Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 13:38     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:TJ has the most number of NMSF in the country!


That maybe but not by % of kids. Not even in DMV area. Looks like RMIB magnet is 1, Blair is 2 (assuming some of the 41 kids are CAP students) and TJ at 3.


TJ is number 1 with 36.2%
Blair science is number 2 with 31%
RM IB number is unknown.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 13:35     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:TJ has the most number of NMSF in the country!


That maybe but not by % of kids. Not even in DMV area. Looks like RMIB magnet is 1, Blair is 2 (assuming some of the 41 kids are CAP students) and TJ at 3.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 13:32     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
TJ has the most number of NMSF in the country!
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 13:27     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The reason TJ has a high number is because Fairfax county put all their top kids in one school.


Actually, even with an exceptionally strong magnet like TJ, McLean and Madison in FCPS each had more NMSF this year than BCC, Whitman and Churchill, and McLean had more than Wootton as well. So it seems like an exaggeration to say that Fairfax is putting all its eggs in one basket.


Yes.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 13:26     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:^ that's why RM/IB is considered the most rigorous hs program in dc area.


Not all the semifinalists at Blair were in the magnet, although most were.


That is why 41 includes CAP students and non-magnet Blair students. What is the NMSF for Blair science magnet only?
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:59     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:^ that's why RM/IB is considered the most rigorous hs program in dc area.


Go Rockets!!
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:53     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Maryland is number 1!
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:46     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:So we are comparing the top Asian and Jewish kids in MC and VA. Why not compare the Hispanic or African American scores. Who is improving the most for them.


I don't think posters are saying anything about the race. People just having harmless bragging shouting match. Not sure what your point is.

Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:43     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I count 41 students at each not 31.

http://connectedcommunities.us/showthread.php?t=72292#winners

I don't blame you for not understanding as MCPS as a variety of magnets at different locations focused on different items. It's a complex web that can't be easily compared to the Fairfax model of dropping all the kids in one school. Also, MCPS has NMSF from W schools that are not magnets at all. Yes, by Fairfax putting all the smart kids in one spot you can claim number one, but when it comes to applying to colleges the MCPS model with the kids spread out is better. IMHO


Keep in mind, TJ kids are from all over NOVA, not just Fairfax

Arlington County
Fairfax County (includes City of Fairfax)
Falls Church City
Loudoun County
Prince William County

So you are comparing kids from 5 different districts to one (MCPS)


Actually,kids at Blair only come from the southern half of Montgomery County. It's worse


Good point. Only from 1/2 county.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:43     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
So we are comparing the top Asian and Jewish kids in MC and VA. Why not compare the Hispanic or African American scores. Who is improving the most for them.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:40     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I count 41 students at each not 31.

http://connectedcommunities.us/showthread.php?t=72292#winners

I don't blame you for not understanding as MCPS as a variety of magnets at different locations focused on different items. It's a complex web that can't be easily compared to the Fairfax model of dropping all the kids in one school. Also, MCPS has NMSF from W schools that are not magnets at all. Yes, by Fairfax putting all the smart kids in one spot you can claim number one, but when it comes to applying to colleges the MCPS model with the kids spread out is better. IMHO


Keep in mind, TJ kids are from all over NOVA, not just Fairfax

Arlington County
Fairfax County (includes City of Fairfax)
Falls Church City
Loudoun County
Prince William County

So you are comparing kids from 5 different districts to one (MCPS)


Actually,kids at Blair only come from the southern half of Montgomery County. It's worse
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:40     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:^ that's why RM/IB is considered the most rigorous hs program in dc area.


Not all the semifinalists at Blair were in the magnet, although most were.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:39     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
^ that's why RM/IB is considered the most rigorous hs program in dc area.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:36     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:163 out of 500 = 32.6%
41/100 = 41% at Blair
41/100 = 41% at RMIB


To me, that's the most impressive number! Almost 10% higher than so called #1 school in the country.
Anonymous
Post 09/09/2015 12:36     Subject: National Merit Semifinalist Cut-off Scores for High School Class of 2016
Anonymous wrote:The reason TJ has a high number is because Fairfax county put all their top kids in one school.


Actually, even with an exceptionally strong magnet like TJ, McLean and Madison in FCPS each had more NMSF this year than BCC, Whitman and Churchill, and McLean had more than Wootton as well. So it seems like an exaggeration to say that Fairfax is putting all its eggs in one basket.