Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 13:54     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.


Not really. Past classes have been stronger. The range of matriculations was more top 20 heavy compared to now.

Other all-girls in the area have done just as well, if not better this cycle. Visi and SR are strong this year. The Co-Ed’s = very impressive.

Either other schools have upped their college counseling, or Holton is lackluster. But still a great school.


I love it when ppl talk without looking at the data

If you go back and examine the Holton over the past 5 years, you will see that the proportion of girls going to the above schools is basically the same.

If you want to compare with Stone Ridge, please do so carefully. The SR Insta page has 92 out of 93 commits. Out of 93 girls, only 3 are going to the top schools mentioned above (that’s less than 5 percent of the graduating class). And 2 of 3 are athletes.


I’ve been watching this results quite closely for many years. Have friends kids that went to several of these schools, including Holton.

Again, reading is fundamental.

I shared that either other schools have upped their game and are now posting just as strong, if not stronger results than Holton this year, or Holton’s results appear more lackluster than the past.

Visi had another very strong year. And SJC— wow. Look at the arts matriculations—Berkeley and Julliard. SR has typically been a range lower than Holton, but I think that they did fine.

Madeira; Sidwell. I’ll stop there.

Holton used to stand apart a lot more in the past. Not so much anymore.


Look, let me first say that I am not a fan of the HOS, and I am concerned about the number of great teachers leaving.

That said, there is a difference between your impressions (based on anecdotes) and the actual data. The latter show that college admission outcomes this year are in line with Holton’s performance in previous years. As a parent, I have been tracking the actual data for many years too.



With the number of teachers leaving, this will have seismic effects a year or two down the road. HA was already behind the DC schools and this is not helping.


I fully agree that there would be damage down the road. But let me push back on the dramatic statement that HA is behind other schools.

Here are this year’s college admissions results from some of the schools mentioned above.

Based on Insta posts and Claude’s analysis (which took 5 mins), the proportion of students going to T20 schools (USNWR) is as follows:

Holton Arms: 30 percent (30 out of 99)
NCS: 31 percent (21 out of 68)
GDS: 25 percent (29 out of 115)
Madeira: 19 percent (11 out of 58)
Visi: 20 percent (21 out of 107)
Stone Ridge: 12 percent (11 out of 93)

The corresponding proportions for Ivy+ schools are as follows:

Holton Arms: 17 percent (17 out of 99, 2 athletes)
NCS: 25 percent (17 out of 68, 4 athletes)
GDS: 17 percent (19 out of 115)
Madeira: 12 percent (7 out of 58)
Visi: 7 percent (7 out of 107, 3 athletes)
Stone Ridge: 3 percent (3 out of 93, 2 athletes)

Note that NCS has more recruited athletes this year.



Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 13:10     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.


Not really. Past classes have been stronger. The range of matriculations was more top 20 heavy compared to now.

Other all-girls in the area have done just as well, if not better this cycle. Visi and SR are strong this year. The Co-Ed’s = very impressive.

Either other schools have upped their college counseling, or Holton is lackluster. But still a great school.


I love it when ppl talk without looking at the data

If you go back and examine the Holton over the past 5 years, you will see that the proportion of girls going to the above schools is basically the same.

If you want to compare with Stone Ridge, please do so carefully. The SR Insta page has 92 out of 93 commits. Out of 93 girls, only 3 are going to the top schools mentioned above (that’s less than 5 percent of the graduating class). And 2 of 3 are athletes.


I’ve been watching this results quite closely for many years. Have friends kids that went to several of these schools, including Holton.

Again, reading is fundamental.

I shared that either other schools have upped their game and are now posting just as strong, if not stronger results than Holton this year, or Holton’s results appear more lackluster than the past.

Visi had another very strong year. And SJC— wow. Look at the arts matriculations—Berkeley and Julliard. SR has typically been a range lower than Holton, but I think that they did fine.

Madeira; Sidwell. I’ll stop there.

Holton used to stand apart a lot more in the past. Not so much anymore.


Look, let me first say that I am not a fan of the HOS, and I am concerned about the number of great teachers leaving.

