Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Israeli officer: "Anything that moves in the zone, even a three-year old, needs to be killed."
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/nov/24/israel
And he was reprimanded for doing so.
Muslima wrote:I am sorry but the premise of your statement is wrong. How many Palestinians do you think practice honor killing? How many Americans kill their children? There are more Americans killing their children than there are Palestinians doing honor killing.I guess according to your logic, Americans do not respect the lives of their children so why do we expect them to respect the lives of other people? ughhhhh
Muslima wrote:Anonymous wrote:Muslima - do you believe Palestinians engage in honor killings? Do you believe the UN when they say Hamas has weaponry in civilian locations? Do you support either practice? Do you believe suicide bombers exist? Do you feel they are correct in their behavior?
do you believe Palestinians engage in honor killings?
I believe that this is practiced in various cultures and is not "Palestinian" per se.
Do you believe the UN when they say Hamas has weaponry in civilian locations?
Yes. I have said numerous times that there was evidence of weapons found in schools.
Do you believe suicide bombers exist?
Yes.
Do you feel they are correct in their behavior?
No.
Anonymous wrote:Muslima - do you believe Palestinians engage in honor killings? Do you believe the UN when they say Hamas has weaponry in civilian locations? Do you support either practice? Do you believe suicide bombers exist? Do you feel they are correct in their behavior?
do you believe Palestinians engage in honor killings?
Do you believe the UN when they say Hamas has weaponry in civilian locations?
Do you believe suicide bombers exist?
Do you feel they are correct in their behavior?
Anonymous wrote:Israeli officer: "Anything that moves in the zone, even a three-year old, needs to be killed."
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/nov/24/israel
Anonymous wrote:Muslima, et al: surely you know the answer to your last question. When a country is surrounded by enemies, who have either supplied rockets to Hamas (Syria, Iran), Hezobllah in Lebanon, ISIS psychopaths in Iraq, Hamas leadership in Qatar, many other countries who are less than hospitable to Israel and Jews, and of course Hamas and Islamic Jihad operating in the occupied territories, I think Israel should have weapons for defense. You do understand that, right?
Anonymous wrote:Muslima wrote:Anonymous wrote:[Look, I'm trying to get at practical solutions here. I promise to answer this question if you answer mine first: If Israel ends the blockade, how can they ensure that Hamas will not immediately import sophisticated weaponry and use it on Israel?
Did you read Hamas' s reform documents? This is what they said about their goals : " the aim is to
achieve equality before the law among citizens in rights and duties; bring security to all citizens and protect their proper- ties and assure their safety against arbitrary arrest, torture, or revenge; stress the culture of dialogue . . . ; support the press and media institutions and maintain the right of journalists to accessandto publishinformation; maintain freedomandinde- pendence of professional syndicates and preserve the rights of their membership."
Do I think Hamas is the solution ? No, but I think it is up to the Palestinian people to decide who their leader should be, that is the most basic of democratic rights.....
I don't understand -- how would this minimize the risk that Hamas would immediately import sophisticated weaponry and use it on Israel? Let me try to get at this another way - would you support lifting the blockade but requiring full access to all imports/exports by third-party monitors?
Yes but this brings us back to the double standard issue I've been raising. Why is it okay to monitor Gaza while Israel has been buying weapons freely since it was created? Why is it okay for Israel to be military strong while Gaza has to use rockets ?
Honestly? Because if Israel wanted to eliminate Gaza, it could do so today, in about 12 hours. It's had the ability to do so for years. And Gaza is still here.
Do you really believe that, if Hamas had a nuke, it wouldn't launch it at Israel at the first opportunity?