Anonymous wrote:Are single parents a rarity at STA?
Anonymous wrote:I can't believe someone reactivated a 2008 thread . . .
Anonymous wrote:To add to the previous comment; hardly anyone knows who is actually on financial aid. One home address is not the sole factor in overall wealth, and not all full pay families live in large homes in upscale neighborhoods.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:11:22 I did not write the post I agreed with it. It was thoughtful and honest.
You need to read it again and this time less defensively. The message was that some believe STA is a magic carpet ride to the Ivies. There are some harsh realities about a school with quite a few talented and ambitious students. And yes not all of the teachers are superb. Teacher quality varies everywhere, less so at STA but that is not a criticism it is an observation. Your defensiveness is silly.
Not 11:22 but I was curious and re-read the original post. It seemed quite harsh, with lines like "your son will be squeezed like a sponge" and "Good teaching is just not guaranteed at STA. In fact, if your son gets the wrong teachers, it can undermine his transcript and his college options."
You may think that sort of language is "not critical but observational" but it seems pretty critical to me. (And whenever people blame specific teachers for a college outcome, as that poster seemed to be doing, it's a red flag to me.)
No doubt everyone is bored by this parsing of the original post, by now, but fwiw I disagree with your interpretation of it.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Tell me about what happens during the student/parent visit, please.
The boys go off in a small group of about six, with a faculty member, and the parents go off in a small group wiht one of the admissions staff for a tour of the school. I recall some parents' being obviously competitive and trying to say impressive things, other parents' asking very nitpicky questions. Afterwards, I asked my son what they had done in their group, and he said they had just sat around and talked. Did you say anything, I asked. No, he said, not a word, the whole time! Oh, no, I thought. But he did get accepted after all.
Better manners.
It also becomes clear during these interviews which boys were prompted by their parents to volunteer to say things to try to appear engaged and bright. Such a tactic tends to backfire, as those doing the evaluating figure either the parents or the boys or both are insufferable.
It's still mostly (as in overwhelmingly) about grades, recommendations, test scores and essays. The admissions staff and faculty know that parents and kids can be awkward when over eager and plenty of allowances are made.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Tell me about what happens during the student/parent visit, please.
The boys go off in a small group of about six, with a faculty member, and the parents go off in a small group wiht one of the admissions staff for a tour of the school. I recall some parents' being obviously competitive and trying to say impressive things, other parents' asking very nitpicky questions. Afterwards, I asked my son what they had done in their group, and he said they had just sat around and talked. Did you say anything, I asked. No, he said, not a word, the whole time! Oh, no, I thought. But he did get accepted after all.
Better manners.
It also becomes clear during these interviews which boys were prompted by their parents to volunteer to say things to try to appear engaged and bright. Such a tactic tends to backfire, as those doing the evaluating figure either the parents or the boys or both are insufferable.