE and they said that, since it doesn’t count, no one cares and tries.
That said, there is no question that BASIS kids do really well on the test. In fact, they have the top scores of any middle school in DC.
Here are the results for 8th grade for the latest CAPE testing. This is after kids have been at schools such as BASIS, Deal, and Hardy for several years.
ELA
BASIS 84.4
Deal 81
Latin 2nd 72.4
Oyster 69.9
Latin Cooper 66
Hardy 65.9
S-H 63
DCI 58.1
Math
BASIS 78.5
Deal 64
Latin 2nd 63.3
Oyster 63
Hardy 50
Latin Cooper 41.5
DCI 41
S-H 31.3
I do not believe this for a second given the types of kids and families at BASIS.
Also, you must be new here. The 8th grade math results are the least meaningful. BASIS has 8th graders take 8th grade math even though they're on to more advanced math; other schools don't, so 8th grade CAPE math takers tend to be the 8th graders who are worst at math. Do these numbers exclude the advance math takers? Because, if so, they'd be even less meaningful. Basically it would be every 8th grader at BASIS vs all the kids who were specifically worst at math at the other schools.
Anonymous wrote:I asked my BASIS kid about CAPE and they said that, since it doesn’t count, no one cares and tries.
That said, there is no question that BASIS kids do really well on the test. In fact, they have the top scores of any middle school in DC.
Here are the results for 8th grade for the latest CAPE testing. This is after kids have been at schools such as BASIS, Deal, and Hardy for several years.
ELA
BASIS 84.4
Deal 81
Latin 2nd 72.4
Oyster 69.9
Latin Cooper 66
Hardy 65.9
S-H 63
DCI 58.1
Math
BASIS 78.5
Deal 64
Latin 2nd 63.3
Oyster 63
Hardy 50
Latin Cooper 41.5
DCI 41
S-H 31.3
Anonymous wrote:I asked my BASIS kid about CAPE and they said that, since it doesn’t count, no one cares and tries.
That said, there is no question that BASIS kids do really well on the test. In fact, they have the top scores of any middle school in DC.
Here are the results for 8th grade for the latest CAPE testing. This is after kids have been at schools such as BASIS, Deal, and Hardy for several years.
ELA
BASIS 84.4
Deal 81
Latin 2nd 72.4
Oyster 69.9
Latin Cooper 66
Hardy 65.9
S-H 63
DCI 58.1
Math
BASIS 78.5
Deal 64
Latin 2nd 63.3
Oyster 63
Hardy 50
Latin Cooper 41.5
DCI 41
S-H 31.3
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What about an analysis of middle school 5s like Hardy 6th has 2x ELA 5s as Basis? Sure some kids read lots at home for fun….
Doesn’t Hardy 6th grade have double the amount of students as Basis 6th? 200ish students in hardy 6th grade vs 100ish at Basis. So this makes sense to me when talking about raw numbers.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What about an analysis of middle school 5s like Hardy 6th has 2x ELA 5s as Basis? Sure some kids read lots at home for fun….
This is interesting. Our kid just finished a year at BASIS and got his first CAPE scores -- both 4s. But previously at his (pretty mediocre) DCPS school he got 5s and 98th percentile scores. Scores and percentiles on CAPE both dropped after a year at BASIS!
He does extremely well on all the BASIS exams and other standardized tests. So I wonder if BASIS is truly not teaching to CAPE in any way.
BASIS ignores CAPE. Other than taking time away from class to administer it, totally irrelevant.
BASIS’ whole model is that extensive test and drill is actually teaching kids, not just teaching them to pass BASIS-specific tests. If a kid was getting 5s previously and now isn’t, I would definitely be worried (though I would wait a year to worry too much). The “strategy” of CAPE doesn’t change from year to year, so even if I accept that BASIS doesn’t teach to the test, they shouldn’t need to for kids who have already learned that part. It may be that BASIS’ style of teaching isn’t actually a good match for your kid even if they are performing well of BASIS style exams (very memorization based especially in 6th with little explanation/ extrapolation needed).
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What about an analysis of middle school 5s like Hardy 6th has 2x ELA 5s as Basis? Sure some kids read lots at home for fun….
This is interesting. Our kid just finished a year at BASIS and got his first CAPE scores -- both 4s. But previously at his (pretty mediocre) DCPS school he got 5s and 98th percentile scores. Scores and percentiles on CAPE both dropped after a year at BASIS!
He does extremely well on all the BASIS exams and other standardized tests. So I wonder if BASIS is truly not teaching to CAPE in any way.
BASIS ignores CAPE. Other than taking time away from class to administer it, totally irrelevant.
BASIS’ whole model is that extensive test and drill is actually teaching kids, not just teaching them to pass BASIS-specific tests. If a kid was getting 5s previously and now isn’t, I would definitely be worried (though I would wait a year to worry too much). The “strategy” of CAPE doesn’t change from year to year, so even if I accept that BASIS doesn’t teach to the test, they shouldn’t need to for kids who have already learned that part. It may be that BASIS’ style of teaching isn’t actually a good match for your kid even if they are performing well of BASIS style exams (very memorization based especially in 6th with little explanation/ extrapolation needed).
+1. This teaching to the test is BS. Either you know the material or not. It is just testing what you should know. It is not designed to trick you or anything.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What about an analysis of middle school 5s like Hardy 6th has 2x ELA 5s as Basis? Sure some kids read lots at home for fun….
This is interesting. Our kid just finished a year at BASIS and got his first CAPE scores -- both 4s. But previously at his (pretty mediocre) DCPS school he got 5s and 98th percentile scores. Scores and percentiles on CAPE both dropped after a year at BASIS!
He does extremely well on all the BASIS exams and other standardized tests. So I wonder if BASIS is truly not teaching to CAPE in any way.
BASIS ignores CAPE. Other than taking time away from class to administer it, totally irrelevant.
BASIS’ whole model is that extensive test and drill is actually teaching kids, not just teaching them to pass BASIS-specific tests. If a kid was getting 5s previously and now isn’t, I would definitely be worried (though I would wait a year to worry too much). The “strategy” of CAPE doesn’t change from year to year, so even if I accept that BASIS doesn’t teach to the test, they shouldn’t need to for kids who have already learned that part. It may be that BASIS’ style of teaching isn’t actually a good match for your kid even if they are performing well of BASIS style exams (very memorization based especially in 6th with little explanation/ extrapolation needed).
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What about an analysis of middle school 5s like Hardy 6th has 2x ELA 5s as Basis? Sure some kids read lots at home for fun….
This is interesting. Our kid just finished a year at BASIS and got his first CAPE scores -- both 4s. But previously at his (pretty mediocre) DCPS school he got 5s and 98th percentile scores. Scores and percentiles on CAPE both dropped after a year at BASIS!
He does extremely well on all the BASIS exams and other standardized tests. So I wonder if BASIS is truly not teaching to CAPE in any way.
BASIS ignores CAPE. Other than taking time away from class to administer it, totally irrelevant.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What about an analysis of middle school 5s like Hardy 6th has 2x ELA 5s as Basis? Sure some kids read lots at home for fun….
This is interesting. Our kid just finished a year at BASIS and got his first CAPE scores -- both 4s. But previously at his (pretty mediocre) DCPS school he got 5s and 98th percentile scores. Scores and percentiles on CAPE both dropped after a year at BASIS!
He does extremely well on all the BASIS exams and other standardized tests. So I wonder if BASIS is truly not teaching to CAPE in any way.
Anonymous wrote:What about an analysis of middle school 5s like Hardy 6th has 2x ELA 5s as Basis? Sure some kids read lots at home for fun….