Anonymous wrote:What does everyone think will happen now that the manner of death has been announced?

Her lawyer was on the news stating that he wants the murder charges dropped.

Those poor babies. I don't know if Catherine admitting what she did to a friend will give the kids father closure but I hope so.

Got a link?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Any theories about why she didn’t also kill the oldest child?

She didn’t have the third child with her at the time that she had the opportunity

I wonder how he is doing.

What does everyone think will happen now that the manner of death has been announced?

Her lawyer was on the news stating that he wants the murder charges dropped.

Those poor babies. I don't know if Catherine admitting what she did to a friend will give the kids father closure but I hope so.

I know the Aunt of the Hoggle children as she lived on my street. She said Catherine was very cold, calculating and had a lot of problems beforehand. They should have never left her home with the kids and honestly, she should have been living in a facility from the things that I was told. CPS should have been involved through the time she had the kids as well so there was documentation of the kids’ conditions (cleanliness, attention, meeting milestones). Sarah and Jacob were failed by the same awful system that failed those three beautiful girls who were killed by their father and the 9yo girl in NY killed by her father. So much sadness in this world and it does not have to be. Instead of worrying about wars that aren’t ours and people that do not belong here, we need to invest in worrying about Americans who are struggling and the mentally ill that live amongst us.

Anonymous wrote:Any theories about why she didn’t also kill the oldest child?

She didn’t have the third child with her at the time that she had the opportunity

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Catherine Hoggle was released from Perkins in late July and just charged in Montgomery County with the murder of the children.

I'm sorry I don't know how to link the article but it's from Moco show.

She was found to be incompetent to stand trial nine times. I wonder what will be different this time.

The kids would be 13 and 15 now.

She’s been malingering and I hope there’s documented proof of that now so she can stand trial.

The woman is mentally ill. I find it appalling how little sympathy people have for her. It's the fault of the family who were supposed to make sure the kids were not left alone with her. If this had happened today, her DH and her parents would be held accountable. I findi it sickening that her DH wants her in jail. She is insane. How is that her fault?

She is mentally ill, but she is not insane.

She knew what she did was wrong and that’s why she hid it. If she was truly insane, she would’ve killed the children right in front of her father.

Even if you’re mentally ill, you should be held accountable for your crimes.

If you are insane, then you go to a mental hospital.

She is a very intelligent, cold and calculated human who knows exactly what she did and she knows that was wrong and she needs to go to jail for it.

Do you think the Idaho guy should go to jail for killing all those people in that house?

That's a crazy assumption you just made -- because she didn't kill her children in front of their father, she should be held accountable as a sane person. We don't even know what happened to those children. One thing we DO know is that the mother is mentally ill.

Oh well. She should not be free to walk the streets. It’s good that she was charged again.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Catherine Hoggle was released from Perkins in late July and just charged in Montgomery County with the murder of the children.

I'm sorry I don't know how to link the article but it's from Moco show.

She was found to be incompetent to stand trial nine times. I wonder what will be different this time.

The kids would be 13 and 15 now.

She’s been malingering and I hope there’s documented proof of that now so she can stand trial.

The woman is mentally ill. I find it appalling how little sympathy people have for her. It's the fault of the family who were supposed to make sure the kids were not left alone with her. If this had happened today, her DH and her parents would be held accountable. I findi it sickening that her DH wants her in jail. She is insane. How is that her fault?

She is mentally ill, but she is not insane.

She knew what she did was wrong and that’s why she hid it. If she was truly insane, she would’ve killed the children right in front of her father.

Even if you’re mentally ill, you should be held accountable for your crimes.

If you are insane, then you go to a mental hospital.

She is a very intelligent, cold and calculated human who knows exactly what she did and she knows that was wrong and she needs to go to jail for it.

Do you think the Idaho guy should go to jail for killing all those people in that house?

That's a crazy assumption you just made -- because she didn't kill her children in front of their father, she should be held accountable as a sane person. We don't even know what happened to those children. One thing we DO know is that the mother is mentally ill.

Any theories about why she didn’t also kill the oldest child?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Catherine Hoggle was released from Perkins in late July and just charged in Montgomery County with the murder of the children.

I'm sorry I don't know how to link the article but it's from Moco show.

She was found to be incompetent to stand trial nine times. I wonder what will be different this time.

The kids would be 13 and 15 now.

She’s been malingering and I hope there’s documented proof of that now so she can stand trial.

The woman is mentally ill. I find it appalling how little sympathy people have for her. It's the fault of the family who were supposed to make sure the kids were not left alone with her. If this had happened today, her DH and her parents would be held accountable. I findi it sickening that her DH wants her in jail. She is insane. How is that her fault?

I have no sympathy for her. I have tremendous sympathy for someone like Andrea Yates.

I hope she goes to jail for the rest of her life.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Catherine Hoggle was released from Perkins in late July and just charged in Montgomery County with the murder of the children.

