Anonymous wrote:From TV: Katharine McPhee in Smash. She’s cute, personable, and has a decent voice, but put her next to incredibly talented Broadway stars, in a role where she’s supposed to have some undefinable “x factor” and it just ends up looking silly. Broadway performers are ridiculously talented.

I really wanted that show to work and she wasn’t the only reason it didn’t but her miscasting was a big part of it.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Worst ever? As in I can't watch this part of the movie and it's ruined for me? Andie McDowell 3 Weddings and a Funeral. No question. Such a shame.

Yes, THANK YOU. Can't stand her in general, but this was the worst. "Is it still raining? I hadn't noticed." Ugh.

To be fair, that's the writing. I can't think of anyone who could pull that crap off. This is the same guy that had Julia Roberts say, "I'm just a girl, standing in front of a boy, asking him to love her."

But if it's any comfort, she wasn't first on anyone's list for the role:

The original choice for the role of Carrie was Jeanne Tripplehorn, but she had to drop out because of a death in her family.[10] Marisa Tomei and, reportedly, Sarah Jessica Parker, were also considered before Andie MacDowell was cast.[7] MacDowell took a 75% cut in her fee to appear, receiving $250,000 upfront, but due to the success of the film, she earned around $3 million.[11]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Weddings_and_a_Funeral

Andie MacDowell has said that she never understood complaints about the infamous rain scene at the end of 1994’s Four Weddings and a Funeral.

The scene, which features a climactic kiss in the pouring rain between MacDowell’s Carrie and Hugh Grant’s Charlie, is capped by Carrie asking, “Is it raining? I hadn’t noticed."

It has often been voted one of the worst lines of dialogue in film history.

“Honestly, I really don’t get why the rain scene is regarded as such a big deal,” MacDowell told The Guardian. “It’s beautiful and we were freezing filming it.”

“But I imagine even Richard is surprised that that one line has got so much attention,” she continued, referencing the film’s screenwriter Richard Curtis.

“When the film came out there were absolutely no complaints, everybody loved it. The complaints and comments all happened years later.”

Anonymous wrote:Kiera knightly in Bend it Like Beckham. Nobody on planet earth would buy that girl as a footballer.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:
I’m surprised no one has said Leo in Titanic. He was too young and it always slightly ruined the movie for me. Not believable.



I know. By the time the water started pouring in I was hoping his character would die sooner rather than later.

Funny...I always thought Kate Winslet, though lovely, looked too old for this part. His character was meant to be young and boyish.

Anonymous wrote:15 pages and nobody said Jodie Foster and Mel Gibson in that stupid western?

^^^
That was the most ridiculous casting ever.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So glad I'm not the only one who hated Four Weddings and a Funeral.

No one watched that movie for anything other than hot Hugh Grant, and the hot guy who played the deaf brother. Everyone realized at the time that Andie MacDowell was awful and it was amazing she ever got another acting role. She seems like a nice person, though, from interviews.

I LOVE that movie but hate Andie’s character and performance. Awful miscasting. I do love how unattractive they had to make Kristen Scott Thomas so that audiences wouldn’t ship her and Hugh Grant more.

Similarly, Bill Pullman in While You Were Sleeping. There’s no way Sandra Bullock’s character would have found him remotely attractive. He was an a$$ to her.

Anonymous wrote:Shut your mouth about Forest Gump. And I hate Tom Hanks but that is an epic. I find that that there is extreme overlap in the Venn of men that love The Godfather and Shawshank.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It's AVATAR THE LAST AIR BENDER, NOT THE OTHER AVATAR.

Wait. There’s more than one Avatar movie?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Keanu Reeves in Dracula was, from start to finish, the most laughably bad performance I've seen in 55 years of watching movies.

Yes and no. Terrible, yes, but that whole movie was a damn train wreck. The only reason my sister and I stayed is because one of our teachers was on a date a few rows in front of us and we wanted to see how THAT would end.

Anonymous wrote:It's AVATAR THE LAST AIR BENDER, NOT THE OTHER AVATAR.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Kevin Costner in anything

Wrong. Loved "Dances with Wolves".

Good God. I can't decide which was worse--his terrible acting or terrible directing.

Yeah, it only won seven Oscars, with another five nominations. What garbage.

But please, do tell us more. You're really putting that B- you got in the Intro to Film Studies class you took 25 years ago to good use.

Oh please. Goodfellas losing the Oscar to Dances with Wolves is one of the most embarrassing awards in Oscar history.

I’ll see you this and raise you Brokeback Mountain losing to Crash.