Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:34     Subject: Re:Are we going to hear this week?
My son had NNAT 135 and CogAT 126. Not in.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:27     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:low SES school 146 NNAT 150 COGAT NOT IN...




This one is insane!
Mom—did you piss someone off? Is your kid getting behavior referrals to principal constantly? Because this makes no sense.



We are active members in the PTA and active volunteers and I would say pretty well liked! Our kid has never had a behavior issue in class, so seriously I am scratching my head!

He is a white boy, I'm more upset he is losing is likely going to lose his peer group as most AAP eligible kids go to the center based school.

Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:23     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:I posted on the other thread.

153 Cogat, 160 NNAT, 99% and 94% I ready. Good report cards. Not in. Seriously, what is going on?


That is a bummer. I am sorry.
You should definitely appeal and if possible ask for an explanation about this result. Just curious what kind of work samples you submitted.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:15     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I posted on the other thread.

153 Cogat, 160 NNAT, 99% and 94% I ready. Good report cards. Not in. Seriously, what is going on?


HOPE is bad?

If AAP is designed for gifted students, this doesn't make sense. But maybe AAP is mostly for kids with good behavior and OK grades?


Correct, it is mostly for good/great students with good grades who are (this is the critical part) good in the classroom. The students teachers like to have. It hasn’t been a true gifted program in many years.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:15     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
FWIW, my DD's AAP classes have had plenty of disruptive kids of the chair throwing variety.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:12     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:I posted on the other thread.

153 Cogat, 160 NNAT, 99% and 94% I ready. Good report cards. Not in. Seriously, what is going on?


HOPE is bad?

If AAP is designed for gifted students, this doesn't make sense. But maybe AAP is mostly for kids with good behavior and OK grades?
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:06     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
I posted on the other thread.

153 Cogat, 160 NNAT, 99% and 94% I ready. Good report cards. Not in. Seriously, what is going on?
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:02     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Got in 5:03pm 128 NNAT 126Cogat


WTF? What school? My child's scores were higher than that and was rejected. Are you at a low SES school?


Check with your teacher, this year the HOPE score and student profile weights more.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:01     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Got it. Not in with a 140 Cogat. Am an AAP teacher in the county. Pissed.


What?!


I feel like this has to be an error. What would justify keeping out cogat of over 136 honestly? And especially being that you are an AAP teacher yourself. Not right.


The committee wouldn’t know that I am an AAP teacher, but it is definitely frustrating because I’ve taught AAP for years and know DS is an AAP kid. My other DS is not, and that’s fine. I have DS’ packet and his teacher gave him very mediocre HOPE scores and his reading iReady in the fall was only in the 78th percentile— an outlier and his Spring was 90th.


I'm really surprised if they're weighing iReady that much. It seems like such a joke of a test.

HOPE they have already said they weigh as the biggest factor - or GBRS it was as you know.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:00     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:low SES school 146 NNAT 150 COGAT NOT IN...




This one is insane!
Mom—did you piss someone off? Is your kid getting behavior referrals to principal constantly? Because this makes no sense.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 18:00     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:low SES school 146 NNAT 150 COGAT NOT IN...



Boy or girl?
Race?
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 17:59     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:In. 122 CogAT, 120 NNAT.


No way. What school?


GFES.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 17:58     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Got it. Not in with a 140 Cogat. Am an AAP teacher in the county. Pissed.


What?!


I feel like this has to be an error. What would justify keeping out cogat of over 136 honestly? And especially being that you are an AAP teacher yourself. Not right.


The committee wouldn’t know that I am an AAP teacher, but it is definitely frustrating because I’ve taught AAP for years and know DS is an AAP kid. My other DS is not, and that’s fine. I have DS’ packet and his teacher gave him very mediocre HOPE scores and his reading iReady in the fall was only in the 78th percentile— an outlier and his Spring was 90th.
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 17:58     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:low SES school 146 NNAT 150 COGAT NOT IN...




There are other anomalies posted here, but this one seems to fly in the face of the local norms shift. Is this a boy or a girl and are you willing to disclose race?
Anonymous
Post 04/05/2024 17:57     Subject: Are we going to hear this week?
Anonymous wrote:So I really think what really matters is the CogAt and 2nd grade teacher recommendations..I have a feeling appeals are very hard to get unless you personally know someone.


Well surely the county AAP teacher whose child was rejected knows someone!