Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 20:23     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:Earning an MBA at a Top 15 MBA program can be expensive, but the job opportunities are unequaled elsewhere speaking broadly. Most MBA students at Top 15 programs have the option to earn about $40,000 from an internship during the summer between their first & second year of the MBA degree program. Some employers will pay tuition & fees for an MBA's second year if the internet accepts an offer of permanent employment after completion of the degree.

Some employers will reimburse costs of a part-time MBA program for current employees. If one's desire is to remain with that employer, then almost any local MBA program may work in that situation.


Yes, this is why programs like New Paltz make sense for those who are already employed and need some polishing (at minimal cost) to advance in their current company. But they still make zero sense for the undergrads with zero full time work experience.
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 20:17     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:Would be better if the business school at SUNY New Paltz offered a few business courses at nearby Vassar College or if the expedited program for those with no post undergraduate real world work experience was a certificate program, not an MBA program.

Just as shocking is that the Vassar College recent grads who immediately grab a SUNY New Paltz MBA will receive preferential consideration for teaching assistant positions at SUNY New Paltz. Is this a case of the blind leading the blind ?

Vassar College is a respected school. My thought is that parents of Vassar College students and the students do not attend such an expensive and selective school in order to get an MBA from a program with very low standards for admission. As the inexperienced Vassar/New Paltz MBA degree holders get experience in the post undergraduate working world, they may discover that they have handicapped their future career pursuits with this premature degree from a sub-standard MBA program and crippled. any future eligibility to earn a real MBA from a well respected program.

Doesn't this seem to be an admission from Vassar College that a Vassar education is insufficient for their graduates to enter the post undergraduate working world ? If so, then those Vassar College students who pursue the New Paltz MBA most likely would have been better prepared for the real world by earning an undergraduate business degree elsewhere.


This is a real issue. MBA usually doesn’t make sense right out of school because you have to have at least some real life understanding about how the world works. Even with a better school reputation, I would be wary of hiring an MBA with zero working experience. And then when you consider the school…
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 19:23     Subject: Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

This is a poorly conceived idea.
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 17:56     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Will the effect of this joint effort be to cheapen both Vassar College degrees and MBA degrees ?

Several elite universities (U Chicago, Northwestern, U Michigan, Johns Hopkins, and others) offer nine-to-ten-month MIM (Masters in Management) degrees for recent college graduates with less than two years of post undergraduate work experience. Hundreds of universities offer certificate programs through continuing education arms that enable students to earn a certificate in business or in a specialty area in order to be better prepared for the working world. Some will even count credits earned in the one academic year masters in management program toward their MBA degree after the students get real world work experience and otherwise qualify for the school's MBA program.

Hopefully, someone with better sense will counsel Vassar College students and recent graduates of Vassar that getting a degree from an unranked, non-selective MBA program immediately after finishing an undergraduate liberal arts degree may be an unwise use of the graduate's time,money,and other resources.


Sigh. You guys really don’t get it, do you? All you think about is chasing rank determined by entities that desperately need you people to buy into their rankings to financially stay afloat.

For people into education you consistently miss the point of education.

I think it’s a great idea.


It is clear that you miss the point of earning an MBA degree.


Please explain it to me then.

But I’ll give you one great reason for MBA programs - it is for schools to make a sh!t load of money on another set of students coming back for another 2 years of overpriced education


OMG you must be associated with this venture between Vassar College and SUNY New Paltz.

Google: Why earn an MBA and please reread what I have written above.

Very little to be gained from an MBA experience for those without real world post undergraduate work experience.

FWIW The top MBA programs offer the most value in terms of career options within one's prior field or in an alternate field if one's experience has led them to seek such opportunities.

The program designed by Vassar College & SUNY New Paltz MBA is little more than continuing & supplementing one's insufficient undergraduate experience while sacrificing future options & opportunities by earning a virtually worthless degree from a substandard, unranked, non-selective program.