That said, there is a difference between your impressions (based on anecdotes) and the actual data. The latter show that college admission outcomes this year are in line with Holton’s performance in previous years. As a parent, I have been tracking the actual data for many years too.



With the number of teachers leaving, this will have seismic effects a year or two down the road. HA was already behind the DC schools and this is not helping.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:46     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.


Not really. Past classes have been stronger. The range of matriculations was more top 20 heavy compared to now.

Other all-girls in the area have done just as well, if not better this cycle. Visi and SR are strong this year. The Co-Ed’s = very impressive.

Either other schools have upped their college counseling, or Holton is lackluster. But still a great school.


I love it when ppl talk without looking at the data

If you go back and examine the Holton over the past 5 years, you will see that the proportion of girls going to the above schools is basically the same.

If you want to compare with Stone Ridge, please do so carefully. The SR Insta page has 92 out of 93 commits. Out of 93 girls, only 3 are going to the top schools mentioned above (that’s less than 5 percent of the graduating class). And 2 of 3 are athletes.


I’ve been watching this results quite closely for many years. Have friends kids that went to several of these schools, including Holton.

Again, reading is fundamental.

I shared that either other schools have upped their game and are now posting just as strong, if not stronger results than Holton this year, or Holton’s results appear more lackluster than the past.

Visi had another very strong year. And SJC— wow. Look at the arts matriculations—Berkeley and Julliard. SR has typically been a range lower than Holton, but I think that they did fine.

Madeira; Sidwell. I’ll stop there.

Holton used to stand apart a lot more in the past. Not so much anymore.


Look, let me first say that I am not a fan of the HOS, and I am concerned about the number of great teachers leaving.

That said, there is a difference between your impressions (based on anecdotes) and the actual data. The latter show that college admission outcomes this year are in line with Holton’s performance in previous years. As a parent, I have been tracking the actual data for many years too.

Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:36     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

“Berklee”. Auto correct keeps changing my words
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:35     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.


Not really. Past classes have been stronger. The range of matriculations was more top 20 heavy compared to now.

Other all-girls in the area have done just as well, if not better this cycle. Visi and SR are strong this year. The Co-Ed’s = very impressive.

Either other schools have upped their college counseling, or Holton is lackluster. But still a great school.


I love it when ppl talk without looking at the data

If you go back and examine the Holton over the past 5 years, you will see that the proportion of girls going to the above schools is basically the same.

If you want to compare with Stone Ridge, please do so carefully. The SR Insta page has 92 out of 93 commits. Out of 93 girls, only 3 are going to the top schools mentioned above (that’s less than 5 percent of the graduating class). And 2 of 3 are athletes.


I’ve been watching this results quite closely for many years. Have friends kids that went to several of these schools, including Holton.

Again, reading is fundamental.

I shared that either other schools have upped their game and are now posting just as strong, if not stronger results than Holton this year, or Holton’s results appear more lackluster than the past.

Visi had another very strong year. And SJC— wow. Look at the arts matriculations—Berkeley and Julliard. SR has typically been a range lower than Holton, but I think that they did fine.

Madeira; Sidwell. I’ll stop there.

Holton used to stand apart a lot more in the past. Not so much anymore.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:29     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

HA's PR person has chimed in to clear up any data points. Nice!

But back to the point of the thread: Why is everyone leaving?

Do not contact the Board. They will protect Penny--as they should.

Do not contact Penny. She will say what she must to protect her $400K + bonus salary--as she should.

Do what I and other parents have done: Contact your DD's advisor and/or teachers. It is they who impact her education. It is they who will write her letters of recommendation. It is they who will prepare her for university work. It is they who will model the values we expect of our children.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:21     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.


Not really. Past classes have been stronger. The range of matriculations was more top 20 heavy compared to now.

Other all-girls in the area have done just as well, if not better this cycle. Visi and SR are strong this year. The Co-Ed’s = very impressive.

Either other schools have upped their college counseling, or Holton is lackluster. But still a great school.


I love it when ppl talk without looking at the data

If you go back and examine the Holton over the past 5 years, you will see that the proportion of girls going to the above schools is basically the same.

