Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Saw a theory elsewhere that Ryan is the dad and John killed Erin to protect him (they have a secret after all and it’s not an affair). Billy helped dispose of the body and was bothered at the get together when Lori and John talked about adopting DJ.

I think the show takes place in 2019 so could be true or John is dad and Ryan killed Erin when he found out. And then John and Billy helped dispose of body.

I did wonder if the gun was Mare’s dad’s especially when the therapist asked if anyone had been up in the attic since her son died. She wouldn’t know if it’s missing.

Should be an interesting final episode. I agree that Ryan is involved, even if he just knows some of what happened.

I’d like to find out what Lori knows, because the second scene where she and John are talking about Billy’s “confession” starts partway through a conversation. What did John tell her before the scene starts? There’s a lot of talk of protecting the family. It could be that they’re protecting Ryan instead of John but still making Billy the scapegoat.

Anonymous wrote:Saw a theory elsewhere that Ryan is the dad and John killed Erin to protect him (they have a secret after all and it’s not an affair). Billy helped dispose of the body and was bothered at the get together when Lori and John talked about adopting DJ.

I think the show takes place in 2019 so could be true or John is dad and Ryan killed Erin when he found out. And then John and Billy helped dispose of body.

I did wonder if the gun was Mare’s dad’s especially when the therapist asked if anyone had been up in the attic since her son died. She wouldn’t know if it’s missing.

Anonymous wrote:DNA testing would definitely tell which of the men was the father and which was close relation - ie. uncle etc

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Anyone think that Billy killed Erin to protect John?

I think John is the dad. Did they say how Erin died in a press conference? Dylan said she was shot in the face. Wonder if that was public.

John says to Lori "Billy has confessed to killing Erin and he is Dj's dad"

So.. No. Don't think your theory holds, sadly.

But would a paternity test differentiate between 2 brothers?

I was wondering the same.

In the scene where John confronts Billy he is pushing (drunk) Billy to confess to him, and even supplies the words he needs to hear. When John tells Billy that their father saw Billy in bloody clothes the night of the murder, John says “what am I going to do?” When he talks to his wife about Billy’s confession he begs her not to tell Mare for the good of their family. He doesn’t say anything about the baby or who the father is.

All of this makes me think that John is taking advantage of the fact that Billy is a drunk to manipulate him (maybe even frame him for the murder), and that John is the father. I think Billy was too drunk to remember what happened that night.

I think this is exactly it.

Same

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Anyone think that Billy killed Erin to protect John?

I think John is the dad. Did they say how Erin died in a press conference? Dylan said she was shot in the face. Wonder if that was public.

John says to Lori "Billy has confessed to killing Erin and he is Dj's dad"

So.. No. Don't think your theory holds, sadly.

But would a paternity test differentiate between 2 brothers?

I was wondering the same.

In the scene where John confronts Billy he is pushing (drunk) Billy to confess to him, and even supplies the words he needs to hear. When John tells Billy that their father saw Billy in bloody clothes the night of the murder, John says “what am I going to do?” When he talks to his wife about Billy’s confession he begs her not to tell Mare for the good of their family. He doesn’t say anything about the baby or who the father is.

All of this makes me think that John is taking advantage of the fact that Billy is a drunk to manipulate him (maybe even frame him for the murder), and that John is the father. I think Billy was too drunk to remember what happened that night.

I think this is exactly it.

Anonymous wrote:Maybe this week's episode will clarify things-- I love this show but the brothers everyone is referring to are unclear to me, so I must not be paying enough attention (sleepy when watching)

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Anyone think that Billy killed Erin to protect John?

I think John is the dad. Did they say how Erin died in a press conference? Dylan said she was shot in the face. Wonder if that was public.

John says to Lori "Billy has confessed to killing Erin and he is Dj's dad"

So.. No. Don't think your theory holds, sadly.

What? I didn’t see that scene.

+1
Did this happen?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Anyone think that Billy killed Erin to protect John?

I think John is the dad. Did they say how Erin died in a press conference? Dylan said she was shot in the face. Wonder if that was public.

John says to Lori "Billy has confessed to killing Erin and he is Dj's dad"

So.. No. Don't think your theory holds, sadly.

But would a paternity test differentiate between 2 brothers?

I was wondering the same.

In the scene where John confronts Billy he is pushing (drunk) Billy to confess to him, and even supplies the words he needs to hear. When John tells Billy that their father saw Billy in bloody clothes the night of the murder, John says “what am I going to do?” When he talks to his wife about Billy’s confession he begs her not to tell Mare for the good of their family. He doesn’t say anything about the baby or who the father is.

All of this makes me think that John is taking advantage of the fact that Billy is a drunk to manipulate him (maybe even frame him for the murder), and that John is the father. I think Billy was too drunk to remember what happened that night.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Anyone think that Billy killed Erin to protect John?

I think John is the dad. Did they say how Erin died in a press conference? Dylan said she was shot in the face. Wonder if that was public.

John says to Lori "Billy has confessed to killing Erin and he is Dj's dad"

So.. No. Don't think your theory holds, sadly.

But would a paternity test differentiate between 2 brothers?

I was wondering the same.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Anyone think that Billy killed Erin to protect John?

I think John is the dad. Did they say how Erin died in a press conference? Dylan said she was shot in the face. Wonder if that was public.

John says to Lori "Billy has confessed to killing Erin and he is Dj's dad"

So.. No. Don't think your theory holds, sadly.

What? I didn’t see that scene.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Can someone explain why it’s somehow cool for Mare’s daughter to have sex with someone in college while she’s in high school and the woman in college is seen as a positive character? Have you ever seen a college aged young man portrayed as anything less than a creep for having sex with a high school aged girl?

Well clearly the daughter is a senior. I don't think a HS senior and a college student is considered a big deal.

Example: Bring it on. Boyfriend is a jerk, but not considered inappropriate.