Anonymous
02/18/2023 22:33
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:4.52 / 4.0 GPA
1440 SAT
IB Diploma candidate FCPS
2 3-year varsity sports
Waitlisted at VA Tech Engineering
Accepted UVA and JMU
Tech is his first choice
Hoping to get off the waitlist
Does your son have any extracurriculars that are related to engineering?
A few years ago my nephew was also accepted at UVA and rejected by Tech engineering
The only reason as to why that we could think of is that he didn’t have any engineering/stem related activities.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 21:43
Subject: VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:If rejected/waitlisted, what other schools did your kid apply to? Where have they been accepted?
WVU - Accepted
Penn State Main Campus - Accepted
VCU - Accepted
ODU - Accepted
Drexel - Accepted
GMU - Accepted
JMU - Accepted
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:22
Subject: VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Many high stats kids do want VT because of the in state cost savings. It’s not okay to yield protect in state kids.
Then apply ED and stop complaining.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:22
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please list stats — curious about the couple pps with sons and thought tech was a match and kids rejected.
I’ll be in this spot in a year.
Deferred with 4.0UW/4.5W/1570 and 13 APs or post-APs.
That is nuts. Where else did they apply?
This kid doesn’t want to go to VT . Kids / parents just want to feel proud oh my Larla got into 10/10 schools. VT has figured this out.
Precisely this. Why does no one complain when W&M does exactly the same thing? If you don't apply ED, you have a much lower chance of getting in. Why? Because they know you're not their first choice. Makes sense to me.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:21
Subject: VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:(I’ve posted earlier in this thread. Not sure why I’m so engaged by this.)
Losing in-state high achievers who truly want VT seems wrong. Accepting more first gen state residents seems right. Yield from acceptances to VT is relatively low. How do they get this right if they are clearly not first choice for so many of the people “shocked” not to get in?
Agree with previous poster: there’s no advantage in driving away in-state high achievers who do want to attend.
What process solves this?
ED solves this. High stats kids who *really* want to go to VT should apply ED. Those complaining about rejections did not.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:19
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please list stats — curious about the couple pps with sons and thought tech was a match and kids rejected.
I’ll be in this spot in a year.
Deferred with 4.0UW/4.5W/1570 and 13 APs or post-APs.
That is nuts. Where else did they apply?
Princeton, Harvard, Hopkins, Duke, UVA, bunch of others. VT was lowest ranked school. Already in at several higher ranked schools. If you are high stats and want VT, better go ED and show tons of interest.
In state? Engineering? Yield protection? But, UGH!
Yes, in state engineering. Feels like yield protection but no way to tell for sure.
Seems like no other explanation. But also don’t understand why VT would bother to engage in such a practice.
It doesn’t. This is just something people tell themselves to alleviate bruised egos.
I don't think it's ego to assume that a VA kid with these stats should be accepted to VT. 4.0UW/4.5W/1570 and 13 APs
DP. Of course it is. As a PP said, your student obviously wasn't going to go to VT, and I'm sure that was obvious to them. They didn't apply ED, either. Why are they owed an acceptance?
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:17
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please list stats — curious about the couple pps with sons and thought tech was a match and kids rejected.
I’ll be in this spot in a year.
Deferred with 4.0UW/4.5W/1570 and 13 APs or post-APs.
That is nuts. Where else did they apply?
Princeton, Harvard, Hopkins, Duke, UVA, bunch of others. VT was lowest ranked school. Already in at several higher ranked schools. If you are high stats and want VT, better go ED and show tons of interest.
Couldn’t this be yield protection? And wouldn’t they be right? You don’t actually want VT.
Exactly. We constantly hear that W&M heavily favors those who apply ED because they want kids who want them. Well, the same principle applies here.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:16
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please list stats — curious about the couple pps with sons and thought tech was a match and kids rejected.
I’ll be in this spot in a year.
Deferred with 4.0UW/4.5W/1570 and 13 APs or post-APs.
That is nuts. Where else did they apply?
Princeton, Harvard, Hopkins, Duke, UVA, bunch of others. VT was lowest ranked school. Already in at several higher ranked schools. If you are high stats and want VT, better go ED and show tons of interest.
In state? Engineering? Yield protection? But, UGH!
Yes, in state engineering. Feels like yield protection but no way to tell for sure.
Seems like no other explanation. But also don’t understand why VT would bother to engage in such a practice.
Agreed. Not bitter but it seems silly. State school should accept the top in state applicants and not guess whether or not they may go elsewhere.