If you want to compare with Stone Ridge, please do so carefully. The SR Insta page has 92 out of 93 commits. Out of 93 girls, only 3 are going to the top schools mentioned above (that’s less than 5 percent of the graduating class). And 2 of 3 are athletes.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:16     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.


That is not good. Are we talking titanic effect? We better jump ship while our DD is in MS.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:07     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.


Not really. Past classes have been stronger. The range of matriculations was more top 20 heavy compared to now.

Other all-girls in the area have done just as well, if not better this cycle. Visi and SR are strong this year. The Co-Ed’s = very impressive.

Either other schools have upped their college counseling, or Holton is lackluster. But still a great school.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 12:06     Subject: Re:Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:I’m not a HA parent (or in any way affiliated with the school) but I have 3 kids in a k-8 so we are exploring area schools as we begin to think about high school. My oldest is a girl so HA is on our list to look at.

While this is anecdotal, multiple parents of girl at my DC’s school have mentioned issues with the Holton HOS, and I have now heard from 3 other sources about problems with the HOS, teachers morale, and teachers leaving (not DCUM, people associated with the school).

While the parents I know personally of girls who go all seem very happy with the school (all in lower or middle school), hearing concerns from so many sources has put Holton near the bottom of our list of schools to consider for DD. There are plenty of schools in this area that don’t have these concerns that we would rather focus on. I have heard at least 2 other parents in DD’s cohort say something similar - Holton seems like a bad risk right now. Even if my DD ends up applying, we are very reluctant to send her if we have another option.

I know the DCUM response will be to tell me that HA doesn’t need my DD/ she wouldn’t get in anyway/ my family is terrible, etc, etc. However, if what I am seeing in my small world is also the same conversation happening elsewhere, the quality of students at Holton will decline as their application pool decreases, even if they meet enrollment.


Making school decisions based on DCUM. Not a good idea.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 11:50     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Anonymous wrote:Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.


The college admission results are almost identical to previous years (about 20 percent of girls going to HYPSM, Duke, UChicago, UPenn, Cornell, Brown, Northwestern). This year’s class was very strong academically. But, compared with previous years, there were very few athletes going to top schools.

The impact on college admissions will take awhile to play out.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 11:41     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

Not a HA parent. But in looking at the college matriculations for this cycle, something appeared off. It’s not the HA of even a few years ago.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 10:54     Subject: Re:Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

I’m not a HA parent (or in any way affiliated with the school) but I have 3 kids in a k-8 so we are exploring area schools as we begin to think about high school. My oldest is a girl so HA is on our list to look at.

While this is anecdotal, multiple parents of girl at my DC’s school have mentioned issues with the Holton HOS, and I have now heard from 3 other sources about problems with the HOS, teachers morale, and teachers leaving (not DCUM, people associated with the school).

While the parents I know personally of girls who go all seem very happy with the school (all in lower or middle school), hearing concerns from so many sources has put Holton near the bottom of our list of schools to consider for DD. There are plenty of schools in this area that don’t have these concerns that we would rather focus on. I have heard at least 2 other parents in DD’s cohort say something similar - Holton seems like a bad risk right now. Even if my DD ends up applying, we are very reluctant to send her if we have another option.

I know the DCUM response will be to tell me that HA doesn’t need my DD/ she wouldn’t get in anyway/ my family is terrible, etc, etc. However, if what I am seeing in my small world is also the same conversation happening elsewhere, the quality of students at Holton will decline as their application pool decreases, even if they meet enrollment.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 10:45     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

How does this issue affect our student college admissions outcomes? With so many teachers leaving, we wonder if this is going to affect the quality of education and HS. This is worrisome.
Anonymous
Post 05/26/2026 09:51     Subject: Why is everyone at Holton-Arms leaving?

An anonymous board will change nothing about this school….and neither will speaking the truth out loud. And that’s ok. It’s ok if this school wants to change and a new leader takes it in a different direction. Schools, people, places evolve.

In addition to the above mentioned departures, the head of admissions is leaving after 20+ years, the new comms director is leaving at the end of this year too. Both to be replaced by internal hires.