Huh? I’m basically saying colleges are over priced. I’m not associated with anything. But you are very married to the idea that this is a bad idea. Why do you care?

And I’ll remind you again that your focus on brand and rank is silly


Then why are posting on a thread regarding MBA programs as it is clear that you lack even a basic understanding of MBA programs ?

Is your purpose just a weird attempt to derail this thread ?
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 17:52     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Readers may find the list of 133 MBA programs ranked by US News to be of interest (SUNY-New Paltz is unranked). #61 CUNY-Baruch is a great bargain for New York residents at $16,130 per academic year. #73 Babson College is great for certain specialties such an Entrepreneurship.

A Vassar College grad with a few years of work experience and a decent standardized test score (GRE or GMAT) and a solid reason for wanting to attend an MBA program should have options within the top 30 or so MBA programs.

https://usnews.com/best-graduate-schools/top-business-schools/mba-rankings


Has the U Michigan undergrad accelerated MBA program always been considered elite? I know it is now, but was it 30 years ago?


Does U Michigan-Ross even offer a full-time, in-person, on-campus accelerated MBA program ?

Northwestern University-Kellogg offers lots of options including this accelerated part-time MBA program:

https://Kellogg.northwestern.edu/programs/part-time-mba/accelerated-option/
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 17:30     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Will the effect of this joint effort be to cheapen both Vassar College degrees and MBA degrees ?

Several elite universities (U Chicago, Northwestern, U Michigan, Johns Hopkins, and others) offer nine-to-ten-month MIM (Masters in Management) degrees for recent college graduates with less than two years of post undergraduate work experience. Hundreds of universities offer certificate programs through continuing education arms that enable students to earn a certificate in business or in a specialty area in order to be better prepared for the working world. Some will even count credits earned in the one academic year masters in management program toward their MBA degree after the students get real world work experience and otherwise qualify for the school's MBA program.

Hopefully, someone with better sense will counsel Vassar College students and recent graduates of Vassar that getting a degree from an unranked, non-selective MBA program immediately after finishing an undergraduate liberal arts degree may be an unwise use of the graduate's time,money,and other resources.


Sigh. You guys really don’t get it, do you? All you think about is chasing rank determined by entities that desperately need you people to buy into their rankings to financially stay afloat.

For people into education you consistently miss the point of education.

I think it’s a great idea.


It is clear that you miss the point of earning an MBA degree.


Please explain it to me then.

But I’ll give you one great reason for MBA programs - it is for schools to make a sh!t load of money on another set of students coming back for another 2 years of overpriced education


OMG you must be associated with this venture between Vassar College and SUNY New Paltz.

Google: Why earn an MBA and please reread what I have written above.

Very little to be gained from an MBA experience for those without real world post undergraduate work experience.

FWIW The top MBA programs offer the most value in terms of career options within one's prior field or in an alternate field if one's experience has led them to seek such opportunities.

The program designed by Vassar College & SUNY New Paltz MBA is little more than continuing & supplementing one's insufficient undergraduate experience while sacrificing future options & opportunities by earning a virtually worthless degree from a substandard, unranked, non-selective program.


Huh? I’m basically saying colleges are over priced. I’m not associated with anything. But you are very married to the idea that this is a bad idea. Why do you care?

And I’ll remind you again that your focus on brand and rank is silly


Again, it is clear that you have little to no knowledge of MBA programs and the purpose of MBA programs. Brand and rank opens doors which are unavailable to graduates of lower ranked and, especially, unranked programs such as SUNY-New Paltz. Do you really believe that top management consulting firms, elite tech firms, investment firms, or any type of firms whatsoever are recruiting SUNY-New Paltz MBAs ?
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 12:22     Subject: Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Vassar is a very prestigious school - yes, it is not Harvard or Williams or whatever else, but in the grand scheme of things, it is very hard to get into.