I'm sorry I don't know how to link the article but it's from Moco show.

She was found to be incompetent to stand trial nine times. I wonder what will be different this time.

The kids would be 13 and 15 now.

She’s been malingering and I hope there’s documented proof of that now so she can stand trial.

The woman is mentally ill. I find it appalling how little sympathy people have for her. It's the fault of the family who were supposed to make sure the kids were not left alone with her. If this had happened today, her DH and her parents would be held accountable. I findi it sickening that her DH wants her in jail. She is insane. How is that her fault?

I agree with you.

This did not have to be.
The father and her parents are completely complicit here.

Two things can be true at once.

Her father was responsible for her that day, and he let her be alone with the children. He and only he is responsible and should be charged.

The husband was at work and the father and only the father was responsible for her during this time.

AND she killed them. And while she should not have been alone with them, she was not insane. She was mentally ill. She knew what she was doing, and she could’ve stopped herself. She stopped herself from doing it in front of her father so she’s not completely insane.

It was planned she did two kids separately. This was not a fit of rage or a psychosis.

She needs to be charged and her father needs to be charged.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Catherine Hoggle was released from Perkins in late July and just charged in Montgomery County with the murder of the children.

I'm sorry I don't know how to link the article but it's from Moco show.

She was found to be incompetent to stand trial nine times. I wonder what will be different this time.

The kids would be 13 and 15 now.

She’s been malingering and I hope there’s documented proof of that now so she can stand trial.

The woman is mentally ill. I find it appalling how little sympathy people have for her. It's the fault of the family who were supposed to make sure the kids were not left alone with her. If this had happened today, her DH and her parents would be held accountable. I findi it sickening that her DH wants her in jail. She is insane. How is that her fault?

I agree with you.

This did not have to be.
The father and her parents are completely complicit here.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This is a horrific story when one reads the timeline those children were let down by every single so called adult

Any remaining children should have been removed from the dads care. Grandma and grandpa unfit as well.

The court ordered she not be alone with those kids shame on all of them

Nobody but Catherine Hoggle killed those children. Blaming family members who were trying their best to manage the situation is not helpful. I'm guessing that you have never had to deal with an adult family member with serious mental illness. It is easy to judge. Spend your time praying you are never in the position to have to provide support for seriously mental ill adult.

Do we know what she did with the bodies? How did she kill them ? (are we sure it wasn’t accidental).

Were the poor kids ever found?

No
We don't know
No

We do not know what she did with them

However every stop gap failed here her parents and her X .
It is horrifying her family and him had these kids this did not have to be .

They had no idea the daughter was missing?.. BS that means they are complicit as well,

By the time she took the boy red flags should have been seen.

No there is no way this was accidental. She killed one and came back for the other to do the same which she did

No they won’t be found alive .

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This is a horrific story when one reads the timeline those children were let down by every single so called adult

Any remaining children should have been removed from the dads care. Grandma and grandpa unfit as well.

The court ordered she not be alone with those kids shame on all of them

Nobody but Catherine Hoggle killed those children. Blaming family members who were trying their best to manage the situation is not helpful. I'm guessing that you have never had to deal with an adult family member with serious mental illness. It is easy to judge. Spend your time praying you are never in the position to have to provide support for seriously mental ill adult.

Do we know what she did with the bodies? How did she kill them ? (are we sure it wasn’t accidental).

Were the poor kids ever found?

No
We don't know
No

Actually

She put them in dumpsters and the bodies are in the moco dump.
Idk
No

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Catherine Hoggle was released from Perkins in late July and just charged in Montgomery County with the murder of the children.

I'm sorry I don't know how to link the article but it's from Moco show.

She was found to be incompetent to stand trial nine times. I wonder what will be different this time.

The kids would be 13 and 15 now.

She’s been malingering and I hope there’s documented proof of that now so she can stand trial.

The woman is mentally ill. I find it appalling how little sympathy people have for her. It's the fault of the family who were supposed to make sure the kids were not left alone with her. If this had happened today, her DH and her parents would be held accountable. I findi it sickening that her DH wants her in jail. She is insane. How is that her fault?

She is mentally ill, but she is not insane.

She knew what she did was wrong and that’s why she hid it. If she was truly insane, she would’ve killed the children right in front of her father.

Even if you’re mentally ill, you should be held accountable for your crimes.

If you are insane, then you go to a mental hospital.

She is a very intelligent, cold and calculated human who knows exactly what she did and she knows that was wrong and she needs to go to jail for it.

Do you think the Idaho guy should go to jail for killing all those people in that house?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Catherine Hoggle was released from Perkins in late July and just charged in Montgomery County with the murder of the children.

I'm sorry I don't know how to link the article but it's from Moco show.

She was found to be incompetent to stand trial nine times. I wonder what will be different this time.

The kids would be 13 and 15 now.

She’s been malingering and I hope there’s documented proof of that now so she can stand trial.

This