Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 11:57     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Kiera but it’s a close one.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 11:56     Subject: Re:Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Colin Firth. I can’t even watch the other one, the dialogue is wrong and they look awful.
So Colin Firth version. The best of the bests


They "look awful"? Lol


Yes. The guy who plays Darcy in the KK one is fugly. And KK is too flat.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 11:50     Subject: Re:Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:Colin Firth. I can’t even watch the other one, the dialogue is wrong and they look awful.
So Colin Firth version. The best of the bests


They "look awful"? Lol
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 09:52     Subject: Re:Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
The 1980 BBC miniseries with David Rintoul as Darcy is the best.
Then, the 1995 one with Colin Firth as Darcy is a close second
Then, the 2005 movie is a distant third.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 06:13     Subject: Re:Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Colin Firth. I can’t even watch the other one, the dialogue is wrong and they look awful.
So Colin Firth version. The best of the bests
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 06:10     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:Op again.

Let’s see if there’s an age demographic driving this.

I’m 49, and I prefer the Keira version. It’s beautifully filmed. The music is lovely. The acting feels more authentic. And the chemistry is smoldering.

The Firth version is a cross between watching a play (stilted; feels obviously fake and stuffy) and Little House on the Prairie (modern actors struggling to pull off the costumes and dialogue). Plus, no chemistry. The best acting in this version is Lydia—she’s a natural.


I’m 48 and I much prefer Colin Firth. I can’t stand Kiera as Elizabeth.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 05:37     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Idk that I can pick. I like a lot better about the KK one (filming, many of the actors) but I prefer Colin Firth himself in the Darcy role and don't think he could be topped.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 02:30     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Spinoff... which is a better Emma? Haven't watched either Gwenyth or the BBC one all the way through before and don't fully know the story, so I want the best one to watch


The BBC miniseries


I preferred Gwyneth and the cast of that version.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 01:33     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:Spinoff... which is a better Emma? Haven't watched either Gwenyth or the BBC one all the way through before and don't fully know the story, so I want the best one to watch


The BBC miniseries
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 01:22     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Also—for Austen heads, I strongly recommend the Anya Taylor Joy Emma.


I hated that movie precisely because it did such a good job at revealing how awful Emma's behavior was. Gosh I hated her and I couldn't get behind the redemption.


I hated her as Emma.

The best Emma is in the 2009 BBC miniseries version.

Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 01:17     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:I’m a 36 year old English major who has read and reread Austen. I prefer the 2005 version—one of my favorites that I just adore. I can see the authenticity complaints, but I don’t “feel” them. I appreciate but do not love the BBC version. I think Jennifer Ehle is too old. And though I understand and find somewhat persuasive claim that Lizzie is SUPPOSED to be judgmental, I don’t think she’s supposed to actually be older than 21. I think Keira Knightley conveys the judgmental nature of youth well. I’m not at all persuaded that the 995 Jane is a beauty according to Edwardian standards, and even if she is I don’t think it makes it a better movie. I prefer MM’s awkward, ardent Darcy.


Another English major. 100% agree.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 01:12     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The “pretty” sister in the Firth version really isn’t pretty.


She's pretty for 1813!


It’s distracting having Jane not be beautiful since everyone is always commenting on her beauty.


Agree.
Anonymous
Post 05/09/2025 01:10     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:I prefer Keira Knigthley as Eliaabeth. Jennifer Ehle seemed too old. It's a toss up as to which Mr Darcy is better, I like both.


I agree.

If I had a time machine, it would be Colin Firth and Kiera Knightly transported to the same set at the age each filmed their respective versions.
Anonymous
Post 05/08/2025 22:11     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
Anonymous wrote:The 2005 version will leave Netflix at the end of the month. I’d never seen it, due to friends who claimed that the 1995 version was superior. Dang. The chemistry was amazing. Team 2005 all the way! I’ll be folding laundry in front of it all month.


It's one of my favorite Jane Austen films! I also love the 1995 version of Persuasion.
Anonymous
Post 05/08/2025 14:06     Subject: Quick poll on Pride and Prejudice
The 2005 version will leave Netflix at the end of the month. I’d never seen it, due to friends who claimed that the 1995 version was superior. Dang. The chemistry was amazing. Team 2005 all the way! I’ll be folding laundry in front of it all month.