Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Has anyone noticed that Randall opens two different doors when going to see Rebecca in her bed? One is a heavy duty metal push latch that you push on to release, like in a hospital ward and the other is a nickel colored door handle that you would see in a house. I think we are seeing two different scenes.

The hospital one I believe is a flashback to his youth when Rebecca was in the hospital.

I am the one that noticed his hair is much grayer as he walks to the door. His hair has barely any gray in some scenes from the cabin. I think one is Rebecca’s death and the other is Kate. Especially when Toby ask if she is ok with him being there. But he should be there to support his kids being there. Also, someone else noticed the walls to the door are different. This series is very specific with their details so I think it’s done on purpose.

I don’t think tonight’s episode will tell us who Kevin chooses based on his comments to Randall at the end of last week’s episode. I suspect we won’t know until the final episode.

I just rewatched this. I'm not sure why I am so obsessed with this mystery but here we are.

The door at Kevin's house is surrounded by a textured wall with some windows. You can't see the doorknob.

Then you see him opening a door surrounded by a flat tan wall. That doorknob is a horizontal silver handle. You never actually see him open that door.

Then there is the young Randall clearly in a hospital and you see young Randall open an industrial style hospital door.

But there is also this very short clip of adult Randall opening an industrial style hospital door and walking into a room -- it's blurry - but it looks like Rebecca in a bed, but isn't very sterile/hospital-ish.

Here's the clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXu_Py6gydc in case someone else wants to help solve this mystery with me.

Unless they're really screwed up the doors, I do think this is two deaths. We know the scene at Kevin's house takes place when his twins are about 12. Perhaps Rebecca is not in Kevin's house at all. Maybe everyone is gathering at Kevin's house to see someone else who is sick or dying. I thought maybe Kate, but we know she lives past this scene. Maybe it's Madison. When Randall says, "where is -" Beth says, "he's already in there." And we assume that's Nicky because he's at Rebecca's bedside. But maybe it's Elijah.

And the Rebecca death scene is taking place in a hospice somewhere, because we see the more industrial doorknob when Randall opens the door and walks in. And the only scenes we've seen of Rebecca's death are Randall walking into the room and saying hi mom, it's me Randall - your son and saying hello to Nicky. You can see windows behind Randall which make it seem like it's Kevin's house but they don't line up with the view we had before. However, it is not the industrial style doorknob behind him; it's a lever handle doorknob (but this doesn't line up with the lever dooorknob you see previously because there were no windows to the side of the door).

Bad continuity??

Anonymous wrote:I'm desperately trying to see how people are assuming multiple death bed scenes. Randall's hair seems consistent to me between the kitchen and door scenes. The doorknob seems consistent. Mayyyybe the walls are questionable but that's an easy continuity error depending on the set. And when he asked "where is..." and the answer is "already in there"...remember that this scene is from when we didn't even know Rebecca was in the room, so they were holding back on even the fact that Nicky was there.

I'm all for a conspiracy theory but no matter how many times I watch it I can't see it another way.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Has anyone noticed that Randall opens two different doors when going to see Rebecca in her bed? One is a heavy duty metal push latch that you push on to release, like in a hospital ward and the other is a nickel colored door handle that you would see in a house. I think we are seeing two different scenes.

Yes, was discussed many, many pages back.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Has anyone noticed that Randall opens two different doors when going to see Rebecca in her bed? One is a heavy duty metal push latch that you push on to release, like in a hospital ward and the other is a nickel colored door handle that you would see in a house. I think we are seeing two different scenes.

The hospital one I believe is a flashback to his youth when Rebecca was in the hospital.

I am the one that noticed his hair is much grayer as he walks to the door. His hair has barely any gray in some scenes from the cabin. I think one is Rebecca’s death and the other is Kate. Especially when Toby ask if she is ok with him being there. But he should be there to support his kids being there. Also, someone else noticed the walls to the door are different. This series is very specific with their details so I think it’s done on purpose.

I don’t think tonight’s episode will tell us who Kevin chooses based on his comments to Randall at the end of last week’s episode. I suspect we won’t know until the final episode.

Anonymous wrote:Has anyone noticed that Randall opens two different doors when going to see Rebecca in her bed? One is a heavy duty metal push latch that you push on to release, like in a hospital ward and the other is a nickel colored door handle that you would see in a house. I think we are seeing two different scenes.

Anonymous wrote:Has anyone noticed that Randall opens two different doors when going to see Rebecca in her bed? One is a heavy duty metal push latch that you push on to release, like in a hospital ward and the other is a nickel colored door handle that you would see in a house. I think we are seeing two different scenes.

Anonymous wrote:Has anyone noticed that Randall opens two different doors when going to see Rebecca in her bed? One is a heavy duty metal push latch that you push on to release, like in a hospital ward and the other is a nickel colored door handle that you would see in a house. I think we are seeing two different scenes.

Anonymous wrote:I rewatched the flash-forward death scene on YouTube and noticed Kevin has many awards displayed on a shelf in his house. I wonder if he becomes a celebrated actor, or whether he turns to building homes and wins awards for that.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm not getting the Elijah-hate. Madison is clearly so happy and in love with him - it's not going to be Madison/Kevin. It's going to be Sophie. The stupidest thing was bringing in the random wedding singer as a possible third choice. Seriously??

I don't understand how they're going to tie all of this up in just a few more episodes. We still haven't seen how Rebecca and Miguel reconnect and start dating.

I don’t get why they keep showing how comfortable Madison and Kevin are together AND she’s very in tuned to his feelings, thoughts, etc. Possible mis-direction or show they really are the ones for each other.

The other problem with this show,is how great all the ex’s are with each other. “Let me teach you American football”, all the advice Kevin gave to Elijah. Etc. Very seldom happens.

I think they are trying to keep us guessing. It has turned into a mini Bachelorette.

+1 And the way that characters within the show keep referencing it is annoying.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm not getting the Elijah-hate. Madison is clearly so happy and in love with him - it's not going to be Madison/Kevin. It's going to be Sophie. The stupidest thing was bringing in the random wedding singer as a possible third choice. Seriously??

I don't understand how they're going to tie all of this up in just a few more episodes. We still haven't seen how Rebecca and Miguel reconnect and start dating.

I don’t get why they keep showing how comfortable Madison and Kevin are together AND she’s very in tuned to his feelings, thoughts, etc. Possible mis-direction or show they really are the ones for each other.

The other problem with this show,is how great all the ex’s are with each other. “Let me teach you American football”, all the advice Kevin gave to Elijah. Etc. Very seldom happens.

I think they are trying to keep us guessing. It has turned into a mini Bachelorette.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm not getting the Elijah-hate. Madison is clearly so happy and in love with him - it's not going to be Madison/Kevin. It's going to be Sophie. The stupidest thing was bringing in the random wedding singer as a possible third choice. Seriously??

I don't understand how they're going to tie all of this up in just a few more episodes. We still haven't seen how Rebecca and Miguel reconnect and start dating.

I don’t get why they keep showing how comfortable Madison and Kevin are together AND she’s very in tuned to his feelings, thoughts, etc. Possible mis-direction or show they really are the ones for each other.

The other problem with this show,is how great all the ex’s are with each other. “Let me teach you American football”, all the advice Kevin gave to Elijah. Etc. Very seldom happens.