This degree would not be additive to a Vassar degree. It almost dilutes it. Perhaps it better allows a Vassar alum with a liberal arts degree to compete with a student elsewhere with more traditional business training. But if I were hiring, I would probably hire a graduate of this program to be a peer of someone with an undergrad degree, not an MBA.
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 11:59     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:Readers may find the list of 133 MBA programs ranked by US News to be of interest (SUNY-New Paltz is unranked). #61 CUNY-Baruch is a great bargain for New York residents at $16,130 per academic year. #73 Babson College is great for certain specialties such an Entrepreneurship.

A Vassar College grad with a few years of work experience and a decent standardized test score (GRE or GMAT) and a solid reason for wanting to attend an MBA program should have options within the top 30 or so MBA programs.

https://usnews.com/best-graduate-schools/top-business-schools/mba-rankings


Has the U Michigan undergrad accelerated MBA program always been considered elite? I know it is now, but was it 30 years ago?
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 11:56     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Will the effect of this joint effort be to cheapen both Vassar College degrees and MBA degrees ?

Several elite universities (U Chicago, Northwestern, U Michigan, Johns Hopkins, and others) offer nine-to-ten-month MIM (Masters in Management) degrees for recent college graduates with less than two years of post undergraduate work experience. Hundreds of universities offer certificate programs through continuing education arms that enable students to earn a certificate in business or in a specialty area in order to be better prepared for the working world. Some will even count credits earned in the one academic year masters in management program toward their MBA degree after the students get real world work experience and otherwise qualify for the school's MBA program.

Hopefully, someone with better sense will counsel Vassar College students and recent graduates of Vassar that getting a degree from an unranked, non-selective MBA program immediately after finishing an undergraduate liberal arts degree may be an unwise use of the graduate's time,money,and other resources.


Sigh. You guys really don’t get it, do you? All you think about is chasing rank determined by entities that desperately need you people to buy into their rankings to financially stay afloat.

For people into education you consistently miss the point of education.

I think it’s a great idea.


It is clear that you miss the point of earning an MBA degree.


Please explain it to me then.

But I’ll give you one great reason for MBA programs - it is for schools to make a sh!t load of money on another set of students coming back for another 2 years of overpriced education


OMG you must be associated with this venture between Vassar College and SUNY New Paltz.

Google: Why earn an MBA and please reread what I have written above.

Very little to be gained from an MBA experience for those without real world post undergraduate work experience.

FWIW The top MBA programs offer the most value in terms of career options within one's prior field or in an alternate field if one's experience has led them to seek such opportunities.

The program designed by Vassar College & SUNY New Paltz MBA is little more than continuing & supplementing one's insufficient undergraduate experience while sacrificing future options & opportunities by earning a virtually worthless degree from a substandard, unranked, non-selective program.


Huh? I’m basically saying colleges are over priced. I’m not associated with anything. But you are very married to the idea that this is a bad idea. Why do you care?

And I’ll remind you again that your focus on brand and rank is silly
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 11:00     Subject: Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

Anonymous wrote:Vassar wants/needs to attract more male undergrads (currently 65/35-ish ratio).


This has been a concern for decades. Persistent, consistent rumor--right or wrong--is that the typical Vassar male is short and non-binary.

Vassar College is a very liberal place for very liberal individuals. Application volume seems fine as does the selective rate of admissions. Haven't checked the retention rate recently, but it usually is quite good (around 94%/95%).
Anonymous
Post 09/18/2025 10:49     Subject: Re:Vassar / SUNY New Paltz Joint Errort To Cheapen MBA Degree

US News #31 University of Texas at Dallas Jindal MBA program & #34 SMU Dedman are solid MBA programs with great job placement. UT-Dallas is a steal for residents of Texas.

Many MBA programs do offer scholarships for highly qualified applicants. Everything is relative so what constitutes highly qualified for one particular MBA program may be just average for another, higher ranked MBA program.

To the folks at Vassar College & SUNY New Paltz MBA program: Please consider showing some care & respect for the Vassar College students; consider changing the MBA option to a certificate or to a few undergraduate business courses open for Vassar College students.