UVA does this too, especially if you don't apply ED - as does W&M and many other schools. Weird how the complaining is always about VT doing this.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:15
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
4.52 / 4.0 GPA
1440 SAT
IB Diploma candidate FCPS
2 3-year varsity sports
Waitlisted at VA Tech Engineering
Accepted UVA and JMU
Tech is his first choice
Hoping to get off the waitlist
1440 SAT
IB Diploma candidate FCPS
2 3-year varsity sports
Waitlisted at VA Tech Engineering
Accepted UVA and JMU
Tech is his first choice
Hoping to get off the waitlist
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:14
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Please list stats — curious about the couple pps with sons and thought tech was a match and kids rejected.
I’ll be in this spot in a year.
Deferred with 4.0UW/4.5W/1570 and 13 APs or post-APs.
That is nuts. Where else did they apply?
Princeton, Harvard, Hopkins, Duke, UVA, bunch of others. VT was lowest ranked school. Already in at several higher ranked schools. If you are high stats and want VT, better go ED and show tons of interest.
In state? Engineering? Yield protection? But, UGH!
Yes, in state engineering. Feels like yield protection but no way to tell for sure.
Seems like no other explanation. But also don’t understand why VT would bother to engage in such a practice.
DP. They also have an incredibly competitive applicant pool from which to choose. Not sure why some parents choose to ignore that fact and just claim "yield protection" when their kid isn't admitted.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:10
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Please list stats — curious about the couple pps with sons and thought tech was a match and kids rejected.
I’ll be in this spot in a year.
If your child really wants to attend VT, have them apply ED. You can't expect to be accepted just because you think the school is a match.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:09
Subject: VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Tech was supposed to be a match for DS, but he was rejected. Anyone else in the same boat? Still waiting to hear from a few schools and accepted to a few, some with merit.
On the bright side, Blacksburg is remote and not near anywhere. I went there back in the day. Will be happy to have DS closer to home.
I’m sorry for your kid- but remote and not near anywhere? That was not true when DH and I went there in the 90s and it’s even more built up now!
I also went there in the ‘90’s. Tech is a great school and a fun place to be a student, but Blacksburg is far. It’s not close to any big job centers for internships and the like.
And yet, all the big companies/agencies come to Blacksburg to recruit. Internships usually take place in the summer.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:07
Subject: VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Tech was supposed to be a match for DS, but he was rejected. Anyone else in the same boat? Still waiting to hear from a few schools and accepted to a few, some with merit.
On the bright side, Blacksburg is remote and not near anywhere. I went there back in the day. Will be happy to have DS closer to home.
I’m sorry for your kid- but remote and not near anywhere? That was not true when DH and I went there in the 90s and it’s even more built up now!
+1
It may be four hours from NoVa, but so are many other schools. Blacksburg is a cute little town, nearby is larger Christiansburg, less than an hour away is Roanoke, and the surrounding New River Valley is gorgeous.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:03
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:No one (except the one pp's DD's URM bf) admitted below 4.0? (lowest I've seen accepted so far is 4.2)
DD accepted. TO, 3.97 GPA. Business. IB and AP courses.
I don’t think she thought she’d get in. Was accepted at JMU, I think she feels conflicted. Wants to be closer to home. Any advice??
DS got into both last year and chose JMU with no hesitation. It felt like home to him and he's had a great year so far, academically and socially. I'd suggest you attend both admitted student days if you can.
DP. I have kids at both VT and JMU and they both love their respective schools. Either one is a great option.
Anonymous
02/18/2023 20:02
Subject: Re:VT this Friday?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:No one (except the one pp's DD's URM bf) admitted below 4.0? (lowest I've seen accepted so far is 4.2)
DD accepted. TO, 3.97 GPA. Business. IB and AP courses.
I don’t think she thought she’d get in. Was accepted at JMU, I think she feels conflicted. Wants to be closer to home. Any advice??
TECH all the way! It has better nationwide recognition an more options. And, come on...hokie nation!! Enter Sandman...
I can honestly say this because I went to Tech as an undergrad and then got a stipend to go to JMU for grad school and transferred out after a year. Not a fan. I have a nephew who is a senior at JMU now and it is such a party school now, insanely so. He can't wait until graduation. He's done.
From this area, there are so many kids to ride home with and always a carpool seat available.
Kid at JMU who is not a partier. JMU is no different from any other college which has students who want to party. Some do and some don’t.
+1
Exactly this.