Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:........... If a MS kid excels in English, they won't need to study Latin to score high on the SAT verbal section eventually.
strangely enough, my 6th grade kid LOVES Latin and wants to continue it. I took Latin all the way through my private highschool (and ended up in a class of only 3 kids with a wonderful teacher). We all got 5s on the AP exam, but I also made a best friend for life who fortunately has ended up in the DC area and a teacher I talked to until the day she died. Kid has already read the Iliad and the Oddysey in English (I had read one, but not by 6th grade, and kid really loved the Classics teacher and the subject last year. So there may be other reasons for exposing kids to Latin.
Wonderful. He wants to continue with Latin, and can and will. Why not let him take AP Latin as early as 8th grade if he wants? But let others have a choice, let respect for the high-achieving individual prevail in the language acquisition sphere at BASIS, and in other areas. A control freak undercurrent in the curriculum nonpluses some of us, including parents of excellent students.
BASIS students who excel at French, Spanish, Arabic, Russian, Chinese etc. shouldn't have to study Latin, or any other language, to reach for the stars academically. MoCo understands this, explaining why they don't force MS students in public programs to take language classes. Language study is voluntary before HS in MoCo, yet the county's International Baccalaureate language exam scores are among country's highest. Really.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Pp, you're ridiculous. Do you really think the kids coming from dcps have a foundation in any language? My kid was a product of Brent's weekly mandarin classes. She learned next to nothing in those years. The quality of instruction was lacking, to say the least. We're very happy that Basis requires Latin for two years, and they do a great job of it..
Don't get why BASIS requires Latin. What would be wrong with making Latin optional, while teaching Spanish, Chinese, maybe French to families who would prefer kids to learn those languages from 5th grade, particularly those who come in with serious background for whatever reasons? Sure, kids aren't coming in from DCPS with strong language foundations en masse, now. But if a kid starts weekly Spanish in PreK3 (as at Brent this year) and continues through 5th grade, they're likely to learn a certain amount of Spanish, particularly if families supplement.
There has been for a while a class for kids who come from native or almost native french speaking families I think (we had two kids in MS place #4 and #6 in the nation in some competition last year) but honestly if you have really learned a language, not studying it for two years will not do untold damage. What I hope for eventually (but we would have to get our Latino population up there) is a Spanish class for native speakers who can already speak the language but don't know how to read and write it and what is slang and what is not......
Anonymous wrote:........... If a MS kid excels in English, they won't need to study Latin to score high on the SAT verbal section eventually.
strangely enough, my 6th grade kid LOVES Latin and wants to continue it. I took Latin all the way through my private highschool (and ended up in a class of only 3 kids with a wonderful teacher). We all got 5s on the AP exam, but I also made a best friend for life who fortunately has ended up in the DC area and a teacher I talked to until the day she died. Kid has already read the Iliad and the Oddysey in English (I had read one, but not by 6th grade, and kid really loved the Classics teacher and the subject last year. So there may be other reasons for exposing kids to Latin.
Anonymous wrote:I disagree. IMO a couple of the PPs are being very unconstructive by venting here and/ or 'warning' others about vague issues and supposed retribution. There are better, more direct ways to raise concerns - with the school administration of the management organization who are the only ones who can change anything. I've done it more than once, respectfully, and my kids grades didn't change and the treatment of my family was fine.
If the retaliatory things being alleged (grade manipulation, unfounded calls to CFS) are happening those parents should leave. Vote with your feet. It sends a strong signal to others. Most important staying is bad for the kids. Period.
As for the supposed cell phone cheating - BASIS has a policy that cell phones are to be kept in lockers during the day. Do you want kids frisked daily to make sure they aren't on their person? Before tests? Just before a trip to the bathroom on a test day? Or maybe they shouldn't be allowed to go to the bathroom during a test? Any of the above will raise howls of civil rights violations and a culture of distrus within days on this board.