Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This thread is so stupid. Seriously what’s the point of it?
I actually think it's super interesting
My in-laws: Northwestern. FIL was a sports admit
Their kids: Harvard, Princeton, Brown, Yale, Cornell, Tufts. All sports.
One of them introduced me to his brother 40 years ago at a game where they were playing each other.
Of all my sisters and brothers in law, only one of their kids (my kids' cousins, there are 18 of them) is now going to their own parent's alma mater
I think it interesting because it is a window into social mobility, albeit merely anecdotal and difficult to draw firm conclusions.
If anything, I detect a strain that going to high value schools (someone mentioned the SUNY schools as an example) combined with diligence, make a lot of sense. Some of the so-called prestige schools attract very bright people. They would succeed in many environments.
One can achieve social mobility without college. But the stats don't support it generally. I went to a so-called prestige school, but on athletic scholarship. For me, just going to a decent college (may parents did not go to any college) enabled me to mature, engage in time management, and set priorities. These are valuable skills and four years in the scholastic world gave me the opportunity and space to develop them.
I observed it harder to obtain a degree in terms of requirements and volume at my twin brother's high quality state flagship. A multiple NCAA All American, he had significantly more requirements than I did at my private school. Not sure either was harder or easier on balance, but it was an equally challenging experience for him. He went on to be a well known Econometrics PHD, and his public school served him well, obtaining beyond generational wealth and living a full intellectual life (he passed away a year ago).
i understand those who claim college should not be solely about social mobility. But for poor kids like my brother and me, it always loomed large in our minds. Getting it done on our own and without debt changed us.
Anonymous wrote:This tells me how white this forum is. Only one post with HBCUs in a DC forum is crazy.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I see a ton of downward mobility in these posts (Almost all Ivies/Duke/Stanford do not have Ivy kids or have Cornell kids at most).
I think this is 3 fold from observing the kids at our private school:
1)Kids who grow up around money/success do not feel the pressure/panic to achieve the same.
2)Highly successful people do not have the time to manage their kids. Getting kids into HYPDS generally takes some degree of micro management AT SOME POINT in high school. Very few HYPS level kids are completely self driven from ages 14-18.
3)Intelligence reverts to the mean? Not sure if this is true or not but it kind of holds true for some families I know.
4) college admissions at top schools are way harder now
than a generation ago
Anonymous wrote:I see a ton of downward mobility in these posts (Almost all Ivies/Duke/Stanford do not have Ivy kids or have Cornell kids at most).
I think this is 3 fold from observing the kids at our private school:
1)Kids who grow up around money/success do not feel the pressure/panic to achieve the same.
2)Highly successful people do not have the time to manage their kids. Getting kids into HYPDS generally takes some degree of micro management AT SOME POINT in high school. Very few HYPS level kids are completely self driven from ages 14-18.
3)Intelligence reverts to the mean? Not sure if this is true or not but it kind of holds true for some families I know.
Anonymous wrote:This tells me how white this forum is. Only one post with HBCUs in a DC forum is crazy.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This thread is so stupid. Seriously what’s the point of it?
I actually think it's super interesting
My in-laws: Northwestern. FIL was a sports admit
Their kids: Harvard, Princeton, Brown, Yale, Cornell, Tufts. All sports.
One of them introduced me to his brother 40 years ago at a game where they were playing each other.
Of all my sisters and brothers in law, only one of their kids (my kids' cousins, there are 18 of them) is now going to their own parent's alma mater
Anonymous wrote:This tells me how white this forum is. Only one post with HBCUs in a DC forum is crazy.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This thread is so stupid. Seriously what’s the point of it?
Seriously, what’s the point of you writing or reading the thread? Empower yourself, and begone.
Explain the point of it. Why is it interesting?